Government's chief scientific adviser hits out at climate sceptics

Professor John Beddington dismisses 'unreasonable' comments from groups including Nigel Lawson's thinktank, as Royal Society responds to critics with new climate science guide

• UK Royal Society revives confusion as US concludes climate change certainty

The government's chief scientific adviser has hit out at climate sceptics who attack global warming science on spurious grounds.

The statements from Professor John Beddington appeared to be a veiled attack on the former Tory chancellor and arch climate sceptic Nigel Lawson.

Beddington said that he had met Lord Lawson to brief him about the science of global warming.

His comments came as the Royal Society announced that it would publish a new guide to climate science for the public following criticism of existing statements on the topic, reportedly from 43 of the society's 1,489 fellows.

"It has been suggested that the society holds the view that anyone challenging the consensus on climate change is malicious – this is ridiculous," said Professor Martin Rees, the society's president.

"Science is organised scepticism and the consensus must shift in light of the evidence.

"In the current environment we believe this new guide will be very timely. Lots of people are asking questions, indeed even within the fellowship of the society there are differing views."

In his first interview since the election, Beddington agreed that true scientific scepticism was healthy and must be encouraged but he criticised individuals and organisations that cherrypicked data for political ends.

"There is no doubt that there are organisations and individuals who will choose to characterise the science as being nonsensical on the basis of what are not reasonable criticisms," he said.

He highlighted the spurious argument that because the UK winter had been so cold, climate change science must be wrong.

Beddington said there was a difference between weather and climate. "The fact that we have had a very cold winter in Britain does not mean that the climate is not getting warmer," he said, adding that rejecting global warming on those grounds was wrong. "This is just not science. This is commentary," he said.

Lawson's thinktank, the Global Warming Policy Foundation, has deployed similar arguments to downplay the significance of climate change.

Benny Peiser, a social anthropologist at Liverpool John Moores University who is the foundation's director, said in December last year: "We look out of the window and it's very cold, it doesn't seem to be warming."

Lawson has said that "global warming ... is not at the present time happening". Peiser has previously said the GWPF does not challenge climate science but concentrates on examining policy implications.

Beddington, who gave a public lecture on climate change at the University of York yesterday, was also highly critical of the mistakes made by the UN's climate science body, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, which he called "fundamentally stupid statements".

Referring to the incorrect claim that Himalayan glaciers would melt by 2035, he said: "Nobody in their right mind would see that as even a scientific statement. There's no uncertainty, there's no caveats." But he added that overall the IPCC report had a "remarkably small number of problems".

Beddington said that he had yet to have a formal meeting with David Cameron or Nick Clegg, but he said the coalition government faced a slew of scientific and engineering issues.

"Just about anywhere I look around the portfolio of government problems in any department, there are big issues of science and engineering including social science," he said.

He highlighted climate change, obesity, the volcanic ash cloud and vigilance to pandemic influenza as pressing problems for government to address.

He said he would advise Cameron to shield funding for scientific research from future spending cuts as far as possible.

"If you then think about how the UK as an economy is going to compete in the future, the underpinning of science and engineering having the best quality students, the best quality scientists and engineers is absolutely imperative."

When asked about the BP oil spill off the coast of Louisiana, Beddington said there would be lessons for the UK.

"I think we need to understand it," he said. "I think deep offshore [drilling] presents formidable engineering problems as you can see from the attempt to actually deal with it.

"I think that one will have to be asking questions about the appropriate levels of regulation that are operating in licensing deep offshore drilling in the North Sea."


James Randerson

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Manmade global warming: a stormy meeting between sceptics and believers
House of Lords plays host to face-off featuring Lord Lawson and six of Britain's most eminent climate change scientists

Damian Carrington

13, Dec, 2013 @8:29 PM

Article image
Climate scientist at centre of email row to face questions from MPs

Scientists Phil Jones and John Beddington and sceptics Nigel Lawson and Benny Peiser among those giving evidence

David Adam, environment correspondent

01, Mar, 2010 @6:00 AM

Article image
United Nations to commission independent scientific inquiry into IPCC
UN climate body to appoint scientists to review climate change panel as UK climate change secretary writes to Rajendra Pachauri to express concern over 'damaging mistakes'

David Adam

26, Feb, 2010 @12:21 PM

UK's top scientist urges care in presenting results of climate change

• Be frank on degree of uncertainty, but as such it is no excuse for inaction
• John Beddington responds to scepticism after melting glaciers mistake

Haroon Siddique

27, Jan, 2010 @1:41 AM

Article image
IPCC vice-chair: Attacks on climate science echo tobacco industry tactics

Jean-Pascal van Ypersele says rows over 'climategate' emails and Himalayan glaciers were organised to undermine Copenhagen summit

Damian Carrington in Brussels

28, Oct, 2010 @11:44 AM

Article image
Rajendra Pachauri: Climate scientists face 'new form of persecution'
IPCC chair accuses politicians and sceptics of portraying scientists as 'criminals' through attacks on their credibility

David Adam, environment correspondent

26, Mar, 2010 @5:00 PM

Article image
BBC coverage criticised for favouring climate change sceptics

A letter from the BBC in response to the science committee's criticism defends airing 'misinformed' arguments

Fiona Harvey, environment correspondent

28, Oct, 2013 @3:49 PM

Article image
Climate change sceptics are 'headless chickens', says Prince Charles
Charles uses green awards speech at Buckingham Palace to renew attack on 'powerful groups of deniers'

Ben Quinn

31, Jan, 2014 @6:22 PM

Food crisis will take hold before climate change, warns chief scientist

Professor John Beddington raises food security and the global rush to grow biofuels in his first major speech

James Randerson, science correspondent

07, Mar, 2008 @1:18 PM

Article image
Don't hound the climate scientists | Rajendra Pachauri

Rajendra Pachauri: One regrettable mistake about glaciers doesn't alter the vast evidence there is of climate change

Rajendra Pachauri

26, Mar, 2010 @5:00 PM