M&S cuts soya from production of milk to curb deforestation

UK retailer worked with dairy farms to end use of destructive cattle feed, but critics say move could ‘shift problem elsewhere’

UK retailer Marks & Spencer has eliminated soya from the production of all its milk as part of its commitment to end deforestation in its supply chain.

The high street chain says it has worked with the 44 British farmers producing M&S RSPCA Assured milk to replace soya feed with alternatives such as rapeseed oil and sugar beet – avoiding the use of nearly 4,000 tonnes of soya each year. The retailer sells an estimated 160m pints of milk in its UK stores and through Ocado annually.

The move – to be officially announced on Thursday – is a milestone in progress towards the retailer’s goal of zero deforestation in the production of all its products, including food and drink, as it continues to find ways of providing more sustainable animal feed across its wider supply chain.

Last year, M&S was among several UK supermarkets, including Tesco, that admitted, after a Guardian investigation, that they could not guarantee that soya from deforested areas was not present in their supply chains – despite making firm commitments to phase out its use.

Soya is one of the global commodities most closely associated with deforestation, along with palm oil, beef, timber and paper, and it is the second largest driver of deforestation, according to the charity WWF.

The bean is widely used in food production, mainly as animal feed. Brazil is one of the world’s leading producers and growing demand for soya has led to deforestation in regions such as the Amazon and the Cerrado tropical savannah.

M&S’s move is part of the company’s innovation programme, which includes a strong focus on diversification of feed away from soya, exploring alternative proteins and different feed formulations. The company plans to expand its work in this area over the coming months.

Paul Willgoss, M&S director of food technology, said: “Soya is widely used in animal feed across the industry because it’s fast-growing and protein-rich, but we’re all aware of the devastating impact its use is having on Brazilian forests.

“Our absolute priority is to eliminate deforestation from the production of our products and to get there, we’re looking at both reducing our reliance on soya and finding more responsible ways of sourcing it. We’re proud of the team’s hard work to move 100% of the animal feed in our milk supply chain to high-performing soya alternatives.”

Environmental campaigners claim that substituting other crops for soya in the feed mix may simply be shifting the problem elsewhere and that land use rather than soya itself is the main issue. Direct emissions of gases from cows – such as methane – add to the climate impact of dairy milk production.

Anna Jones, head of forests at Greepeace UK, said: “M&S committed to remove commodity-driven deforestation from its supply chains by 2020 and removing soya from its dairy supply chain is a big step, since the crop is a leading driver of deforestation. However, what’s vital to understand is that the underlying problem of deforestation is the amount of land being used to grow crops like soya to use as animal feed for meat and dairy.

“Switching soya for other crops in the animal feed mix and selling meat and dairy at the same or even greater volumes will just shift that land use problem elsewhere. Our health, the stability of the climate and the future of the world’s forests depends on us eating less meat and dairy, meaning what supermarkets must urgently do is to begin replacing them with plant-based options.”

Sign up for the Animals farmed monthly update to get a roundup of the best farming and food stories across the world and keep up with our investigations. You can send us your stories and thoughts at animalsfarmed@theguardian.com


Rebecca Smithers

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Walmart selling beef from firm linked to Amazon deforestation
Exclusive: US chains Walmart, Costco and Kroger selling Brazilian beef produced by JBS linked to destruction of Brazilian rainforest

Andrew Wasley and Alexandra Heal

13, Feb, 2021 @7:00 AM

Article image
Less windy Whoppers? Low-methane Burger King still involves some hot air
Lemongrass-fed cows mean more sustainable burgers, says the fast-food chain – but experts say there’s more work to be done

Sarah Mock

22, Jul, 2020 @9:59 AM

Article image
Livestock industry lobbying UN to support more meat production
Meat and dairy groups threaten to stop contributing to international summit on food sustainability after critical voices invited

Sophie Kevany

21, Sep, 2021 @5:00 AM

Article image
Animals farmed: UK supply chain crisis, meat plant workers exploited and Billie Eilish’s Cop26 plea
Welcome to our monthly roundup of the biggest issues in farming and food production, with must-read reports from around the web

Clare Horton and Tom Levitt

05, Oct, 2021 @9:30 AM

Article image
How can we stop using soya linked to deforestation?
From feeding insects to chickens to tracking produce, a range of options aim to curb appetite for soya that harms the environment

Tom Levitt

25, Nov, 2020 @3:00 PM

Article image
UK imported 1m tonnes of soya with deforestation risk in 2019
New analysis finds 40% was brought in without sourcing checks from Brazil, Argentina and Paraguay

Tom Levitt

01, Dec, 2020 @11:58 AM

Article image
Brazilian beef farms ‘used workers kept in conditions similar to slavery’
Workers on farms supplying world’s biggest meat firms allegedly paid £8 a day and housed in shacks with no toilets or running water

Dom Phillips

06, Jan, 2021 @1:08 PM

Article image
Netherlands proposes radical plans to cut livestock numbers by almost a third
Dutch farmers could be forced to sell land and reduce the amount of animals they keep to help lower ammonia pollution

Senay Boztas

09, Sep, 2021 @12:31 PM

Article image
What’s the beef with cows and the climate crisis?
Reducing methane emissions is seen as the biggest opportunity for slowing global heating by 2040

Tom Levitt

27, Oct, 2021 @5:00 AM

Article image
Investors drop Brazil meat giant JBS
Top investment house delists world biggest meat producer over lack of commitment to sustainability issues

Dom Phillips in Rio de Janeiro

28, Jul, 2020 @6:30 AM