Shell and Exxon face censure over claim gas was 'cleanest fossil fuel'

Dutch advertising watchdog’s ruling prompts company to change line to ‘least polluting fossil fuel’ as campaigners welcome action over ‘misleading’ ad

The Dutch advertising watchdog will on Tuesday censure Shell and Exxon for claiming that natural gas was “the cleanest of all fossil fuels” in an advert earlier this year.

It will be the second time this summer that the Netherlands advertising standards board has ruled against the fossil fuels industry, after it slapped down Statoil in June for calling gas a “clean energy” and “low emissions fuel”.

In a bid to pre-empt the latest ruling, online versions of the advert were changed a few weeks ago to redefine gas as “the least polluting fossil fuel”.

The Dutch watchdog waived punitive action against the NAM company, which is part-owned by Shell and Exxon, in that light.

Paul de Clerk of Friends of the Earth Europe, which co-filed the complaint with Milieudefensie, said: “This clear ruling by the advertisement standards board is of great importance. Time after time we see how oil and gas companies are misleading citizens and politicians.

“They want us to believe that gas is clean and they support the transition to renewable energy. Behind the screens we see how the same companies lobby against this transition. To prevent catastrophic climate change we need to end the dependency on all fossil fuels – including gas. ”

The issue is highly contentious, after a Trump administration push for gas to be described as a “clean technology” at a G20 summit in July split the meeting.

The US disassociated itself from the final communique, inserting text into the document saying that it would help countries “access and use fossil fuels more cleanly and efficiently.”

But gas is seen by many policy-makers as a “bridging fuel” to a renewable-powered future and the EU’s research wing has also described it as a low carbon energy source, making about £100m available for research grants on that basis.

Natural gas emits around half as much carbon dioxide as coal when burned, although this is still far more than from renewables.

But the picture is less clear when it includes methane – a short-lived but much more potent greenhouse gas – which one recent study found was being emitted by gas plants at levels up to 120 times higher than reported to US regulators.

The ruling by the Dutch Advertising Code Authority, which the Guardian has seen, found that “the absolute term ‘cleanest fossil fuel’ is not in line with the MRC [Dutch advertising code].”

“It is suggested that fossil fuels can be clean in that they do not cause environmental damage. It is firm – and recognised by NAM – that that suggestion is not correct.”

Antonetta van Beem, a spokeswoman for NAM, said her company’s decision to change the advert was not an admission that the original had been misleading.


Arthur Neslen

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Shell and Exxon's €5bn problem: gas drilling that sets off earthquakes and wrecks homes
Groningen has been one of Europe’s richest gas-drilling sites for 30 years, but in that time thousands of buildings have been damaged by manmade earthquakes. Compensation claims could run into billions of euros, and might force a rethink of European energy security

Lucas Amin

10, Oct, 2015 @9:00 AM

Article image
Fears of new quakes in Dutch gas field as energy crisis bites
As Dutch government weighs resuming gas production in earthquake zone this winter, anxiety is rising in Groningen

Arthur Neslen

22, Aug, 2022 @9:00 AM

Article image
Shell threatened with legal action over climate change contributions
Friends of the Earth demands the oil firm move away from fossil fuels to comply with Paris deal

Jonathan Watts Global environment editor

04, Apr, 2018 @11:41 AM

Article image
'Greenwashing': fossil fuel execs to hold invite-only forum at UN climate summit
BP, Shell and Chevron representatives will be at event on sidelines of UN climate summit

Sandra Laville

18, Sep, 2019 @6:01 AM

Article image
How cities and states could finally hold fossil fuel companies accountable
These lawsuits may force fossil fuel companies to reveal what they lied about

Chris McGrealand Alvin Chang

30, Jun, 2021 @7:01 AM

Article image
‘Cataclysmic day’ for oil companies sparks climate hope
Court and investor defeats over carbon emissions a historic turning point, say campaigners and lawyers

Damian Carrington Environment editor

27, May, 2021 @1:38 PM

Article image
Shell in court over claims it hampered fossil fuels phase-out
Environmentalists say firm broke Dutch law by expanding its fossil fuel operations

Daniel Boffey in Brussels

30, Nov, 2020 @11:12 AM

Article image
Fossil fuel big five 'spent €251m lobbying EU' since 2010
Report comes amid calls for set up of firewall to protect politics from industry influence

Sandra Laville

24, Oct, 2019 @5:01 AM

Article image
Shell approves $12bn liquefied natural gas project in Canada
Scheme will send supercooled gas to Asia as countries switch over from coal

Adam Vaughan

02, Oct, 2018 @1:10 PM

Article image
US taxpayers subsidising world's biggest fossil fuel companies
Shell, ExxonMobil and Marathon Petroleum got subsidises granted by politicians who received significant campaign contributions from the fossil fuel industry, Guardian investigation reveals

Damian Carrington and Harry Davies

12, May, 2015 @11:00 AM