Petrol cars allowed to exceed pollution limits by 50% under draft EU laws

Car industry successfully lobbied for loopholes to dilute EU laws limiting toxic particulates emissions for new cars, the Guardian has learned

New European cars with petrol engines will be allowed to overshoot a limit on toxic particulates emissions by 50% under a draft EU regulation backed by the UK and most other EU states.

Campaigners say that a simple €25 (£22) filter could drastically cut the pollution, but the Guardian has learned that car-makers have instead mounted a successful push for loopholes and legislative delay.

Bas Eickhout, a Green MEP on the European parliament’s environment committee and dieselgate inquiry panel, promised action to ensure that the lessons of the VW scandal were learned.

“With this ridiculous proposal, the EU’s member states are again trying to dilute EU laws at a terrible cost to human health. We will call on the European commission to come to the European parliament and explain themselves on this issue,” he said.

Particulate matter (PM) is the largest single contributor to the estimated 600,000 premature deaths across Europe from pollution-related heart and lung diseases each year. Children and the elderly are worst affected, and the associated health costs could be as high as €1.6tn a year in Europe, according to the World Health Organisation.

Although exhaust fumes from diesel and petrol engines are one of the largest sources of particulates emissions, most EU member states support raising the EU’s pollution standard 50% above the legal limit set down in the Euro 6 regulation. Behind the scenes, vehicle makers have pushed strongly for a staggering 300% over, according to material seen by the Guardian.

The draft regulation is still being discussed by EU member states and the auto industry has not given up hopes of wrenching further concessions on particulate emissions ahead of a final decision on 7 December.

One Powerpoint slide shown to EU expert groups by the European automobile manufacturers association (Acea) says that a 300% latitude in meeting the letter of the law would be “realistic” because of “measurement uncertainty” in emissions tests.

Florent Grelier, a clean vehicles engineer at the Transport and Environment (T&E) campaign group, told the Guardian he feared that EU attempts to improve air quality were being “bent to the will of the automotive industry”.

“This is a petrolgate scandal in the making,” he said. “Unless the European commission and governments establish strict test procedures to protect the industry from its own short-sightedness, within a few years we will see continuing high levels of particles killing hundreds of thousands of citizens prematurely.”

Under EU law, car-manufacturers are already obliged to use filters for diesel engines, but not for the rapidly-growing 40% of the petrol engine market which is made up by uncontrolled gasoline direct injection engines. These release more particulate matter than modern diesel cars.

Gasoline particulate filters could reduce these emissions by a factor of around 100, and would cost manufacturers just €25 per car, according to research by T&E. But car manufacturers have argued this would violate the principle of technology neutrality.

A spokesman for Acea declined to comment on the issue.

Calls by the auto industry for a delay in implementing the new regulation have been well received by several car-producing EU countries. Spain and Sweden argued for a one-year legislative delay that would push its introduction back to 2019, in minutes of a technical committee meeting earlier this month seen by the Guardian.

The UK took no formal position on when the new regulation should enter into force but warned of “unintended adverse effects” if PM limits were given a separate starting date to standards for another pollutant, nitriogen oxide (NOx) , which will now begin in 2019.

An EU group of national experts – the technical committee on motor vehicles - is now expected to sign off on the final proposal to amend the Euro 6 regulation for real world driving emissions, in December.

The issue of “conformity factors” - or compensating for uncertainties in emissions tests – last year led the committee to impose a NOx limit 110% higher than the one written into the Euro 6 regulations last year.


Arthur Neslen

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Nine out of 10 new diesel cars exceed EU pollution limits, report finds
Road test reveals cars emit seven times the permitted level of exhaust emissions when tested in real-world conditions

Damian Carrington

14, Sep, 2015 @4:03 PM

Article image
Revealed: nearly all new diesel cars exceed official pollution limits
Health experts lambast ‘deceitful’ carmakers as data suggests 97% of vehicles fail to meet NOx emissions standards in real-world conditions

Damian Carrington, Gwyn Topham and Peter Walker

23, Apr, 2016 @6:00 AM

Article image
Mayors of 20 European cities attack weak EU diesel pollution limits
Mayors from Paris, Madrid and Athens say loophole in NOx emissions tests puts citizens’ health at risk

Adam Vaughan

16, Mar, 2016 @11:39 AM

Article image
Diesel cars emit 10 times more toxic pollution than trucks and buses, data shows
Stricter EU emissions testing for large vehicles means modern diesel cars produce 10 times more NOx per litre of fuel

Damian Carrington

06, Jan, 2017 @6:01 AM

Article image
German backlash against EU air pollution limits 'lacks evidence'
World Health Organization official comments on row about safe levels of nitrogen dioxide

Arthur Neslen in Brussels

05, Feb, 2019 @3:00 PM

Article image
How conniving carmakers caused the diesel air pollution crisis
Cheating, dodging rules and heavy lobbying by motor manufacturers fuelled the toxic air the UK is struggling with today

Damian Carrington, Environment editor

07, Apr, 2017 @10:32 AM

Article image
Secrecy around air pollution controls in cars faces legal challenge
New EU rules that allow car firms to keep their emissions control systems secret from the public risk another dieselgate and should be made illegal, say environmental lawyers

Damian Carrington Environment editor

09, Oct, 2017 @12:16 PM

Article image
Ikea and Nestle call for new EU laws to cut truck emissions
Increase fuel efficiency of heavy good vehicles that cause a quarter of Europe’s traffic carbon emissions to meet climate targets, says clean corporate alliance

Arthur Neslen

26, May, 2016 @12:19 PM

Article image
EU car pollution laws have improved UK's air quality, say carmakers
New Euro 6 standards will eliminate exhaust pollutants, says industry facing criticism over ‘major cancer risk’ from diesel fumes

John Vidal

04, Sep, 2015 @10:48 AM

Article image
Diesel pollution stunts children’s lung growth, London study shows
Research carried out in London also shows charging polluting trucks had no effect on health

Damian Carrington Environment editor

14, Nov, 2018 @11:30 PM