UK pupils failed by schools’ teaching of climate crisis, experts say

Many teachers and pupils frustrated over climate education despite ministers’ pledge to prioritise it

Britain’s children are being failed by schools when it comes to learning about the climate crisis, with the subject often wholly missing from the curriculum, sidelined, or mistaught, students and education experts have said.

A private member’s bill that would require basic knowledge of climate issues to be taught in the national curriculum receives its second reading in parliament on Friday with cross-party support. But it is unlikely to make it to the statute books, despite promises at Cop26 last November that ministers would prioritise climate education in schools.

Nadia Whittome, the Labour MP who brought forward the bill, said: “The education system should be helping young people to get informed on the impacts of climate change – it’s their lives that will be affected. It’s also part of how we will reach net zero – give young people the tools to be part of the solution.”

Nadhim Zahawi, the education secretary, pledged at Cop26 to “put climate change at the heart of education”. A draft strategy is due to be published in April. The Guardian has reported that an early version told teachers not to advise pupils to get involved in climate protests.

However, students and experts said the UK was failing to equip young people with the skills they will need to understand and cope with the climate emergency.

A survey of 4,680 teachers in England found that two-thirds of secondary school teachers felt climate change was not taught in a meaningful way within their subject, even though nine out of 10 said the climate was relevant to their subject area. Four in 10 teachers said they would like more time and capacity to devote to climate issues, as well as more cross-subject collaboration.

Students have described their frustration at the lack of opportunities and resources to discuss the climate crisis in class. Scarlett Westbrook, 17, from Birmingham, who helped to write the climate education bill, faced a question on her geography GCSE paper in 2020 requiring her to list benefits from climate change. She complied, to get the marks, but also wrote that any benefits were vastly outweighed by the damage – a note that was criticised by the exam marker.

“I was shocked to be asked that. To have to write that to get marks was a really weird dilemma – should I spite the education system or spike my exams?” she said. “I think there has been influence from lobby groups, and that’s why the education on this subject is so bad.”

Phoebe Hanson, a second-year politics student at Lancaster University, said young people had a right to expect the education system to inform them about and equip them to understand the crisis. “We are growing up in this world where the climate is changing. The immensity of that is terrifying. But in our education system, this subject is just tacked on the side. We are letting people down,” she said.

Matt Carmichael, an English teacher in Leeds, said teachers felt under pressure to be cautious about discussing the climate crisis. “I educated myself on the issue, but I know colleagues who lack the confidence and know this as a controversial subject that they don’t feel equipped to teach,” he said. “It’s vital that we do teach it as there is lots of misinformation out there, especially on social media, and lots of anxiety among young people.”

Education is a devolved issue, and the survey, by the Teach the Future campaign, applied only to England. However, Teach the Future covers all four UK nations, and it said schoolchildren were poorly served on climate education across the UK.

A spokesperson for the Department for Education said: “Topics related to climate change already feature across the curriculum at primary and secondary school. By 2023, all teachers in all phases and subjects will have access to high-quality curriculum resources, so they can confidently choose those that will support the teaching of sustainability and climate change.

“Our new sustainability and climate change strategy will help empower all teachers to deliver education on climate change. From aiding the development of climate interests in early childhood right through to the skills needed for green careers. It also goes beyond the classroom – children and young people will get hands-on experience of understanding, nurturing and protecting the biodiversity around them through our new national education nature park and climate leaders awards.”


Fiona Harvey Environment correspondent

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Climate change should be excluded from curriculum, says adviser

Head of government review says school syllabus needs to 'get back to the science in science'

Jessica Shepherd

12, Jun, 2011 @9:00 PM

Letters: Climate curriculum
Letters: There is a vital distinction between what the national curriculum should prescribe as core scientific knowledge and the vast range of issues that can and should be discussed in schools that need not be listed in the national curriculum

16, Jun, 2011 @8:15 PM

Article image
Michael Gove abandons plans to drop climate change from curriculum
Climate change will stay on geography syllabus after lobbying from energy secretary Ed Davey

Patrick Wintour

05, Jul, 2013 @4:08 PM

Letters: Crucial lessons in climate change
Letters: It appears contradictory for a government that aspires to be the "greenest ever" to remove from the issue of climate change from the national science curriculum

21, Jun, 2011 @8:00 PM

Article image
Disadvantaged pupils learning watered-down curriculum, says Ofsted
Chief inspector of schools says focus on ‘badges and stickers’ instead of learning and substance could limit social mobility

Richard Adams Education editor

11, Oct, 2017 @1:12 PM

Article image
Michael Gove's own experts revolt over 'punitive' model for curriculum
Education secretary has been bypassing the panel set up to advise on reforms, claim senior members

Daniel Boffey, policy editor

16, Jun, 2012 @11:06 PM

Article image
Michael Gove's disdain for experts is typical of the laissez-faire ideologues | David Priestland
David Priestland: Consultation on the new curriculum is closed but no matter. Gove, like the rest of his government, will do what he believes in

David Priestland

18, Apr, 2013 @5:40 PM

Article image
Pupils will have to know times tables by age 11 under new tests
Schools in England to use on-screen tests for first time, providing instant results on tables up to 12x12

Haroon Siddique

03, Jan, 2016 @10:30 AM

Article image
Curriculum experts say Gove's plans could lower standards
Leaked papers show that experts employed to advise the government on the new national curriculum say it lacks rigour, and in English could lower standards of reading

Warwick Mansell

24, Jun, 2013 @6:30 PM

Article image
The national curriculum barely mentions the climate crisis. Children deserve better | Fiona Harvey
The emergency should not be taught just in science, but in history, the arts and food tech too

Fiona Harvey

11, Feb, 2020 @7:15 AM