Water vapour caused one-third of global warming in 1990s, study reveals

Experts say their research does not undermine the scientific consensus on man-made climate change, but call for 'closer examination' of the way computer models consider water vapour

Scientists have underestimated the role that water vapour plays in determining global temperature changes, according to a new study that could fuel further attacks on the science of climate change.

The research, led by one of the world's top climate scientists, suggests that almost one-third of the global warming recorded during the 1990s was due to an increase in water vapour in the high atmosphere, not human emissions of greenhouse gases. A subsequent decline in water vapour after 2000 could explain a recent slowdown in global temperature rise, the scientists add.

The experts say their research does not undermine the scientific consensus that emissions of greenhouse gases from human activity drive global warming, but they call for "closer examination" of the way climate computer models consider water vapour.

The new research comes at a difficult time for climate scientists, who have been forced to defend their predictions in the face of an embarrassing mistake in the 2007 report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), which included false claims that Himalayan glaciers could melt away by 2035. There has also been heavy criticism over the way climate scientists at the University of East Anglia apparently tried to prevent the release of data requested under Freedom of Information laws.

The new research, led by Susan Solomon, at the US National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, who co-chaired the 2007 IPCC report on the science of global warming, is published today in the journal Science, one of the most respected in the world.

Solomon said the new finding does not challenge the conclusion that human activity drives climate change. "Not to my mind it doesn't," she said. "It shows that we shouldn't over-interpret the results from a few years one way or another."

She would not comment on the mistake in the IPCC report - which was published in a separate section on likely impacts - or on calls for Rajendra Pachauri, the IPCC chairman, to step down.

"What I will say, is that this [new study] shows there are climate scientists round the world who are trying very hard to understand and to explain to people openly and honestly what has happened over the last decade."

The new study analysed water vapour in the stratosphere, about 10 miles up, where it acts as a potent greenhouse gas and traps heat at the Earth's surface.

Satellite measurements were used to show that water vapour levels in the stratosphere have dropped about 10% since 2000. When the scientists fed this change into a climate model, they found it could have reduced, by about 25% over the last decade, the amount of warming expected to be caused by carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases.

They conclude: "The decline in stratospheric water vapour after 2000 should be expected to have significantly contributed to the flattening of the global warming trend in the last decade."

Solomon said: "We call this the 10, 10, 10 problem. A 10% drop in water vapour, 10 miles up has had an effect on global warming over the last 10 years." Until now, scientists have struggled to explain the temperature slowdown in the years since 2000, a problem climate sceptics have exploited.

The scientists also looked at the earlier period, from 1980 to 2000, though cautioned this was based on observations of the atmosphere made by a single weather balloon. They found likely increases in water vapour in the stratosphere, enough to enhance the rate of global warming by about 30% above what would have been expected.

"These findings show that stratospheric water vapour represents an important driver of decadal global surface climate change," the scientists say. They say it should lead to a "closer examination of the representation of stratospheric water vapour changes in climate models".

Solomon said it was not clear why the water vapour levels had swung up and down, but suggested it could be down to changes in sea surface temperature, which drives convection currents and can move air around in the high atmosphere.

She said it was not clear if the water vapour decrease after 2000 reflects a natural shift, or if it was a consequence of a warming world. If the latter is true, then more warming could see greater decreases in water vapour, acting as a negative feedback to apply the brakes on future temperature rise.


David Adam, environment correspondent

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Scientists polled at Copenhagen climate conference fear worst on global warming

Poll of attendees at Copenhagen climate conference exposes gulf between political rhetoric and expert opinion

David Adam, environment correspondent

13, Apr, 2009 @11:01 PM

Article image
China's top climatologist stays cool over 2C rise
It is too early to determine the level of meteorological risk posed by global warming, says director-general of the Beijing Climate Centre

Jonathan Watts, Asia environment correspondent

17, Sep, 2009 @2:48 PM

Article image
The tropics on fire: scientist's grim vision of global warming

Temperature rises will turn damp and humid forests into parched tinderboxes, warns Dr Chris Field

Ian Sample, science correspondent

16, Feb, 2009 @12:01 AM

Article image
United Nations to commission independent scientific inquiry into IPCC
UN climate body to appoint scientists to review climate change panel as UK climate change secretary writes to Rajendra Pachauri to express concern over 'damaging mistakes'

David Adam

26, Feb, 2010 @12:21 PM

Article image
Rajendra Pachauri: Climate scientists face 'new form of persecution'
IPCC chair accuses politicians and sceptics of portraying scientists as 'criminals' through attacks on their credibility

David Adam, environment correspondent

26, Mar, 2010 @5:00 PM

Article image
Met Office warns of catastrophic global warming in our lifetimes

Study says 4C rise in temperature could happen by 2060 without strong action on emissions

David Adam, environment correspondent

27, Sep, 2009 @11:06 PM

Article image
Sea level could rise more than a metre by 2100, say experts

New study in Greenland indicates that ice sheets are melting faster than 10 years ago and the implications could be severe

David Adam in Copenhagen

11, Mar, 2009 @12:01 AM

Article image
Met Office to release records that show global temperature rise

Records from nearly 2,000 stations worldwide may cool debate over leaked emails from University of East Anglia

Alok Jha

07, Dec, 2009 @5:20 PM

Article image
Climate change emails between scientists reveal flaws in peer review | Fred Pearce

Fred Pearce: A close reading of the hacked emails exposes the real process of science, its jealousies and tribalism

Fred Pearce

02, Feb, 2010 @6:27 PM

Article image
India 'arrogant' to deny global warming link to melting glaciers
IPCC chairman Rajendra Pachauri accuses Indian environment ministry of 'arrogance' for its report claiming there is no evidence that climate change has shrunk Himalayan glaciers

Randeep Ramesh in Delhi

09, Nov, 2009 @4:17 PM