Flagship eco-town plan falters in tough climate

Only two of the 10 sites originally promised by Gordon Brown are now expected to be built

Gordon Brown's flagship plan to build a string of environmentally friendly 'eco-towns' across Britain has been dealt a critical blow, with only two of the 10 sites promised now expected to be built.

The model green communities, where residents would be able to do without cars and grow their own food on allotments, were billed as the most imaginative answer to putting roofs over heads in half a century. But the plans are now in jeopardy thanks to a combination of the credit crunch, a collapsing construction industry and fierce local opposition.

Officials at the Department for Communities and Local Government have concluded only 'one or two' of the 15 shortlisted projects are genuinely viable, according to a source close to the discussions. The Eco-Towns Challenge Panel, appointed by ministers to ensure the plans were genuinely green, is understood to have reached similar conclusions. Some bidders have already dropped out, while others are said to have been alarmed by the house price crash and the collapse in sales.

The final decision on how many should go forward is yet to be taken by Margaret Beckett, the new housing minister. But she failed to mention either eco-towns or the government's wider target to build three million new homes by 2020 - which housing experts are also now openly questioning - when she made her first speech to the Home Builders Federation's annual conference last week.

The news comes as Brown prepares to hail green industries tomorrow as a new source of job creation in Britain. Geoff Hoon, the Transport Secretary, will announce plans to boost the manufacture of electric cars which ministers hope could become more appealing, as they are exempt from congestion charges and also save on petrol. He will announce a £20m grant for businesses to buy electric vans.

Eco-towns are, however, central to Brown's vision for the environment. They were one of the first major ideas he announced within days of becoming Labour leader, pledging thousands of new homes in every part of the country. Four months later, he doubled his original target of five towns because of interest in the scheme, adding: 'For the first time in nearly half a century we will show the imagination to build new towns - eco-towns with low- and zero-carbon homes.'

Although only a small amount of the three million planned new homes, eco-towns were intended to encourage other builders.

'The government will probably say it's all to do with the economic climate but I think the mistake was their approach to the subject,' said Grant Shapps, the Tory housing spokesman.

'They came up with a good idea but they messed it up by going for a top-down "ministers know best where they should go" approach.'

A spokesman for the Department for Communities and Local Government insisted the programme would remain on track.


Gaby Hinsliff, political editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

So, just how green will the eco-towns be?

Robert Booth examines Gordon Brown's utopian vision for housing in the 21st century

Robert Booth

12, Jul, 2008 @11:01 PM

'Secret' eco-town plans spark protest

Government will soon unveil 10 sites nationwide

Jo Revill and Caroline Davies

10, Feb, 2008 @3:01 PM

Long Marston eco town faces legal challenge

Government faces prospect of legal challenge against plans for building 10 eco towns across England

Jo Revill

24, May, 2008 @11:01 PM

Article image
Grass roots rise against the eco-towns

Opposition is growing among rural communities who feel they have been deliberately kept in the dark. Jo Revill and Caroline Davies report

Jo Revill and Caroline Davies

10, Feb, 2008 @3:01 PM

Ministers hit back at stars over eco-towns

Public five to one in favour of eco-towns despite protests of high-profile residents

Juliette Jowit, environment editor

28, Jun, 2008 @11:01 PM

Article image
MPs sit in judgment in conservation versus construction planning battle

Campaigners to air their views on George Osborne-Eric Pickles proposals to relax regulations

Fiona Harvey, environment correspondent

16, Oct, 2011 @5:30 PM

New eco-towns to ease house crisis
Chancellor promises 100,000 low-emission homes to trump Cameron's green credentials.

Nicholas Watt and Jo Revill

13, May, 2007 @8:57 AM

Ecotowns plan may be illegal, say local government lawyers

Legal challenge latest controversy in housing programme faced with rising rural property prices

Allegra Stratton, political correspondent

23, Jul, 2008 @11:01 PM

Article image
Tories' long and winding road to sensible planning | Simon Jenkins

Simon Jenkins: At last the government has reined in the cowboy lobbyists and allowed urban renewal to trump rural development

Simon Jenkins

27, Mar, 2012 @7:35 PM

Article image
Environment: Queen and Charles join race to build government-sponsored ecotowns

Prince's foundation for Built Enivironment is asked to advise on design and to ensure local community input

James Meikle

08, Jul, 2008 @11:01 PM