African wildlife officials appalled as EU opposes a total ban on ivory trade

European commission’s opposition to a proposed global ban will spell the beginning of a mass extinction of African elephants, warn officials from 29 African states

Wildlife officials in nearly 30 African states say they are appalled by an EU decision to oppose a comprehensive global ban on the ivory trade.

In a position paper released on 1 July, the European commission said that rather than an all-encompassing ban it would be better to encourage countries with growing elephant numbers to “sustainably manage” their populations.

An existing global embargo on ivory sales is due to end in 2017 and Zimbabwe, Namibia, South Africa and Botswana are pushing for it to be replaced with a decision-making mechanism for future tusk trading, at the Convention on International Trade in International Species (Cites) conference in Johannesburg this September.

However, the African Elephant Coalition (AEC) – a coalition of 29 African states – is warning of a mass extinction on the continent within 25 years, unless elephants are given an ‘Annex I’ Cites listing, which would ban any future domestic ivory trade.

Andrew Seguya, the director of Uganda’s Wildlife Authority, told the Guardian: “If the EU prevents an Annex I listing, it will be the beginning of the extinction of the African elephant for sure. We have lost 100,000 elephants in just three years. If nothing is done, we will see a tipping of the balance in conservation efforts before the next Cites COP (conference of parties).”

In 2014, 20,000 African elephants were killed by poachers. Between 2009 and 2015, Tanzania and Mozambique lost over half their elephant populations, with similar figures reported across east and central Africa.

The death rate is such that every 15 minutes, an elephant somewhere is killed by poachers.

Experts say that traumatised elephant populations in Africa are increasingly becoming nocturnal and migrating in mega-herds of up to 550 in a bid to avoid contact with poachers.

Azizou El Hadj Issa, a former minister in Benin and president of the AEC’s council of elders said: “The situation is alarming in most of our countries. Elephants are slaughtered every day, rangers are being killed and the trade is fuelling terrorism which destabilises the continent and has huge repercussions for EU security. We need the EU to support us and become part of the solution to this crisis.”

With 28 members, the EU makes up the biggest voting bloc at Cites. Its funding and trade levers give it a powerful influence in the developing world.

Europe says that it wants an extension of the current ivory ban but also backs a system of exemptions included in the ban, which allows exports of some elephant products from the four African states.

Under a ‘Annex I’ listing, all international ivory trade would be outlawed.

An EU official said: “We need a balanced position. We admit that the domestic trade in ivory should be banned in those situations where it can facilitate illegal trade but don’t fully agree with the inclusion of the African elephant in ‘Annex I’ in those four countries. We would encourage the African countries to have a dialogue about this.”

However, experts believe that there is currently no way to prevent poached ivory from entering legal chains and then finding a way on to the world market.

A one-off legal sale of ivory in 2007, when the current ban came into force, was followed by “an abrupt, significant, permanent, robust and geographically widespread increase” in elephant poaching, according to researchers.

Patricia Awori a member of the AEC’s secretariat, said that she was left “flabbergasted” by the EU’s positioning. “When you consider that there were 600,000 elephants at the start of the crisis which led to this Appendix I proposal and there are now less than 400,000, I am at a loss to understand why this is not more troubling for the EU.”

Patrick Omondi, the deputy director of the Kenya wildlife service, added he was “taken aback and disappointed” by the stance from Brussels.

The most recent figures show a 61% decline in African elephants between 1980 and 2013, although an updated census is due before the Cites meeting.

To ratchet down rampant poaching, the AEC wants all elephants on the continent to be considered a single species – without exceptions for the four countries – arguing that they are a threatened migratory species.

“An elephant that wakes up in the morning in Angola as ‘Appendix I’ could be in Namibia under ‘Appendix II’ by the same afternoon,” Seguya said.

Europe is agnostic on the proposal for a decision-making mechanism to allow future ivory sales. More internal discussions are planned before the bloc takes a final position on the Cites debates, in early September.


Arthur Neslen

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
US adopts near total ban on commercial ivory trade
Barack Obama tightens restriction on sale of elephant ivory within the US to clamp down on illegal trade

Suzanne Goldenberg

02, Jun, 2016 @4:15 PM

Article image
Kenya to burn biggest ever stockpile of ivory
Tusks from over 6,000 illegally killed elephants will be set alight in Nairobi national park to highlight the poaching crisis

Fiona Harvey

29, Apr, 2016 @1:33 PM

Article image
Prince William warns poachers are outrunning efforts to stop wildlife trade
Animals are still being killed in horrifying numbers despite global efforts to stop the poaching crisis, says prince at Hanoi summit

Adam Vaughan

17, Nov, 2016 @10:44 AM

Article image
Wildlife trade summit is a 'do or die' moment for endangered animals
Conservationists urge countries to give imperilled species the highest level of protection at the global Cites summit opening on Saturday to prevent them becoming extinct in the wild

Damian Carrington

23, Sep, 2016 @3:25 PM

Article image
Europe to crack down on wildlife smugglers to protect rare lizard species
EU proposal seeks to close a legal loophole allowing the sale of endangered lizards in Europe after a Guardian article revealed the scale of the problem

Arthur Neslen

05, May, 2016 @6:00 AM

Article image
Thailand's prime minister pledges to outlaw domestic ivory trade
Yingluck Shinawatra's announcement on opening day of Cites wildlife summit offers hope in war on elephant poaching

Damian Carrington

03, Mar, 2013 @4:03 PM

Article image
Swaziland acting as 'puppet' to South Africa in bid to legalise rhino horn trade
Top conservationists criticise the proposal – announced just days after neighbouring South Africa dropped its bid for legal trade – saying it will open the gates for a black market

Adam Vaughan in Nairobi

27, May, 2016 @9:51 AM

Article image
Ivory seizures prompt calls for China to end domestic trade
Despite a 1989 global ban the market in elephant tusks is growing, threatening populations of the animal across Africa

Gaia Vince

24, Jul, 2012 @5:28 PM

Article image
Global pact against illegal wildlife trade should also look beyond poaching

Bradnee Chambers: Controlling poaching is only part of the battle – internationally agreed conservation policies are also needed

Bradnee Chambers

14, Feb, 2014 @4:15 PM

Article image
Global accord on combatting illegal wildlife trade agreed by 46 nations

William Hague hails London event as 'turning point' in fight against yearly slaughter of thousands of rhinos and elephants

Adam Vaughan

13, Feb, 2014 @8:52 PM