Most global investors recognise financial risk of climate change, report finds

Global index reveals 60% of asset owners are now taking some action, but warns there is still ‘enormous resistance’ to managing climate risk

For the first time a majority of global investor heavyweights recognise the financial risks of climate change, according to the results of a major global index rating how investors manage such risks.

But despite the advances, the Asset Owner Disclosure Project chairman, John Hewson, has warned there is still an “enormous resistance” to managing climate risk.

The AODP releases its fifth global index on Wednesday, ranking the world’s largest 500 asset owners and, for the first time, the 50 largest asset managers on their performance managing financial risks associated with climate change.

Asset owners and managers were scored on governance and strategy, portfolio carbon risk management and metrics and targets, and graded as leaders (A-AAA) rating), challengers (B-BBB), learners (C-CCC), bystanders (D-DDD) and laggards (X).

The index found that 40% of asset owners and just 6% of asset managers were classed as laggards, meaning they had a scored zero on the measures for managing and disclosing climate risks.

The report concluded that “the scales have tipped”, as 60% of asset owners are now taking some action.

Of the 500 asset owners, there are now 34 leaders, 34 challengers, 44 learners and 187 bystanders, an increase in all categories since the last year compared with laggards, which fell from 246 to 201 in number.

Australia and New Zealand were among the 10 best-performing countries, which were all in Oceania and Europe.

Asset owners in Australia and New Zealand average B compared with an average D across Asia. Australia’s Local Government Super ranked first among asset owners in the world and First State Super ranked third, both with a triple A rating.

But Hewson said there was still “enormous resistance” among Australia’s asset owners because they tend to “take a very short-term focus, and rely on short-term remuneration, so they won’t take a medium to long-term challenge on easily”.

Hewson said asset owners tended to have a “herd instinct” and many people saving for retirement haven’t focused on the risk of a climate-induced financial crisis and exercised their concern through choice of fund.

“The government downplaying the need to transition to renewables doesn’t help ... It’s not conducive to a serious assessment of risk, that’s for sure.”

The former Australian opposition leader warned a climate change-induced financial crisis would be a “global phenomenon and is a global risk”, agreeing with the former US secretary of the treasury Hank Paulson that the risks dwarfs even the US subprime mortgage crisis that precipitated the global financial crisis.

According to the AODP report, nearly one in five asset owners have staff focused on integrating climate risk into their investments, two in five (42%) incorporate climate change into their policy frameworks, and 13% of asset owners now calculate portfolio carbon emissions, up from 10%.

However assessing the risk of stranded assets is still quite an advanced tool used by only 6% of the index.

All three asset managers in Australia and New Zealand rated D. Macquarie, the sole Australian investment manager included in this index, rated a D.

The report said this was “a cause for concern giving its impending acquisition of the UK’s Green Investment Bank” and called on it to “dramatically improve its climate credentials”.

Hewson called for regulators to mandate disclosure of climate change risks, suggesting the Bloomberg taskforce on climate-related financial disclosures and other G20 processes will “inevitably” lead to such disclosure.

“The solution should be disclosure first, because once [asset owners and managers] admit this is the risk they’re running, naturally they’ll want to manage it.”

Hewson also praised the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority for warning in March that individual directors may be financially accountable for failing to factor in losses from climate change, commenting “that’s shaken them up a lot”.

Three of Australia’s big four banks are currently reviewing their exposure to fossil fuels, including their lending practices to households and farmers, in response to climate change.


Paul Karp

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
'World-first' legal case: student accuses Australia of misleading investors on climate risk
Katta O’Donnell, 23, says her claim will put government ‘on trial for misconduct’ for failing to address climate change

Adam Morton Environment editor

22, Jul, 2020 @4:09 AM

Article image
Australian firms told to catch up on climate change risk checks
New report says Australian companies lag behind international organisations

Lisa Cox

17, Jun, 2018 @6:00 PM

Article image
Climate change poses risk to Australia's financial stability, warns RBA deputy governor
Guy Debelle urges policymakers and business to address global warming as a trend rather than a temporary weather cycle

Katharine Murphy Political editor

12, Mar, 2019 @9:08 AM

Article image
Super funds and investors with $34tn urge leaders to speed up climate action
Fund managers call on world leaders to bring in carbon pricing and phase out coal power ahead of G20

Adam Morton

26, Jun, 2019 @3:17 AM

Article image
Finance sector could face climate-risk testing, says Australian watchdog
Regulator says it may add climate change to the list of scenarios it asks institutions to run to check economic resilience

Gabrielle Chan

08, Mar, 2017 @7:39 AM

Article image
Banks warned of 'regulatory action' as climate change bites global economy
Australian Prudential Regulation Authority says it is quizzing companies about their actions to assess climate risks

Michael Slezak

29, Nov, 2017 @9:00 AM

Article image
Australian shareholders should be told of climate risk to profits, says thinktank
Centre for Policy Development urges companies to adopt standardised analysis of climate’s impact on business

Gareth Hutchens

28, Nov, 2017 @5:01 PM

Article image
Plan that tackles recession and climate change could create 76,000 Australian jobs, report says
Jobs could be created in three years with a focus on 12 areas including large-scale renewable energy and electric vehicle networks

Adam Morton Environment editor

20, Jul, 2020 @10:09 PM

Article image
Australian businesses must do more to disclose climate change risks to investors, Asic says
Financial analysts say regulator’s report makes it clear ‘many Australian companies are not meeting their legal requirements’

Lisa Cox

20, Sep, 2018 @7:01 AM

Article image
'Investors are mostly concerned about political risks': energy minister Angus Taylor – full interview
As the Coalition announces new measures to reduce power bills, Taylor talks to political editor Katharine Murphy

Katharine Murphy Political editor

23, Oct, 2018 @5:00 PM