Climate denial ads on Facebook seen by millions, report finds

The ads included calling climate change a hoax and were paid for by conservative US groups

Adverts on Facebook denying the reality of the climate crisis or the need for action were viewed at least 8 million times in the US in the first half of 2020, a thinktank has found.

The 51 climate disinformation ads identified included ones stating that climate change is a hoax and that fossil fuels are not an existential threat. The ads were paid for by conservative groups whose sources of funding are opaque, according to a report by InfluenceMap.

Last month Facebook said it was “committed to tackling climate misinformation” as it announced a climate science information centre. It said: “Climate change is real. The science is unambiguous and the need to act grows more urgent by the day.”

Facebook uses factcheckers and bans false advertising but also says this process “is not meant to interfere with individual expression, opinions and debate”. Some of the ads were still running on 1 October. The ads cost just $42,000 to run and appear to be highly targeted, with men over the age of 55 in rural US states most likely to see them.

The Massachusetts senator Elizabeth Warren said: “InfluenceMap’s devastating report reveals how Facebook lets climate deniers spread dangerous junk to millions of people. We have repeatedly asked Facebook to close the loopholes that allow misinformation to run rampant on its platform, but its leadership would rather make a quick buck while our planet burns and communities – disproportionately black and brown – suffer. Facebook must be held accountable for its role in the climate crisis.”

Warren and other senators wrote to Facebook in July calling on it to close the loopholes.

Facebook’s former director of sustainability Bill Weihl, now at the NGO ClimateVoice, said: “Calling out the climate misinformation issue on Facebook is crucial because the company’s limited attempts to deal with the problem are failing to keep pace with powerful tactics like micro-targeting.”

On Tuesday Facebook announced a crackdown on another thread of misinformation, the antisemitic conspiracy movement QAnon, saying it would remove pages or groups “representing” QAnon. In July Facebook was hit by an advertiser boycott in a row over its policing of hate speech following the killing of George Floyd in Minneapolis.

Dylan Tanner, of InfluenceMap said: “[Climate disinformation adverts] will be of concern to advertisers like Unilever and others who are clearly concerned about climate, both from the viewpoint of the company’s risk and also being on the same platform as these ads.”

InfluenceMap compared a database of organisations it said had propagated climate disinformation in the past against Facebook’s Ad Library database to see which advertised on the platform in 2020. Analysis of the ads run by these groups found 51 examples of disinformation, including an ad paid for by the conservative group PragerU that ran to 1 October.

Its headline was: “Make no doubt about it: the hysteria over climate change is to sell you Big Government control.” The accompanying video said: “Fossil fuels are not an existential threat … The Green New Deal is an existential threat.”

Craig Strazzeri, of PragerU, said: “We are not running any disinformation ads. Apparently ‘disinformation’ means anything Facebook or the left disagrees with. The ad in question is an educational video on the truth about the Green New Deal.”

Another ad, which ran in April, was paid for by Turning Point USA, whose “mission is to identify, educate, train, and organise students to promote the principles of freedom, free markets and limited government”. It was headlined: “Conservatives Are Pro-Science, While Leftists Are Pro-Panic! Climate Change Is A HOAX! #ThinkForYourself #EarthDay.”

The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change is clear that global heating is real, dangerous and caused by greenhouse gas emissions from human activities, a conclusion accepted by governments around the world.

The Guardian asked PragerU and Turning Point USA about who provided the funds to pay for the ads, but neither provided this information. Tanner said: “We don’t know whose money is behind the ads that we analysed here – that’s hidden.”

The report said the ads appeared to be tailored to different audiences. Those seen mostly by the over-55s often contested the credibility of climate science, while ads mostly seen by 18- to 34 year-olds tended to challenge the future impact of climate change.

A Facebook spokesperson said: “We prohibit ads that include claims debunked by third-party factcheckers and we are investigating the findings of this report. We work to reduce the spread of climate misinformation on Facebook and we recently launched a climate ccience information centre to connect people with factual information from the world’s leading climate organisations.”

• This article was amended on 9 October 2020 because an earlier version said that the climate disinformation ads were viewed by at least 8 million people. The report found that they were viewed 8 million times. This has been corrected.

Contributor

Damian Carrington Environment editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Let's expose everyday climate denial. Here's how
Trump’s climate stance is blatant and extreme but just as damaging is the daily denial that goes unchallenged, from airport expansion to pub patio heaters. A first step to change is to call it out #DailyClimateDenial

Andrew Simms

09, Jun, 2017 @6:00 AM

Article image
Climate change denial is evil, says Mary Robinson
Exclusive: chair of Elders group also says fossil fuel firms have lost their social licence

Damian Carrington Environment editor

26, Mar, 2019 @6:30 AM

Article image
Facebook and Google announce plans to become carbon neutral
Firms join Apple and Microsoft in committing to put no excess carbon into the atmosphere

Alex Hern

15, Sep, 2020 @5:00 AM

Article image
Facebook announces UK trial to tackle climate misinformation
Labels to be attached to posts directing users to Facebook’s Climate Science Information Center

Alex Hern

18, Feb, 2021 @2:54 PM

Article image
BBC apologises over interview with climate denier Lord Lawson
Exclusive: Lawson’s claim that global temperatures are not rising went unchallenged, breaching guidelines on accuracy and impartiality

Damian Carrington Environment editor

24, Oct, 2017 @5:00 PM

Article image
Facebook video spreads climate denial misinformation to 5 million users | Dana Nuccitelli
Dana Nuccitelli: Facebook is still struggling to contain its fake news problem

Dana Nuccitelli

25, Jul, 2018 @10:00 AM

Article image
Facebook builds 'green' datacentre in Sweden
Datacentre will be powered mainly by renewables and handle all data processing from Europe, the Middle East and Africa

Hanna Gersmann

27, Oct, 2011 @2:29 PM

Article image
Climate change email hacking to be looked into by University of East Anglia

University of East Anglia to launch review into theft and online publication of hundreds of emails sent by scientists in climate research unit

Leo Hickman, Suzanne Goldenberg and Caroline Davies

23, Nov, 2009 @8:42 PM

Article image
Facebook users unwittingly revealing intimate secrets, study finds
Personal information including sexuality and drug use can be correctly inferred from public 'like' updates, according to study. By Josh Halliday

Josh Halliday

11, Mar, 2013 @7:00 PM

Article image
Facebook let fossil-fuel industry push climate misinformation, report finds
Thinktank InfluenceMap accuses petroleum giants of gaming Facebook to promote oil and gas as part of climate-crisis solution

Chris McGreal

05, Aug, 2021 @5:00 AM