Rich countries' $100bn promise to fight climate change 'not delivered'

Brazil, China, India and South Africa say they are disappointed in failure to make good on promise six years ago to mobilise $100bn a year by 2020

Rich countries are very, very far from raising the billions they promised to help poor countries fight climate change, jeopardising the prospects of reaching a global warming deal at Paris, the world’s rising economies warned.

As a key United Nations meeting got underway, Brazil, China, India and South Africa said they were disappointed in rich countries’ failure to make good on a promise six years ago to mobilise $100bn a year by 2020 for climate finance.

The funds, intended to help developing countries cut their greenhouse gas emissions and prepare for sea-level rises, extreme weather and other consequences of climate change, are seen as a crucial element to reaching a global warming agreement at the end of the year.

Monday’s high-level meeting of the UN general assembly – including an appearance from Robert Redford – was intended to help build momentum for a Paris deal that would keep warming to 2C, the internationally agreed limit to avoid dangerous climate change.

But some of the key players among the 193 countries taking part in the negotiations – and two of the world’s biggest carbon polluters in India and China – say they are frustrated with rich countries’ failure to come up with a clear plan for raising the cash to fight climate change.

By some estimates, there is less than $20bn a year in public finance making its way to developing countries for climate action – or less than a fifth of the $100bn target.

“We will say that that is very, very far from what has to be mobilised by the year 2020,” Edna Molewa, South Africa’s environment minister, said. “It is important therefore that this scaling up happens … there is still a lot of money that is required.”

Rich countries have been promising since 2009 to help rising economies develop technologies to cut greenhouse gas emissions that cause climate change and protect their people from consequences of climate change.

But a joint statement from the four countries expressed “disappointment over the continued lack of any clear road map to provide $100bn per year by 2020, as well as on substantially scaling up financial support after 2020”.

Climate finance has been a major sticking point in negotiations for a global warming deal at Paris. The last round of negotiations, in Bonn earlier this month, ground along without really managing to zero in on the key components of a deal.

There is widespread recognition that rich countries will need to help developing countries, which did the least to cause climate change, but will suffer the most severe consequences.

“If rich countries can show they are making good on their $100bn promise, there will be a much stronger foundation of trust for the Paris talks,” said Tim Gore, Oxfam’s international climate adviser. “We need to see real funding increases.”

Raramuris indigenous waiting for food in Samachique town, Chihuahua state on January 20, 2012. Religious organizations, governmental and civil society in Mexico launched a campaign to collect funds and food to combat chronic hunger that afflicts the indigenous Rar  muris, and that was compounded by the historic drought in 2011 affected the region in which they live.
Members of the Raramuri tribe waiting for food in Samachique town, Chihuahua state, Mexico, in a region hit by drought. Photograph: Yuri Cortez/AFP/Getty Images

But it’s unclear how much rich countries will pay, and to whom. Developing countries are also pushing rich countries to make more funds available for future protections against climate change – not just cutting greenhouse gas emissions.

But by Oxfam’s estimates, just $2.5bn to $4.5bn of current climate finance is going towards climate protection measures.

Countries in sub-Saharan Africa are already spending about $5bn from their own budgets to prepare for climate change – much more than they were receiving in climate finance from rich countries, according to Oxfam.

The four countries said they were working hard to try to put a climate deal in place, but that finance was a crucial element to reaching an agreement.

“There is still a clear expectation and so I hope the developing countries can fulfill their commitment before the Paris meeting,” Xie Zhenhua, China’s climate change envoy, said.

“We need to avoid what happened in Copenhagen”, which failed to reach a comprehensive climate deal, Izabella Teixeira, Brazil’s environment minister said.

But the four countries made it clear developing countries could not be expected to cut greenhouse gas emissions without help. “Without the flow of technical support … it will be impossible to move onto any such trajectory in the near future,” said Ravi Prasad, India’s climate change negotiator.


Suzanne Goldenberg

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Copenhagen destroyed by Danish draft leak, says India's environment minister
Jairam Ramesh claims Connie Hedegaard admitted leak of text was 'death blow from which summit never recovered'

Jonathan Watts in Boao, Hainan

12, Apr, 2010 @12:00 PM

Article image
Lima climate summit extended as poor countries demand more from rich
Talks stumble amid rising frustration over ‘ridiculously low’ cash commitments offered by rich nations to help pay for emissions cuts

Suzanne Goldenberg in Lima

12, Dec, 2014 @8:04 PM

Article image
The BRIC nations' response to climate change is critical to the fate of the planet
The world’s four largest developing economies, Brazil, Russia, India and China, have a huge impact on global sustainability. In a new series, we’ll examine their sphere of influence, the innovations that result, and what it’s like to do business in their shadows

Matthew Wheeland

04, May, 2015 @5:02 PM

Article image
Which countries are doing the most to stop dangerous global warming?
In November, nearly 200 countries meet in Paris for UN talks to agree a new climate deal. Find out below how their pledges - known as Intended Nationally Determined Contributions or INDCs - compare

Matt Osborn, Troy Griggs, Will Franklin, Caelainn Barr , Adam Vaughan, Arthur Neslen, Justin McCurry, Shaun Walker, Suzanne Goldenberg, Lenore Taylor, Jonathan Watts, Jennifer Duggan, Jason Burke, Emma Howard, John Vidal, Jo Tuckman

16, Oct, 2015 @8:43 AM

Article image
Copenhagen media coverage: A perfect storm

Twitterers, blogging activists and other interest groups will outnumber the media at the world climate change summit in Copenhagen

John Vidal

07, Dec, 2009 @12:21 AM

Article image
Poor nations threaten climate deal showdown at Copenhagen summit

Negotiators fail to reach agreement on key areas such as emission cuts, long-term finance and when poor countries should reduce emissions

John Vidal, Jonathan Watts and Suzanne Goldenberg in Copenhagen

13, Dec, 2009 @11:15 PM

Article image
China, India, Brazil and South Africa prepare for post-Copenhagen meeting
Influential bloc of large developing countries expected to define common position on emissions cuts and climate aid

John Vidal, environment editor

13, Jan, 2010 @4:53 PM

Article image
Durban talks unlikely to result in climate change deal
With only three more days of negotiations to go, UN chief Ban Ki-moon says agreement may be 'beyond our reach – for now'

Fiona Harvey and John Vidal in Durban

06, Dec, 2011 @6:02 PM

Article image
Paris climate talks: ‘Six years on, climate change is killing fish, flooding our fields’
On the eve of the 2009 Copenhagen summit, we reported on families threatened by climate change around the world. Now, as the Paris summit nears, many of their worst fears are being realised

Robin McKie Science editor

22, Nov, 2015 @12:04 AM

Article image
More countries reject OECD study on climate aid
China, Brazil and South Africa join India in refusing key report that state rich countries have already mobilised two-thirds of $100bn pledged for climate aid

John Vidal, Suzanne Goldenberg and Lenore Taylor in Paris

08, Dec, 2015 @5:38 PM