World set for climate disaster, say activists, as Lima talks falter

Proposals too weak to keep global warming to the agreed limit of two degrees above pre-industrial levels

Frustrated climate campaigners have claimed that the world was on course for an unsustainable four-degree rise in temperatures, as two weeks of negotiations for a climate change agreement headed for an unsatisfying conclusion.

The proposals, still under discussion on Saturday, a day after the talks were scheduled to end, were too weak to keep global warming to the agreed limit of two degrees above preindustrial levels, setting the world on course to a climate disaster, according to developing countries at the summit.

“We are on a path to three or four degrees with this outcome,” said Tasneem Essop, international climate strategist for WWF.

She said the final draft text, a five-page document put forward for approval on Saturday, offered little assurance of cutting emissions fast enough and deeply enough to curb warming. “We are really unhappy about the weakening of the text. This gives us no level of comfort that we will be able to close the emissions gap to get emissions to peak before 2020,” she said. Saleemul Huq, a senior fellow at the International Institute for Environment and Development, put it even more succinctly: “It sucks. It is taking us backwards.”

The disappointment with the progress of the Lima negotiations was widespread – and hugely at odds with the mood of optimism that prevailed at the opening of the talks following a historic deal between the US and China to curb carbon pollution. The deal between the world’s two biggest carbon polluters – followed just days later by a US pledge to contribute $3bn to a fund to help poor countries deal with climate change – had created a sense of momentum at the opening of the talks.

By Saturday, with exhausted negotiators forced to cancel flights and continue the talks into extra time, those upbeat sentiments were gone. “None of us is really happy,” a figure in Switzerland’s delegation told the negotiating session. “At this moment, we have to make sure we are not striving towards the lowest common denominator.”

The Malaysian delegate said the proposed deal would not hold the major polluters to account. The Democratic Republic of the Congo representative said: “This crosses all our red lines.” Sudan flatly said the proposals were unacceptable.

The talks at Lima had been charged with producing the blueprint for a climate change agreement due to be finalised in Paris at the end of next year. “Let me be frank. There are parts of this text that make me very uncomfortable and parts that are very thin,” said Tony deBrum, foreign minister of the Marshall Islands.

It was initially hoped the agreement would push the world’s large economies into making ambitious commitments to cut carbon pollution while also contributing funds and technology to protect the world’s poorest countries from climate change.

But those hopes were frustrated by the divide over whether rising economies should be under similar obligation to cut emissions as America and Europe. India – though quickly emerging as one of the world’s biggest carbon polluters – says it should not be held to similar standards as the US and EU.

By the time the final draft text appeared, it had been stripped of language that would have required the emissions cuts offered by countries to keep warming below the two-degree target. It was even unclear whether those targets would be subjected to a serious review. In an even bigger blow to small island countries, the draft made no mention of industrialised countries’ responsibility towards the small island states which are under threat of being drowned by rising seas. The accountability gap was a big disappointment for the US and the EU – which had pushed for a strong review process of such commitments – as well as the small islands.

The proposals also takes the pressure off industrialised countries to make good on promises to provide up to $100bn a year in climate finance to poor countries by 2020. “We are shocked that some of our colleagues would want to avoid a process to hold their proposed targets up to the light,” DeBrum said. “There should be nothing to hide.”

Mark Maslin, professor of climatology at University College London, said: “Though the weak text emerging from Lima is extremely disappointing, there are still 12 months for the negotiators to up their game before the critical Paris COP [UN climate talks]. Essential to this is for the negotiators to understand that the world’s public expect a global legally binding treaty. Not because it is enforceable, as we know they are not, but it shows commitment to a safe, better and hopefully more equitable world.”


Suzanne Goldenberg

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Lima climate summit extended as poor countries demand more from rich
Talks stumble amid rising frustration over ‘ridiculously low’ cash commitments offered by rich nations to help pay for emissions cuts

Suzanne Goldenberg in Lima

12, Dec, 2014 @8:04 PM

Article image
Lima climate talks agree on just one paragraph of deal with 24 hours left
As crucial UN climate summit in Peru draws to a close, negotiators have made little progress on draft text

Suzanne Goldenberg in Lima

11, Dec, 2014 @7:14 PM

Article image
UN climate change talks avoid contentious issues in draft agreement
Struggles remain on enacting 2015 Paris accord despite more clarity on emissions

Fiona Harvey in Katowice

15, Dec, 2018 @12:39 PM

Article image
Lima climate talks: pledge to plant 20m hectares of trees
Global plan to plant hundreds of millions of trees will save over 1bn tonnes of CO2 a year and restore degraded land as natural forests or as agro-forestry

John Vidal

08, Dec, 2014 @6:03 PM

Article image
Lima climate talks: South American diplomats hopeful of progress on deal
Regional powers like Brazil and Peru see themselves as key facilitators for Paris deal, but critics say they should also take bold action on emissions domestically

Jonathan Watts

09, Dec, 2014 @7:00 AM

Article image
Michael Gove bars Tory minister Amber Rudd from Lima climate change talks
Lib Dem Ed Davey, climate change secretary, goes on ahead as Tory chief whip tells MP to stay for counter-terror measures vote

Patrick Wintour, political editor

07, Dec, 2014 @7:33 PM

Article image
Copenhagen climate protesters rally
Thousands of people march as part of a global protest to demand that governments agree a new climate deal

Bibi van der Zee Copenhagen, David Batty and agencies

12, Dec, 2009 @4:58 PM

Article image
Lima climate talks: EU and US at odds over legally binding emissions targets
EU says mandatory carbon emissions cuts should be set for all countries, whereas US wants individual countries to be free to adjust the scale and pace of reductions

Dan Collyns, Lima

02, Dec, 2014 @10:19 AM

Article image
Lima climate change talks end in agreement - but who won?
This weekend’s deal on cutting greenhouse gas emissions gave everyone at the talks in Peru what they came for - sort of

Suzanne Goldenberg in Lima

14, Dec, 2014 @11:47 AM

Article image
Paris climate talks: ‘Six years on, climate change is killing fish, flooding our fields’
On the eve of the 2009 Copenhagen summit, we reported on families threatened by climate change around the world. Now, as the Paris summit nears, many of their worst fears are being realised

Robin McKie Science editor

22, Nov, 2015 @12:04 AM