Paris climate deal must be legally binding, EU tells John Kerry

US warned that any agreement in Paris will be enshrined in law after secretary of state said it would ‘definitively’ not be a treaty

The EU has warned the Obama administration that a global climate deal at the Paris summit must be legally binding, after the US secretary of state John Kerry said that it “definitively” would not be a treaty.

“The Paris agreement must be an international legally binding agreement,” a spokeswoman for the EU’s climate commissioner, Miguel Arias Cañete, told the Guardian. “The title of the agreement is yet to be decided but it will not affect its legally binding form.”

Earlier today, the French foreign minister, Laurent Fabius, had said it was obvious that any agreement in Paris would contain lawful elements, and suggested that Kerry was “confused” about the point.

Kerry told the Financial Times on Wednesday that any agreement in Paris, where world leaders meet in three weeks’ time, is “definitively not going to be a treaty” and there were “not going to be legally binding reduction targets like Kyoto”, in a reference to the world’s only previous binding climate treaty.

But the nature of the agreement’s elements is being fiercely contested in talks that officials publicly say have reached a very sensitive point. Privately, they say that countries are keeping their powder dry for the frantic last days of negotiations in which a pact is expected to be thrashed out.

“The political-level talks in Paris start on 7 December so we still have some time to sort this out,” Cañete’s spokeswoman said. “What still needs to be negotiated is what provisions within the Paris agreement would be legally binding.”

The EU would like to see a five-yearly multilateral review process or “facilitative regime” that can enforce emissions commitments, with the threat of withholding climate aid being used as a stick against developing countries that renege on their promises.

Whether the deal will be formalised as a treaty or protocol, however, remains up in the air. The Kyoto protocol was criticised by states such as the US, which withdrew from it under the George W Bush presidency, arguing that it exempted developing countries and would damage the US economy.

While keen to clinch a deal in Paris, the Obama administration is worried that a Republican-dominated US Senate could demand a deciding say over any treaty with legally binding obligations.

Some influential countries seem willing to extend Obama the benefit of the doubt. “We don’t need a treaty in Paris,” the Moroccan environment minister Hakima el Haite told a UN climate conference in Rabat last month. “We need a universal agreement in which everyone agrees and commits – and is engaged to respect commitments and contributions. That is what we are working for.”

Bob Ward, the policy director at the Grantham Research Institute on Climate Change and the Environment said that the Paris agreement was always intended as a complement to emissions pledges, rather than a body of statute.

“John Kerry, the US secretary of state, has simply restated what has been understood for a long time,” he said. “It was agreed at the United Nations climate change summit in Durban in 2011 that countries would seek a new and universal greenhouse gas reduction protocol, legal instrument or other outcome with legal force. The Paris agreement will fulfil this.”

But it remains unclear what sanctions could be imposed against developed countries that flout their obligations, or how the review process would ramp up inadequate climate pledges. Countries putting forward their climate plans in recent days include Bosnia, which anticipates a 70% increase in emissions by 2030 compared to 2010 levels, and oil-rich Saudi Arabia.


Arthur Neslen Brussels and Damian Carrington

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Paris climate talks: John Kerry sees hurdles to deal as deadline approaches
US secretary of state expects a slog in the next 72 hours as governments seek to reach an agreement, but he voices optimism: ‘Consensus is slowly being built’

Suzanne Goldenberg in Paris

08, Dec, 2015 @10:11 PM

Article image
Donald Trump says US could re-enter Paris climate deal
In ITV interview US president also says he would take tougher stand on Brexit than Theresa May

Graham Ruddick

29, Jan, 2018 @12:02 AM

Article image
How US negotiators ensured landmark Paris climate deal was Republican-proof
White House officials at COP 21 helped craft a deal congressional Republicans would not be able to stop – and the effort required major political capital

Suzanne Goldenberg

13, Dec, 2015 @3:42 PM

Article image
John Kerry rejects leading climate scientist's claim Paris talks were 'fraud'
Kerry defends agreement after James Hansen, considered the father of climate change awareness, condemned talks over lack of potential for carbon tax

Oliver Milman in New York

13, Dec, 2015 @6:35 PM

Article image
Michael Gove 'deeply regrets' Trump's approach to Paris climate agreement
In first speech since cabinet return, environment secretary says he hopes US president will have a change of heart

Jessica Elgot Political reporter

21, Jul, 2017 @9:51 AM

Article image
Australia warns against stripping Paris climate agreement of ambition
After more than 20 years of negotiations, the next 48 hours are seen as crunch time in reaching a deal to avoid dangerous temperature rise

Lenore Taylor, Suzanne Goldenberg and John Vidal in Paris

09, Dec, 2015 @9:37 PM

Article image
Paris talks: US pledges to double aid to climate-hit countries
John Kerry’s promise of $861m by 2020 marks final push by the US to reach a global climate deal

Suzanne Goldenberg in Paris

09, Dec, 2015 @3:00 PM

Article image
Greta Thunberg tells EU: your climate targets need doubling
Swede, 16, says EU cannot just ‘wait for us to grow up and become the ones in charge’

Jennifer Rankin in Brussels

21, Feb, 2019 @1:22 PM

Article image
Paris climate talks: delegates warn of flaws in ambitious proposals for deal
Despite agreeing on need for bold plans to protect vulnerable countries from rising seas, gaps remain in latest draft text, with next 48 hours crucial

Suzanne Goldenberg, John Vidal and Lenore Taylor in Paris

09, Dec, 2015 @7:56 PM

Article image
Barack Obama: parts of Paris climate deal must carry legal force
President offers apparent compromise over the periodic review of emission reduction targets as Hillary Clinton goes on attack against Republicans back in US

Suzanne Goldenberg

01, Dec, 2015 @8:42 PM