How to dislodge the posh clique that rules Britain | Letters

Simon Bull asks for discrimination against the state-educated to be outlawed, and other readers write on Oxbridge and Eton domination

Like John Harris, I went from a comprehensive school to Oxbridge, and my experience was very similar to his (To understand the Zahawi story and Tory sleaze, look no further than Britain’s posh cliques, 29 January). The consequences of this for all in society are becoming increasingly clear.

It puzzles me very greatly that in an era when we have rightly banned direct and indirect discrimination in many forms, discrimination against the massive majority of the population who attended state schools remains lawful and (particularly in its indirect form) common. This form of discrimination affects far more people than any other.

Why is the reception of a state education not made a protected characteristic under the discrimination legislation? Then former public school boys and girls would no longer be able to ensure their own gross overrepresentation in the ranks of those who hold positions of power and influence.
Simon Bull
Claydon, Oxfordshire

• John Harris’s analysis of the “posh clique ruling us” is a powerful account of the way educational privilege is used to obtain positions of power and influence. He then tells us that in 1989 he went to Oxford University.

Chris Elliott, then readers’ editor, dealt with this issue in 2011. A round robin of journalists on the Guardian and Observer garnered 178 responses out of 630 journalists. Of the replies, 67 went to either Oxford or Cambridge. That is 37% of the replies, or 10% of the total number of journalists – a significant chunk of Oxbridge graduates for any newspaper, let alone the Guardian.

The issue that John raises of a posh clique infiltrating positions of power is important but complex. To imagine that Oxbridge is the fundamental problem is to ignore the significance of many other prestigious universities targeted by public schools. I fully support John’s argument for reform and positive discrimination. Where that leaves the Guardian is intriguing.
Peter Martindale
Castle Bytham, Lincolnshire

• John Harris is so right about the posh clique of public school alumni and their malign influence. He then tells us about his education history. And yet he did not name the comprehensive school or the state-sector sixth-form college that he attended. Let’s hear it for state education and promote these schools in the way that Eton promotes itself.
Janet Mansfield
Aspatria, Cumbria

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
George Orwell was right, private schools bar moves towards a fairer society | Letters
Letters: Jol Miskin and Margaret Tulloch on what Labour may do about private education, and Robert Harding and John Lancaster on the Oxbridge intake from state schools


15, Sep, 2019 @3:47 PM

Article image
The class pay gap: why it pays to be privileged
The long read: Within Britain’s elite occupations, the advantages of class are still mistaken for talent

Sam Friedman and Daniel Laurison

07, Feb, 2019 @6:00 AM

Article image
The class divide in Oxbridge interviews | Letters
Letters: David Butler says interviewers at Oxford and Cambridge take into account the background of candidates when assessing them, while Mike Rogers recalls a clash of class and accent at his 60s interview at Jesus College


12, Dec, 2018 @5:48 PM

Article image
Nadhim Zahawi’s Oxbridge claim is an insult to state school students | Letters
Letters: Michael Pyke takes issue with Nadhim Zahawi’s argument that it is up to state schools to improve access to elite universities. Plus letters from Richard Duckworth, Gerald Sandison and Nigel Gann


18, May, 2022 @5:11 PM

Article image
How to fix Oxbridge’s biased admissions system | Letters
Letters: Readers discuss ways to make entry to Oxford and Cambridge fairer to students from state schools


10, Dec, 2018 @5:14 PM

Article image
The strange dialect of an Oxbridge elite
Letters: Stan Godfrey and Ivor Morgan discuss how upper class patois can be baffling to those from different backgrounds


26, Sep, 2019 @5:09 PM

Article image
Tackling the damage done to the UK by private schools | Letters
Letters: Readers respond to an article by John Harris claiming Britain’s current crisis is rooted in the power of our public schools


20, Mar, 2019 @6:18 PM

Article image
Britain is still ruled by a privately educated elite. Let’s end this culture of deference | Rhiannon Lucy Cosslett
The baffling preference by employers (and voters) for people from expensive schools blocks progress and innovation, says Guardian columnist Rhiannon Lucy Cosslett

Rhiannon Lucy Cosslett

25, Jun, 2019 @11:01 AM

Article image
The Guardian view on private schools: motors of unfairness | Editorial
Editorial: Social mobility has stalled and inequalities between schools play an important part. It’s time to even things up


12, Feb, 2019 @6:33 PM

Article image
Down with the meritocratic elite | Letters
Letters: Michael Meadowcroft on how to establish a less divisive society and Susan Finlay on how to overcome a lack of diversity in publishing


25, Jan, 2019 @4:16 PM