GOP state senator walks back comments on Nazi history in schools

Scott Baldwin faced backlash after his comments during a hearing on Senate Bill 167, which would ban ‘concepts that divide’ in schools

An Indiana state senator has backtracked on his remarks that teachers must be impartial when discussing nazism in classrooms after he sparked widespread backlash.

During a state senate committee hearing last week about Senate Bill 167, a proposed bill that would ban “concepts that divide”, the Republican senator Scott Baldwin, who co-wrote the bill, said teachers should remain unprejudiced when teaching lessons about fascism and nazism.

“Marxism, nazism, fascism … I have no problem with the education system providing instruction on the existence of those ‘isms’,” Baldwin said, adding, “I believe we’ve gone too far when we take a position … We need to be impartial.” He went on to say that teachers should “just provide the facts” and that he is “not sure it’s right for us to determine how that child should think and that’s where I’m trying to provide the guardrails”.

Baldwin has since walked back on his remarks. In an email to the Indianapolis Star last Thursday, he said that his intention with the bill was to make sure teachers are being impartial when discussing and teaching “legitimate political groups”.

“When I was drafting this bill, my intent with regard to ‘political affiliation’ was to cover political parties within the legal American political system,” Baldwin said. “In my comments during committee, I was thinking more about the big picture and trying to say that we should not tell kids what to think about politics.”

He went on to denounce the aforementioned ideologies, saying, “nazism, Marxism and fascism are a stain on our world history and should be regarded as such, and I failed to adequately articulate that in my comments during the meeting. I believe that kids should learn about these horrible events in history so that we don’t experience them again in humanity.”

SB 167 was filed in recent weeks in response to the fierce debates that have emerged across Indiana and the rest of the country in the past year regarding the ways schools should teach children about racism, history and other subject matters.

The bill prohibits kindergarten through 12th grade schools from teaching students that “any sex, race, ethnicity, religion, color, national origin, or political affiliation” is inherently superior, inferior, racist, sexist, oppressive. Teachers would also be prohibited from making individuals feel “discomfort, guilt, anguish, responsibility or any other form of psychological distress” when it comes to meritocracy and the notion that it was created by one group to oppress another.

The bill also prohibits teachers and curriculums from teaching that Indiana and the United States was founded as a racist or sexist state or nation.

The midwest chapter of the Anti-Defamation League has criticized Baldwin’s apology, arguing that it “doesn’t change the deep harms of using ‘impartiality’ or ‘neutrality’ as tools to sanitize history”.

“This is part of the continued efforts by some to try and rewrite history and characterize extremism, racism, and genocide as somehow legitimate. That is dangerous and despicable. It should be categorically, universally, and loudly rejected,” the organization added.

The incident comes less than three months after a north Texas school official said that classrooms with books on Holocaust must offer “opposing” viewpoints.

Contributor

Maya Yang

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Republican senator says ‘I don’t want reality’ in hearing on race and education
Markwayne Mullin of Oklahoma says he ‘misspoke’ when questioning witness about childcare and teaching of race

Martin Pengelly in New York

01, Jun, 2023 @12:02 PM

Article image
Texas board of education vote is critical for conservatives – and US schools
Board has become a battleground as members seek to stamp their values on textbooks, and now an extreme conservative is on the brink of a key position

Tom Dart in Houston

24, May, 2016 @1:04 PM

Article image
US conservatives linked to rich donors wage campaign to ban books from schools
Experts warn trend is accelerating as groups push for bans of works that often address race, LGBTQ issues and marginalized people

Adam Gabbatt

24, Jan, 2022 @10:00 AM

Article image
Florida schools plan to use only excerpts from Shakespeare to avoid ‘raunchiness’
DeSantis law that clamps down on LGBTQ+and gender issues also says material sexual in nature should not be used in classes

Martin Pengelly in Washington

08, Aug, 2023 @4:52 PM

Article image
Idaho governor signs bill to ban critical race theory from being taught in schools
Theory states that racism is embedded in US history and modern American law, and that legal institutions are inherently racist

Mike Jordan

06, May, 2021 @12:00 PM

Article image
Last Best Hope review: George Packer’s elegant dissection of America in crisis
Like his hero, George Orwell, the Atlantic writer is not afraid to look to his own – liberals, the media – and prescribe harsh cures

Charles Kaiser

20, Jun, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
Asian American history to be taught in all Illinois public schools
State will be first in US to ensure students learn about Asian Americans’ contributions to the nation’s culture and history

Sarah Betancourt

13, Jul, 2021 @3:03 PM

Article image
Top Virginia Republican apologizes for misgendering Democratic state senator
Lieutenant governor Winsome Earle-Sears misgendered Danica Roem, the first transgender person to serve in any state legislature

Erum Salam

27, Feb, 2024 @5:40 PM

Article image
Schwarzenegger rebukes Trump and compares Capitol riot to Kristallnacht
Ex-Republican governor of California compares US democracy to sword wielded by Conan the Barbarian in video address

Martin Pengelly in New York

10, Jan, 2021 @8:51 PM

Article image
As Trump declares independence, Cruz slams academic over another Paris deal
Texas senator and Dr Joyce Chaplin exchange fire over whether treaty signed 233 years before climate deal saw US ‘created by international community’

Joanna Walters

04, Jun, 2017 @11:00 AM