Auditors decry 'marine protected areas' that fail to protect ocean

Only 1% of 3,000 supposedly ‘protected’ areas in the Mediterranean ban fishing

Europe’s marine protected areas (MPAs), set up to prevent biodiversity loss at sea, are failing to protect the oceans according to an excoriating report from auditors.

Examining actions to protect marine life over the past decade, the European court of auditors raised a “red flag” warning the EU had failed to halt marine biodiversity loss in Europe’s waters and restore fishing to sustainable levels.

Its report concluded there had been “no meaningful signs of progress” in the Mediterranean, the most overfished sea in the world, where the report said fishing is now at twice the sustainable level.

The news follows Guardian Seascape revelations on the so-called “paper parks” that marine conservationists say allow bottom trawling and other activities harmful to vulnerable marine habitats.

The report’s findings echoed a recent assessment by the European Environment Agency (EEA), which found fewer than 1% of European MPAs were fully protected by fishing bans, and urged better management of protected areas.

The auditors, who visited Italy, Spain, Portugal and France, found these states had used only 6% of a €6bn (£5.42bn) European Maritime and Fisheries Fund aimed at supporting environmental protection.

Porto Cesareo on the Salento coast
The protected Porto Cesareo on the Salento coast. The Mediterranean Sea is the most overfished in the world. Photograph: Giuseppe Colasanto/Alamy

“Due to their economic, social and environmental importance, seas are a real treasure. However, EU action has so far been unable to restore European seas to good environmental status, nor fishing to sustainable levels”, said João Figueiredo, the member of the European court of auditors responsible for the report.

“Our audit clearly raises the red flag over the EU’s sea protection,” he said.

The EU marine protection framework established an “emblematic” network of more than 3,000 MPAs, which cast a “wide protective net” around Europe’s seas, the auditors said. But they stressed that the network “does not run deep”, and was insufficient to restrict overfishing.

To be effective, MPAs would need to sufficiently cover the EU’s most vulnerable marine species and their habitats, include fishing restrictions where needed and be well managed.

“This is far from being the case,” the report said.

The report documented a “decade of failure by key fishing nations to address the Mediterranean crisis”, said Domitilla Senni of MedReAct. While the commission was committed to restoring seas to good environmental status and reducing overfishing, she said, the problem lay with individual member states.

“The findings of the independent report are painfully clear: in the Mediterranean, there were no meaningful signs of progress,” she said.

“While the dire state of the Mediterranean calls for urgent and bold recovery actions, certain member states continue to block progress on the establishment of key conservation measures, including fisheries restricted areas closed to bottom fishing.”

European MPAs were mostly small, “and the majority still allow fishing”, Senni said.

The report also found that EU fisheries management lags behind scientific advice. It recommended renewed action towards the establishment of new fisheries restricted areas by 2023.

Last week 11 NGOs, including MedReAct and Oceana, wrote to the European commissioner for the environment, oceans and fisheries, Virginijus Sinkevičius, to urge him to press member states to create a properly protected network of fish habitats across the Mediterranean, to protect spawning grounds and marine ecosystems. They said that overfishing of hake, one of the most important species commercially, had reached levels 15 times above what is considered to be sustainable in one area, the Gulf of Lion, on the French coast.

Earlier this year, the EEA reported that loss of marine biodiversity in Europe’s seas had not been halted, with a high proportion of marine species and habitats assessments showing an unfavourable conservation status.

And last year a study found that 59% of the MPAs in Europe were actually trawled by commercial vessels at higher levels than unprotected areas.

“Much of the EU’s spatially impressive MPA network provides a false sense of security about positive conservation actions being taken,” it concluded.


Karen McVeigh

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
UK to trial ‘highly protected marine areas’ in win for ocean campaigners
‘Historic’ move to ban destructive fishing methods in five habitats welcomed, but conservationists say change must come faster

Karen McVeigh

09, Jun, 2021 @10:54 AM

Article image
EU slammed over failure to protect marine life from ‘destructive’ fishing
Strict no-take policies urged by scientists, who note there is less protection in 59% of marine protected areas than outside MPAs

Karen McVeigh

12, Sep, 2022 @4:16 PM

Article image
World leaders descend on France for ocean summit as Macron puts spotlight on seas
As One Ocean event in Brest aims to deliver ‘blue diplomacy’ in areas from pollution to overfishing, activists warn against ‘bluewashing’

Jon Henley

08, Feb, 2022 @1:09 PM

Article image
UK fishing licences could be unlawful, says Oceana
Permits for UK and EU vessels will hinder efforts to protect marine life and may break habitats directive, conservation group warns

Karen McVeigh

17, Dec, 2021 @6:20 AM

Article image
‘An invisible killer’: how fishing gear became the deadliest marine plastic
Plastic in the depths: as ‘ghost gear’ chokes the ocean, campaigners call for mandatory measures including buy-back schemes and recycling

Emma Bryce

07, Nov, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
Weak controls failing to stop illegal seafood landing on EU plates, investigation shows
EU financial watchdog blames small fines and feeble controls in some states for amount of illegal seafood

Karen McVeigh

27, Sep, 2022 @5:00 AM

Article image
Tiny Pacific island nation declares bold plan to protect 100% of its ocean
Niue is creating a marine park to protect its waters, an area the size of Vietnam, from illegal fishing

Claire Turrell

30, May, 2022 @6:15 AM

Article image
Video reveals devastation from scallop dredging on ‘protected’ Scottish seabed
Campaigners say marine protected area set up to save UK’s only fan mussels exists merely as a ‘paper park’

Karen McVeigh

06, Oct, 2022 @10:07 AM

Article image
EU accused of ‘neocolonial’ plundering of tuna in Indian Ocean
Indian Ocean states say EU pushing weakest conservation efforts for yellowfin tuna while EU ‘distant fleet’ hoovers up the most fish

Karen McVeigh

05, Mar, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
NGOs demand action not promises as EU accused of ‘failing to protect seas’
Environmental groups propose urgent plan to stop overfishing and safeguard marine life, as existing laws go unenforced

Karen McVeigh

18, Jan, 2021 @6:30 AM