Paris climate change talks yield first draft amid air of optimism

Country representatives and green groups say French summit is more cordial and efficient than Copenhagen five years ago

Negotiators paving the way for a global climate change agreement in Paris have cleared a major hurdle, producing a draft accord in record time and raising hopes that a full week of minister-led talks can now clinch a deal despite many sticking points.

No part of the deal has been finalised because in the end it is likely to be a tradeoff between developing countries’ demands – particularly for financing to help cope with the impacts of locked-in climate change – and wealthier nations’ insistence that over time all countries properly account for the progress they have made towards emission reduction goals.

And it remains littered with brackets – indicating areas of disagreement. But the document handed to the French on Saturday has refined 50 pages down to just over 20 and, unusually, was agreed on schedule, leaving a full week for ministers to reach agreement.

China’s chief climate negotiator, Su Wei, said: “It has laid a solid foundation for next week … like when we cook a meal you need to have all the seasonings and ingredients and recipes, but next week is the actual cooking.”

A giant whale sculpture next to the river Seine in Paris.
A giant whale sculpture next to the river Seine in Paris. Photograph: Benoit Tessier/Reuters

Senior negotiators and long-time observers believe there will be a way through the sticking points. “There is good news. This is only a basis for a negotiation … there are several disagreements that we need to talk to each other, to try to solve … but political will is there from all parties,” he said.

Non-government observers were also cautiously optimistic. Martin Kaiser of Greenpeace said progress was far better than at a similar point in the 2009 Copenhagen talks. “At this point in Copenhagen [in 2009] we were dealing with a 300-page text and a pervasive sense of despair. In Paris we’re down to a slim 21 pages and the atmosphere remains constructive. But that doesn’t guarantee a decent deal. Right now the oil-producing nations and the fossil fuel industry will be plotting how to crash these talks when ministers arrive next week.”

Laurence Tubiana, the French envoy for the talks, said: “We could have been better, we could have been worse. The job is not done, we need to apply all intelligence, energy, willingness to compromise and all efforts to come to agreement. Nothing is decided until everything is decided.”

Liz Gallagher, project manager at the non-profit organisation E3G, said the first week of talks had seen “some movement among negotiation blocs, with the idea of north and south … becoming more nuanced”. India had been “better behaved than we expected them to be”, she said, but Saudi Arabia had been blocking the negotiations on several fronts. The Saudis had, for example, been trying to prevent any reference to the need to hold global warming at 1.5C.

The final draft agreement includes the options of holding temperature increases to 1.5C or “well below two degrees”; evidence, the US envoy, Todd Stern, said on Friday, of the emergence of “a high-ambition coalition”, that “includes many countries” but not all of the 195 countries in the talks.

Protesters walk past a gendarme outside the talks in Paris.
Protesters walk past a gendarme outside the talks in Paris. Photograph: Christophe Ena/AP

For the foreign minister of the tiny Marshall Islands, Tony de Brum, that goal is a matter of survival because some islands are already under water. “Put simply, I refuse to go home from Paris without being able to look my grandchildren in the eye and say I have a good deal for you.”

The Saudis have also been blocking the idea that the commitments countries have put on the table in Paris – covering emission reductions between 2020 and 2030 – should be reviewed before that period commences, and potentially increased. The Climate Action Tracker website has calculated those commitments put the world on track for warming of at least 2.7C. Differences on this issue between China and the US were central to the breakdown of the Copenhagen talks six years ago, but in Paris China is taking a softer approach. “We need to enhance the transparency system … it is very important to build trust,” Su said.

There is intense division over how the agreement is worded, in a way that would bind rich countries to specific continued investments, beyond the deal struck in Copenhagen for $100bn (£66bn) a year in public and private money to flow by 2020. (An OECD review said around $60bn was already committed, but poor countries dispute the calculations). And there are also divisions over suggestions big developing countries should join rich countries to make financial contributions to help poor countries reduce their emissions and cope with the impacts of locked-in climate change.

Former governor of California and actor Arnold Schwarzenegger delivers a speech to the French parliament.
Former governor of California and actor Arnold Schwarzenegger delivers a speech to the French parliament. Photograph: Lionel Bonaventure/AFP/Getty Images

Stern told reporters some countries had “over-read” the issue. He said it was about recognising what was already happening – China pledged US$3.1bn in support to developing countries, when President Xi Jinping met President Obama at the White House this year – rather than introducing any requirement, he said.

A group of 10 Democratic US senators reassured countries at the climate meeting on Saturday they “had Barack Obama’s back” and would defend his agenda in a Republican-controlled Congress. The 10 were the first wave of what is anticipated to be a strong US presence at the Paris meeting, designed to counter Republican attempts to sink Obama’s climate plan. Congress voted last week to repeal the main part of Obama’s plan, especially on rules limiting carbon emissions from power plants. But the Democrats said they would be prepared to defend Obama’s agenda in Congress, and push for stronger climate action.

“What you see here are people who are going to protect what the president is putting on the table here in Paris as a promise from the American people to the world,” Ed Markey, a Democrat senator from Massachusetts, told a press conference. “We are going to back up the president every step of the way.”

Despite the multiple disagreements in Paris, Christiana Figueres, the executive secretary of the UN convention on climate change, said the talks were “where we thought they could be”. Officially Saturday is “high level action day” in Paris, the culmination of a process to get emission reduction commitments from bodies other than governments. There have been more than 10,000 such pledges from businesses, local authorities, non government groups and individuals.

Among those attending the event are the former US vice president Al Gore, the former mayor of New York, Michael Bloomberg, the United Nations secretary general, Ban Ki-moon, the actor-cum-politician Arnold Schwarzenegger, and the actor Sean Penn.

Contributors

Lenore Taylor and Suzanne Goldenberg in Paris

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Paris climate change deal: new draft cuts through key sticking points
French foreign minister says Paris talks are ‘extremely close’ to agreement but negotiations will overrun into Saturday

Lenore Taylor in Paris

11, Dec, 2015 @7:36 AM

Article image
Paris talks: new draft climate deal published - as it happened
Negotiators from governments around the world continue to work to iron out their differences over a draft text of the COP21 agreement to stop dangerous global warming

Adam Vaughan, Paris

10, Dec, 2015 @9:21 PM

Article image
François Hollande calls for 'miracle' climate agreement at Paris talks
French president says role of businesses will be key to the success of any emissions agreement reached by world’s nations at crunch climate change talks at the end of this year

Fiona Harvey

20, May, 2015 @3:33 PM

Article image
Paris climate deal is an 'opportunity to change the world'
François Hollande urges delegates to adopt agreement set to provide strong push towards curbing global warming

Lenore Taylor, Fiona Harvey and Adam Vaughan in Paris

12, Dec, 2015 @12:10 PM

Article image
Don't let Paris attacks stop COP21 climate change deal, Obama urges
US president seeks to shore up attendance at COP21 climate summit by saying world leaders had to show murderers ‘that we’re not afraid’

Fiona Harvey in London

22, Nov, 2015 @6:00 PM

Article image
Paris climate change agreement: the world's greatest diplomatic success
With all 196 nations having a say, the UN climate deal, with all its frustrations and drama, has proven that compromise works for the planet

Fiona Harvey in Paris

14, Dec, 2015 @7:51 AM

Article image
Paris climate summit march in doubt after talks deadlock
Activists object to French government proposals to scale down protest on 29 November amid security fears following terrorist attacks

Arthur Neslen and Fiona Harvey

17, Nov, 2015 @2:31 PM

Article image
Paris climate summit: world leaders told to iron out differences before talks end
France steps up diplomatic efforts to get consensus on a global deal six days before official talks conclude

Fiona Harvey and Kim Willsher in Paris

28, Nov, 2015 @7:01 AM

Article image
Paris climate talks: Bishop hails 'historic' day as nearly 200 countries sign deal
Foreign minister, who led Australia’s negotiating team, says 31-page plan setting ambitious goals to limit temperature rise offers ‘comfort’ to country

Lenore Taylor, Suzanne Goldenberg, John Vidal, Adam Vaughan and Fiona Harvey

12, Dec, 2015 @11:55 PM

Article image
Paris climate deal ‘close to finish line’ but talks set to overrun
French foreign minister calls for second all-night session to seal agreement on 20-year diplomatic process but admits talks will finish on Saturday

Suzanne Goldenberg in Paris

11, Dec, 2015 @7:56 AM