Controversial herring gull cull gets green light

The environment secretary has ruled that the cull of the endangered sea birds on the Ribble Estuary can go ahead

Owen Paterson, the environment secretary, has given the green light to a controversial cull of endangered sea birds on the Ribble Estuary in Lancashire, the Guardian has learned.

The RSPB said it is "extremely concerned" that the cull of up to 475 breeding pairs of herring gulls and 552 breeding pairs of lesser black-backed gulls at BAE System's Warton aerodrome could now set a precedent for similar culls elsewhere.

The Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra) ruled that the cull could go ahead because it would not reduce the area's number of breeding seabirds by more than 25% of its designated total of 20,000 birds. The RSPB said that while it has recognised BAE Systems' concerns that the gulls present a risk to aircraft using the airfield, it fears that the 25% reduction threshold cited by Defra could now be used to justify further culls.

BAE Systems' application to cull the birds was originally rejected in 2010 by Natural England, the government agency responsible for protecting the bird species, on the grounds that it was not compatible with the conservation objectives stipulated by the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981. The Warton aerodrome lies inside an SSSI (site of special scientific interest) as well as being part of the Ribble and Alt Estuaries special protection area (SPA), meaning that its endangered bird species are afforded further conservation status and protection by the EU.

However, BAE Systems successfully appealed against Natural England's original decision, citing in part - according to documents seen by the Guardian - that Natural England had earlier given consent to a cull of lesser black backed gulls on a shooting estate on the Bowland Fells, a nearby SPA in Lancashire. Chris Packham, the BBC Springwatch presenter and naturalist, described the Bowland cull as a "travesty" when it was first reported in the Guardian last month.

BAE Systems also successfully persuaded Defra that the site's "species diversity" was not a relevant factor when assessing its total number of breeding seabirds.

Defra granted the consent to cull on 29 May and BAE Systems now has a year to complete the extermination of the birds. Appeal documents show that shooting the birds within two daily alternating "cull zones" is the preferred method. Marksmen positioned in camouflaged hides will use rifles muffled with silencers.

A Defra spokeswoman said: "After careful consideration, we have taken the decision to allow a limited number of gulls to be controlled that are impacting on air safety."

A Natural England spokeswoman said: "Natural England has been directed [by Defra] to consent control of a limited number of gulls on the Ribble Estuary that are impacting on air safety. We expect to issue the consent within the coming weeks. We continue to consider ways to minimise the impact on the estuary's important colony of seabirds, taking into consideration the safety of aircraft using BAE Warton."

A spokeswoman for BAE Systems said the company legally carried out a smaller cull of 200 breeding pairs of lesser black backed gulls in 2011 and has also been deploying "bird scaring" techniques at the airfield. However, it said that the population of birds had "grown substantially".

She added: "The population of herring gulls at the Ribble Estuary presents a risk of birdstrike to aircraft operating from Warton airfield. BAE Systems has sought to reduce this risk. Following a public inquiry, and a decision by the secretary of state, we were given consent to cull up to 475 pairs of herring gulls on Banks Marsh."

The RSPB said that it acknowledged that BAE Systems had first explored using non-lethal methods and that a cull is now necessary to the "reduce the risk [of bird strike] to a safe level". However, it said it was "extremely concerned" with the way the Defra had arrived at its decision and its "implications for the UK's wildlife".

Martin Harper, the RSPB's conservation director said: "Although we recognise the air safety risk, we believe the secretary of state's conclusion is based on a fundamental misunderstanding of wildlife protection designed to conserve the UK's best wildlife places. We strongly disagree with his interpretation that it is acceptable to lose up to a quarter of a protected site's breeding bird population without it damaging the conservation value of that site. This sets a very worrying precedent for this and similar sites across the UK."


Leo Hickman

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Legal challenge to controversial herring gull cull dismissed by judge
High Court rejects judicial review attempt by RSPB which had claimed cull in Lancashire would set dangerous precedent

Adam Vaughan and agencies

21, May, 2014 @9:49 AM

Article image
Long-awaited plan to save England's hen harrier gets green light
Conservation action plan for England’s most threatened bird of prey has taken traditionally opposing groups more than four years to agree

John Vidal

14, Jan, 2016 @2:31 PM

Article image
Conservation agency approved cull of endangered birds, documents show
Natural England licensed cull of tens of thousands of lesser black-backed gulls on one of England's largest shooting estates

Leo Hickman

23, May, 2013 @6:34 PM

Article image
Scientists prepare for mass rat cull on remote UK island

Eradication programme aims to save millions of seabirds from invasive rats on South Georgia

Lewis Smith

24, Feb, 2011 @2:57 PM

Article image
Great bustard reintroduction project gets EU funding boost
Scheme to reintroduce the world's heaviest flying bird to the UK has received £1.8m from the European Union

Press Association

19, Jan, 2011 @11:13 AM

Article image
Roxy the rockhopper penguin searches for a mate on MySpace

A lonely penguin is hoping to find a mate through the social networking website MySpace.

Hilary Osborne

13, Feb, 2007 @3:48 PM

Article image
New IUCN green status launched to help species ‘thrive, not just survive’
Conservation tool will focus on recovery efforts to give a fuller picture of threats to plant and animal populations

Patrick Greenfield

28, Jul, 2021 @6:01 AM

Article image
Ecologists unveil plan for 'barometer of natural life'

Paper co-authored by E O Wilson calls for thousands of scientists to collect information on 160,000 species deemed representative of life on Earth

Juliette Jowit

08, Apr, 2010 @6:00 PM

Article image
British birdwatchers trying to stop illegal killing of Europe's rarest birds in Malta embroiled in increasingly tense standoff with local hunters

British birdwatchers trying to stop the illegal killing of some of Europe's rarest birds in Malta have become embroiled in an increasingly tense standoff with local hunters

Matthew Weaver

30, Sep, 2008 @2:10 PM

Article image
Rare wildlife discovered in biggest nature survey along Britain's coast
Wildlife ‘firsts’ include Norfolk’s only sighting of a Balearic shearwater and a beetle not seen in Northern Ireland for more than 100 years

Jessica Aldred

11, Mar, 2016 @6:01 AM