‘The government hasn’t listened’: teachers in England criticise pay offer

Delegates at NEU conference are angry that school budgets would be expected to fund most of wage rise

Charlotte Lawrence has been a primary school teacher for 14 years and has one word for the government’s latest pay offer for teachers in England: insulting.

“The government hasn’t listened,” said Lawrence, a delegate at the National Education Union’s annual conference in Harrogate. “When the strike ballot was carried, I thought the government would see that teachers are serious and start to negotiate. But it just hasn’t happened.”

Lawrence and other teachers at the conference say pay alone is not what drove 98% of nearly 200,000 NEU members to reject the offer. What has angered them is that school budgets would be expected to fund most of the pay increase – forcing teachers to choose between their own spending and resources and staff for their pupils. Teachers outside the conference chanted: “Hey, Gill, now it’s time to pay the bill,” in a message to the education secretary, Gillian Keegan.

“I know a school in Portsmouth that has 10 pencils to last until the end of the academic year,” said Lawrence, who worries that some school budgets are so tightly stretched that having to find even part of the pay rise promised by the government would be too difficult.

“As a profession we need well-remunerated teachers and well-funded schools. We should be able to have both.”

Laura Beckham, a special needs teacher in Consett, County Durham, said it was insulting that any pay rise was not being fully funded, especially for schools that were already struggling.

Her school’s building is badly in need of refurbishment and expansion, having 100 pupils with special educational needs and disabilities despite having capacity for 64, with wheelchairs having to be stacked in the corridors to make room.

“If it’s an unfunded pay rise then I’m going to lose teaching assistants,” Beckham said. “I can’t afford to lose teaching assistants.”

The government’s pay offer was a £1,000 one-off payment for the current school year, and a pay rise for 2023-24 that amounted to 4.3% for experienced teachers such as Beckham and Lawrence, but more for newly qualified teachers, with starting salaries rising to £30,000.

But only the one-off payment and a small portion of the pay rise from September would be funded by new money from the government. The rest would be from existing budgets, which the government argues have room to afford it because of the additional £2.4bn being allocated nationally in each of the next two years.

Natalie Perera, the chief executive of the Education Policy Institute, said that even after the extra funding, the government’s analysis showed there was only just about enough headroom to cover the current pay offer and the increased school costs arising from inflation, while other services are being slashed.

“It’s likely that school leaders and teachers are not just worried about their pay, but also about having enough resources to support pupils’ education and wellbeing, particularly for the most vulnerable and disadvantaged,” Perera said.

The prime minister’s official spokesperson said: “We remain open to further discussions but we felt this was a fair and reasonable offer. As it stands, now that the membership with the NEU have voted against it, talks on pay or the setting of pay will fall to the independent pay review body.”

But Lawrence, like many of her colleagues in Harrogate, was buoyed up by the overwhelming vote against the government’s offer: “The message is that we are united – and we don’t have a choice.”

Contributor

Richard Adams Education editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Strong rejection of pay offer in England shows teachers’ fury, says union
NEU says vote by 98% to 2% sends clear message that government’s offer is insulting and will not do

Richard Adams and Peter Walker

03, Apr, 2023 @2:56 PM

Article image
One in three young teachers in England skipping meals to make ends meet
NEU survey also finds one in five teachers aged 29 or under have taken on a second job as pay fails to keep up with cost of living

Richard Adams Education editor

05, Apr, 2023 @5:01 AM

Article image
‘United front’ of teachers could launch biggest strikes in a decade in England
New head of National Education Union says four unions could take action in autumn over pay dispute

Richard Adams Education editor

05, Jul, 2023 @4:00 AM

Article image
Striking teachers in England accused of undermining pupils’ pandemic recovery
Education secretary Gillian Keegan says she ‘can’t think of a worse time’ for action by NEU members

Richard Adams Education editor

05, Jul, 2023 @6:10 PM

Article image
Teaching unions in England urge ministers to resume pay talks
Call comes as independent review body to recommend 6.5% pay rise for teachers in England

Richard Adams Education editor

21, May, 2023 @10:30 AM

Article image
Opposition grows among teachers to 6.5% pay offer in England
Union members are concerned about funding for the below-inflation increase and the lack of a long-term agreement

Richard Adams Education editor

16, Jul, 2023 @4:48 PM

Article image
New teachers' salary in England could reach £30,000, says DfE
Announcement is part of plans to increase recruitment and improve profession’s status

Richard Adams Education editor

01, Sep, 2019 @11:01 PM

Article image
Give teachers in England a deal similar to nurses to avoid strikes, says union
Patrick Roach of NASUWT calls on education secretary Gillian Keegan to reopen pay talks

Richard Adams Education editor

09, Apr, 2023 @2:35 PM

Article image
Teachers in England and Wales facing ‘unmanageable’ workload, survey finds
National Education Union reports findings before result of vote that could trigger further strikes and school closures

Richard Adams Education editor

02, Apr, 2023 @11:01 PM

Article image
Teachers in England and Wales vote to strike as nurses prepare further action
Thousands of schools set to close as NEU members plan mass strike on 1 February, followed by regional stoppages

Sally Weale and Denis Campbell

16, Jan, 2023 @7:13 PM