Global alliance for phasing out coal not fit for purpose, says NGO

Powering Past Coal Alliance accused of failing to follow up on pledges as many countries expand use of coal

An attempt by the UK government to encourage countries and businesses around the world to quit coal for power generation is failing to make an impact, and in danger of being used as “greenwash”, an assessment has found.

The Powering Past Coal Alliance, led by the UK and Canada, with 111 members including 24 governments, local governments and businesses, is a key plank of Boris Johnson’s strategy for vital UN climate talks to be hosted in Glasgow in November.

Members are required to show they are on a pathway to eliminating coal-fired power plants before 2030 in the case of developed countries, and 2050 for developing states, to meet the goals of the Paris climate agreement.

But the NGO Reclaim Finance has found that some members, including the UK and Canada, are continuing to expand the use of coal, in ways that will increase greenhouse gas emissions and could help to bust the global carbon budget.

coal emissions chart

Paul Schreiber, the author of the report from Reclaim Finance, said: “The PPCA may be well-intentioned, but it is not fit for purpose. It could be helpful, if done right, but today it is not helpful [to global carbon reductions]. Members are not following up on their pledges. It serves as a greenwashing engine for financial institutions.”

He said there were loopholes in the alliance’s requirements. For instance, Canada is continuing to develop scores of new coalmines, which will be used to export coal for use in power plants in other countries, despite remaining within the rules by planning to phase out coal domestically.

Schreiber also pointed to the UK’s plans for a new coalmine, which is subject to a public inquiry. Ministers argued it should be allowed under the PPCA rules as it would produce coking coal for steel-making, even though the exported coal would increase emissions overseas and could delay the take-up of low-carbon steel-making.

There is also poor enforcement of the existing requirements. Germany has set a coal phase-out date of 2038, well beyond the deadline for developed countries. Mexico is building two coal-fired power plants, and major new coal investments, while Senegal is also considering coal expansion.

A UK government spokesperson said: “The UK is leading the world in tackling climate change and phasing out coal, having gone over 5,000 hours without using coal for electricity last year. As part of this commitment, we launched the Powering Past Coal Alliance along with the Canadian government to advance the transition from unabated coal power electricity generation.

“We intend to bring forward our target to eliminate all coal-fired power stations to October 2024, which could mean that in 10 years, the UK would have reduced its reliance on coal for electricity from around a third to zero.”

Some business members of the alliance were also continuing to back coal in various forms, the report found. The US pension fund Calpers had about $8bn invested in coal, according to the latest data available, from September 2019, and the investment house Schroders had more than $5bn in such investments.

coal consumption interactive

A spokesperson for Calpers said: “We invest in companies which use coal, and are through Climate Action 100+, driving towards the net zero goal.”

A Schroders spokesperson said: “Our membership of the PPCA reflects our concern about the threat climate change poses and the view that the coal industry in particular is at the forefront of that climate challenge. It’s clear that global greenhouse gas emissions must decline, which will require structural changes in many of the most exposed companies.

“We have engaged with these companies and many across the sector extensively over a number of years on their climate change ambitions and strategies and continue to believe that our, and our industry’s, influence and voice will be an important driver of the changes needed in the global energy market.”

Schreiber called for the loopholes in the PPCA declaration to be closed, and for its deadlines on coal phase-out to be brought forward, in line with scientific advice, to target a global elimination of coal-fired power by 2040.


Fiona Harvey Environment correspondent

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Almost half of thermal coal firms set to defy climate pledge – report
Report identifies 935 firms finance industry needs to blacklist to meet Paris goals

Jillian Ambrose Energy correspondent

12, Nov, 2020 @8:01 AM

Article image
‘Reckless’: G20 states subsidised fossil fuels by $3tn since 2015, says report
Support for coal, oil and gas remains high despite pledges to tackle climate crisis

Damian Carrington Environment editor

20, Jul, 2021 @10:00 AM

Article image
UK banks’ support for coal industry has risen since 2015 Paris climate pact
Lenders including Barclays and HSBC provided services and loans worth £21.9bn in 2019

Jasper Jolly and Kalyeena Makortoff

03, May, 2021 @11:01 PM

Article image
Last hope over climate crisis requires end to coal, says Alok Sharma
President-designate of Cop26 talks says tackling the fossil fuel is ‘a personal priority’

Fiona Harvey Environment correspondent

14, May, 2021 @5:00 AM

Article image
Can Poland wean itself off coal?
Climate experts say the renaissance can be stopped but change must happen now – and the main obstacle is at the top

Jonathan Watts in Katowice

14, Dec, 2018 @1:21 PM

Article image
US clean power plan setback 'will not affect Paris climate change deal'
Politicians, businesses and campaigners from other countries rally to support Barack Obama after supreme court puts US flagship climate plan on hold

Fiona Harvey and Suzanne Goldenberg

10, Feb, 2016 @5:27 PM

Article image
World Bank says Paris climate goals at risk from new coal schemes
Jim Yong Kim says slowing down growth in coal-fired power stations is essential in order to reduce emissions

Larry Elliott in Washington

09, Oct, 2016 @11:43 AM

Article image
Biden’s pledge to slash US emissions turns spotlight on China
World leaders will be unable to halt climate breakdown without strong action from biggest emitter

Fiona Harvey Environment correspondent

23, Apr, 2021 @5:31 PM

Article image
Coal lobby boss says industry 'will be hated like slave-traders' after COP21
The head of Europe’s coal lobbying association says his industry will be vilified following the landmark Paris climate deal to cap CO2 emissions

Arthur Neslen in Brussels

15, Dec, 2015 @2:09 PM

Article image
Richest nations agree to end support for coal production overseas
G7 countries reaffirm commitment to limit global heating to 1.5C after nearly two days of wrangling

Fiona Harvey Environment correspondent

21, May, 2021 @3:17 PM