Grouse moors 'to blame for Scotland's disappearing raptors'

As estates gear up for Glorious Twelfth, wildlife crime expert talks of direct link between grouse moors and persecution of birds of prey

Grouse moors are to blame for persecuting endangered birds of prey in the Scottish Highlands and Uplands, according to a wildlife crime expert.

Ian Thomson, the head of investigations at the Royal Society for the Protection of Birds Scotland, said data from 77 birds of prey that had been satellite-tagged showed a direct correlation between dead and disappeared birds and grouse moors.

Moorland estates across Scotland and northern England are gearing up for the start on Saturday of the annual red grouse-shooting season, known as the Glorious Twelfth, although wet weather and late snow have led to some shoots being postponed in the Highlands.

The industry in Scotland is fighting to persuade ministers to drop proposals to introduce licensing for shooting estates, which can include pheasant and partridge, in a further effort to crack down on illegal persecution of birds of prey.

Thomson said “a very stark pattern” emerged when tagging data for 44 golden eagles, eight hen harriers and 25 red kites that had disappeared or been deliberately killed since 2009 was displayed on a map of Scotland.

It showed hotspots in the Angus glens near Dundee, the Highlands in Perthshire, the Monadhliath mountains and Speyside south of Inverness, around the Black Isle north of Inverness, and in the Southern Uplands. Some were poisoned, others shot or killed by blows to the head, but a large majority of tagged birds vanished without explanation, the records said.

In May an expert report from Scottish Natural Heritage on golden eagles said there was a direct correlation between grouse moors and the deaths and disappearances of tagged eagles, and the areas where eagles were failing to breed or prosper.

SNH found a third of 131 young eagles tagged over a 12-year period had disappeared in suspicious circumstances or been killed, chiefly in the Highlands, although several did so on Hebridean islands or remote peninsulas with no shooting estates.

In a blogpost timed to coincide with the Glorious Twelfth, Thomson said: “It is clear from this map that, like golden eagles, the distribution of illegally killed or suspiciously disappeared satellite-tagged red kites and hen harriers is far from random, and shows clear clusters in some upland areas.

“As with the hotspots for eagles, these clusters are almost entirely coincident with land dominated by driven grouse shooting management.”

Landowners insist the rate of persecution has fallen sharply in Scotland because a majority of grouse moor managers and gamekeepers supported government-led campaigns to protect birds of prey. Arguing that Scotland already has among the strictest wildlife crime legislation in the world, they say official Scottish government data shows a decline in recorded incidents.

“The reality, corroborated by official statistics, is that incidents of persecution of birds of prey are at an all-time low and that populations of birds such as eagles and red kites are on the rise,” said Tim Baynes, the director of the Scottish Moorland Group, an industry alliance.

“Many grouse moors host good populations of breeding eagles, harriers, merlin, buzzard and short-eared owls. [The] attitude of grouse moor managers towards protected species is a world away from attitudes held in generations gone by.”

Timed to coincide with a march to support shooting estates by gamekeepers and rural traders last weekend in Edzell, a town in the Angus glens, the moorland group published a survey of 45 grouse moors around Scotland.

It calculated these estates each generated £515,000 on average for local businesses every year “before a shot had been fired”. That figure did not include wages to gamekeepers and other staff, or the spending by clients in local hotels or restaurants.

But prompted by the golden eagle data released in May, Roseanna Cunningham, Scotland’s environment secretary, announced she was setting up an expert group to consider licensing of shooting estates, among other reforms. She also increased police resources to tackle wildlife crime.

The licensing system, which the RSPB has campaigned for, would allow estates linked to wildlife persecution to be barred from commercial shooting. Scottish land owners are already at risk of prosecution under “vicarious liability” regulations if there are suspicions or evidence they are failing to prevent wildlife crime on their estates.

Speaking in May about the golden eagle research, Cunningham said: “The findings of this research are deeply concerning and will give rise to legitimate concerns that high numbers of golden eagles, and other birds of prey, continue to be killed in Scotland each year.

“There is every reason to believe that similar levels of persecution affect untagged golden eagles, as well as those we are able to track via satellite tags.”


Severin Carrell Scotland editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Call for action to protect Scotland's endangered capercaillie birds
Survey finds Highlands population has halved since 1990s, believed to be because of climate change and human activity

Severin Carrell Scotland editor

25, Jul, 2017 @11:01 PM

Article image
Activists sue ministers over release of game birds for shooting
Wild Justice accuses UK government of breaching duty to protect conservation sites

Severin Carrell

18, Sep, 2020 @11:57 AM

Article image
Poisoning of Scottish birds of prey at highest levels in 20 years
Birds of prey such as golden eagles and red kites were poisoned in record numbers in Scotland in 2009, RSPB figures reveal

Severin Carrell, Scotland correspondent

23, Jul, 2010 @6:00 AM

Article image
Hooded vultures 'on brink of extinction' in Africa after mass poisoning
Accidental ingestion of strychnine believed to be cause of nearly 1,000 deaths in Guinea-Bissau

Patrick Barkham

06, Mar, 2020 @11:55 AM

Article image
Scottish grouse moor owners face mandatory licensing
Proposed changes would allow owners to be prosecuted or fined for harming other species

Severin Carrell Scotland editor

19, Dec, 2019 @3:35 PM

Article image
Ecologists unveil plan for 'barometer of natural life'

Paper co-authored by E O Wilson calls for thousands of scientists to collect information on 160,000 species deemed representative of life on Earth

Juliette Jowit

08, Apr, 2010 @6:00 PM

Article image
Scottish government urged to regulate grouse moors after golden eagles vanish
Call to outlaw intensive grouse shooting after disappearance of two juvenile eagles

Severin Carrell Scotland editor

01, Jul, 2019 @12:33 PM

Article image
Illegal bird deaths in UK recorded in RSPB report

Uplands losing birds of prey as buzzards, sparrowhawks and peregrine falcons are shot dead or poisoned

Jessica Aldred

13, Dec, 2013 @6:00 AM

Article image
Last-ditch effort under way to stop corncrake extinction in Britain
Steady decline of migratory bird concerns conservationists who highlight importance of wildlife-friendly farming

Patrick Barkham

01, Jan, 2022 @7:00 AM

Article image
New IUCN green status launched to help species ‘thrive, not just survive’
Conservation tool will focus on recovery efforts to give a fuller picture of threats to plant and animal populations

Patrick Greenfield

28, Jul, 2021 @6:01 AM