UK universities ‘too slow’ to address staff-student sexual relationships

New guidance says ‘given the power differentials’ relationships should be ‘strongly discouraged’

Universities must “strongly discourage” sexual relationships between staff and students, according to official new guidance aimed at tackling staff-to-student sexual misconduct in higher education.

The recommendations fall short of banning relationships between consenting adults, but where they occur staff should be removed from all responsibilities where there could be a conflict of interests.

The new guidance drawn up by Universities UK, which represents the sector, acknowledges universities have been too slow to address the problem of staff-to-student sexual misconduct.

It warns vice-chancellors against using non disclosure agreements (NDAs) – or confidentiality clauses – to silence complainants in settlement agreements in cases of sexual misconduct or sexual harassment.

The guidance calls on universities to create an inclusive and positive culture, backed up by clear policies, practices, reporting and data, to support and protect students when they make complaints and prevent future staff-to-student sexual misconduct.

“Our universities have been too slow to address this issue, which affects every institution,” said Prof Cara Aitchison, the vice-chancellor of Cardiff Metropolitan University and the chair of the advisory group that drew up the guidance.

“We must now be seen to make rapid progress to right this wrong. Preventing and addressing staff-to-student sexual misconduct is, fundamentally, about doing the right thing. We also need to act to comply with a legal duty of care, and to safeguard the reputation and position of our universities.”

The report says there is limited evidence on staff-to-student sexual misconduct, but research by the Guardian, the National Union of Students and the 1752 Group, which has led the way in the battle to end staff sexual misconduct in higher education, has raised concerns about the scale of the problem and the way in which universities deal with it.

According to the report, titled “Changing the culture: tackling staff-to-student sexual misconduct,” the vast majority of complaints are made by female students about male staff, postgraduate students are more likely to be targeted than undergraduates, and the issue often goes unreported.

It damages educational experiences and can lead to students dropping out, while the use of NDAs can help perpetrators to move from one university to another with their reputation intact and the same person can end up offending in multiple institutions.

On staff-student relationships and the unequal balance of power, it says: “While we recognise the autonomy of universities, given the power differentials and professional relationship between staff and students, we recommend that close, personal relationships between staff and students are strongly discouraged by universities.

“This is especially important where there is a direct professional responsibility. Where relationships do occur, the staff member should be removed from all responsibilities that may entail a perceived or actual conflict of interest and/or abuse of power.

“Universities should, where appropriate, and in accordance with data protection and human rights legislation, require staff members to declare any close, personal relationships they have with students, for whom they have a direct responsibility. A failure to declare can be treated as a disciplinary matter.”

Michelle Donelan, the minister for higher and further education, said more than 30 universities have so far signed up to a pledge she launched in January to end the use of NDAs, adding: “Universities have a profound responsibility to protect students from sexual misconduct, especially when perpetrated by those in positions of power such as a member of staff, so I welcome this timely guidance.”


Sally Weale Education correspondent

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
UK universities and colleges face three days of strikes in December
Staff at 58 institutions voted to strike over pay and conditions and to stop cuts to pensions

Richard Adams Education editor

16, Nov, 2021 @5:51 PM

Article image
'Abuse of power': should universities ban staff-student relationships?
UCL has become the third UK university to ban relationships between lecturers and their students. Should others follow?

Rachel Hall and David Batty

26, Feb, 2020 @11:00 AM

Article image
Universities urged to hire staff to investigate sexual harassment
Report commissioned by Office for Students also calls for hate crimes to receive greater focus

Richard Adams Education editor

11, Jun, 2019 @11:05 PM

Article image
University sex abuse report fails to tackle staff attacks on UK students
Recommendations include action to prevent violence against women, harassment and hate crime

Sally Weale and David Batty

20, Oct, 2016 @11:01 PM

Article image
UK universities accused of failing to tackle sexual misconduct
Guardian investigation finds many have not enacted reforms to support and protect victims

David Batty and Elena Cherubini

28, Mar, 2018 @4:30 AM

Article image
Senior UK academics protest over pay and working conditions
Professors say they will not act as external examiners, potentially disrupting students’ results

Richard Adams Education editor

22, Jan, 2020 @6:25 PM

Article image
Universities failing to tackle sex harassment by staff, says report
Only one sexual misconduct case out of 16 led to a staff member losing their job

Sally Weale Education correspondent

25, Sep, 2018 @11:01 PM

Article image
UK universities’ tuition income rises by a third, outpacing staff pay
Staff ‘will be sickened’ by £21.5bn takings while salaries of lecturers rose by just 10%, says union leader

Rachel Hall

30, Jun, 2021 @5:59 PM

Article image
Sexual harassment rife in UK universities, warns staff union
One in 10 college staff experienced sexual violence, with women, disabled, LGBTQ+ and minority ethnic people more at risk

Rachel Hall

22, Dec, 2021 @12:01 AM

Article image
UK universities brace for strike action in pensions dispute
Union rejects offer of limited rises in pension contributions in return for strike ban

Richard Adams Education editor

25, Aug, 2019 @11:10 AM