What future for British fishing? | Letters

We can take back control of our waters, writes Bertie Armstrong, while Steve Peak laments the Tories’ broken promises

We agree with Polly Toynbee that fishing is “deep-dyed in the national identity” (Opinion, 23 April). The UK is in the middle of some of the best fishing grounds in the world. Where she is wrong is in making two assertions: firstly, that taking back control of our waters “is not going to happen, because it can’t”; and secondly, that the problem is that UK skippers sold their quotas to foreigners.

On the first, actually it can. The United Nations convention on the law of the sea (UNCLOS) awards sovereign rights over and responsibilities for the natural resources to coastal states in their own exclusive economic zones. That will be us on Brexit, and there are a couple of pre-packed examples of the benefits in the EEZs of our near north-east Atlantic neighbours. Iceland catches 90% of the seafood resource in its EEZ and Norway some 85%. For us, under the rules in the common fisheries policy, we catch 40%, which is absurd. It certainly can change, and according to the prime minister and DexEU and Defra, it will change. It will be a negotiation, but if, as Polly says, the referendum was actually won on fishing sentiment, then public support will see the negotiations move in the right direction.

On the second issue, foreign ownership, I am amazed by Tom Appleby’s assertion that “Britain could and should have banned the sale of its quotas”. He’s missed the fact that the UK sought to do just that in the Factortame case 1989-2000, but was prevented from doing so by EU law. As long as we are in the EU, it is illegal to require UK majority ownership of a UK fishing vessel. But that can change should it be decided that the UK wishes to again have unfettered ownership of its natural capital.

Polly is right that 0.5% of GDP is the oft-quoted figure, but that represents about £1bn at landings value. Doubling that, for the direct benefit of our coastal communities is no small thing. Returning to the idea that fishing is deep-dyed in our national identity, it’s simply the right thing to do.
Bertie Armstrong
Chief executive, Scottish Fishermen’s Federation

• Polly Toynbee describes the near hopeless position of the small British fishing boats as epitomised in the Hastings fleet. The first and most important stage in this sell-out by the establishment took place in 1973, when Britain joined the EEC. The Tory government did a deal with the existing EEC whereby British farmers (ie, many Tory MPs) would be given large grants, while British well-stocked fishing waters would be opened up to the Euro fishing fleets. No Tory MPs owned a fishing boat. Hastings had a Tory MP in 1973, as it does now (Amber Rudd). All Hastings MPs since 1973 have promised a better deal for the local fishing industry, but the situation has steadily deteriorated, and shows all signs of continuing to do so under Brexit.
Steve Peak
Author of Fishermen of Hastings, Hastings, East Sussex

• Join the debate – email guardian.letters@theguardian.com

• Read more Guardian letters – click here to visit gu.com/letters


The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Westminster, not the EU, is to blame for the sorry state of UK fishing | Letters
Letters: Roger Mainwood, David Walker and John Byrne respond to claims that Brexit will restore the fortunes of the UK’s fishing fleets


25, Apr, 2018 @4:23 PM

Article image
Potential dangers to the Chagos Islands | Letters
Letters: Jonathan Hunt says most of the islands are uninhabitable and Paul Tattam says there is a risk of China playing Britain at its own game of gunboat diplomacy


26, Feb, 2019 @5:44 PM

Article image
UK to 'take charge' of its fishing waters under post-Brexit plan
Bill promises fairer share for British fishermen – but they face annual battle for EU rights

Fiona Harvey Environment correspondent

03, Jul, 2018 @11:01 PM

Article image
Norway backs EU fishing policies remaining during Brexit transition
North Sea curbs to last at least 21 months despite Michael Gove’s suggestion Britain would take back control of its waters

Daniel Boffey

12, Jan, 2018 @1:38 PM

Article image
EU fishing quotas pose risk to some stocks, say campaigners
Ministers setting limits for 2019 accused of ignoring scientific advice on overfishing

Fiona Harvey Environment correspondent

19, Dec, 2018 @11:14 AM

Article image
Dutch urge Gove to spell out post-Brexit fishing industry plans
UK environment secretary told by Dutch fisheries minister to set out proposals after department missed Christmas white paper deadline

Daniel Boffey in Brussels

30, Jan, 2018 @11:18 AM

Article image
Bog off, it’s not called a bathroom | Brief letters
Brief letters: Pre-Brexit swallow arrivals | Putin’s missiles | World leaders’ grip on reality | Brexit songs | Unwelcome Americanisms | 75-minute lunch breaks


24, Feb, 2019 @6:00 PM

Article image
Cooperation and force in aid of the environment | Letters
Letters: Albert Beale says Britain needn’t be in the EU to make environmental progress, Darian McBain says seafood companies are helping to establish regulations, Michael Williams outlines the progress made by fisheries and conservation authorities, and Ursula Holden highlights the Mothers Rise Up climate march


14, May, 2019 @5:06 PM

Article image
Time for Solskjær to wear the No 10 shirt | Brief letters
Letters: Donald Tusk | RSPB takeover | No lobby | May’s fate | A lesson from history | Ole Gunnar Solskjær for caretaker PM

Brief letters

16, Jan, 2019 @6:38 PM

Article image
The great British school holidays washout | Brief letters
Brief letters: Changing your name | School summer holidays | Socks | HS2 | No-deal Brexit | Today programme


21, Aug, 2019 @4:05 PM