Curbing political topics in English schools will harm minority students, say critics

Restrictions on critical debate in classrooms risks taking away safe spaces for students to discuss issues that impact them, experts argue

Restrictions on political topics in schools will harm young people by curbing discussions about the polarised arguments and issues they are exposed to on social media, according to the government’s former mental health champion.

Natasha Devon said young people from minority backgrounds stood to be the biggest losers if the new guidelines meant teachers in England were afraid to provide students with a safe environment to debate issues.

“I work with 14- to 18-year-olds and my experience is that young people are bringing ideas from social media, from activists that they admire, into the classroom,” said Devon, who was the first ever mental health champion for schools.

“Teachers are trying to help them to make sense of those ideas, and discuss them in a way that is non-partisan. But the desire to address these things in the classroom is 100% coming from young people, it’s a not a case of indoctrination by teachers.”

This week the education secretary, Nadhim Zahawi, published guidance aimed at teachers in England, as part of an effort by the government to dampen down critical debate about the history of the British empire, and controversy over the role of leaders such as Winston Churchill.

The guidance – which is a reformulation of existing statutory regulations and legal duties – stresses the need for impartiality when teaching “contentious” issues such as imperialism. It cautions teachers against adopting or advocating “extreme” political positions such as those it claims are espoused by the Black Lives Matter movement, which is singled out by name in the document as needing to be balanced.

But Devon compared the guidance to the section 28 regulations concerning classroom discussion of homosexuality in force during the late 1980s and 1990s.

“With section 28 it didn’t say you can’t talk about homosexuality, it said you were not allowed to ‘promote’ homosexuality,” she said. “But what ended up happening is that no one talked about it and I think the same thing is going to happen now, which will harm minority students by taking away their space to explore issues like race and social justice that are affecting them all the time.”

Rowena Seabrook, Amnesty International UK’s humans rights education manager, agreed, saying: “The government’s guidance for schools is unnecessary – and it will have a chilling effect in classrooms across the country.

“Suggesting that teachers should not use material from social justice movements such as Black Lives Matter is entirely partisan, and lacks balance and safe spaces for students to explore issues labelled ‘controversial’.”

Natasha Robinson, a researcher at the University of Oxford who studies how controversial subjects are taught in history classrooms, said the guidance “leaves teachers with the impression that they could be bludgeoned for most of what they teach”.

She added: “Giving teachers a list of thing that they shouldn’t talk about, or of things they should avoid, is very different from giving them practical strategies in the classroom. When a student makes a racist comment or a very partisan political comment, how do teachers deal with that? That takes a great deal of skill. And this report – because it’s so vague – just comes across as scare-mongering.”

Nick Lowles, chief executive of Hope Not Hate, a campaigning antifascism and antiracism group, said the DfE’s guidelines seemed designed to create headlines about “culture wars” rather than improving education.

“Turning the need to teach children about racism and prejudice into a political football is cynical and does little to help schools navigating this complex topic,” Lowles said.


Richard Adams, Education editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Guidance on political impartiality in English classrooms ‘confusing’ say teachers’ unions
Education secretary Nadhim Zahawi warns against promoting contested theories as fact

Richard Adams Education editor

17, Feb, 2022 @12:01 AM

Article image
Experts reject claim Covid has worsened behaviour in English schools
Education secretary announces ‘behaviour hubs’, saying some pupils ‘out of control’ after lockdown

Richard Adams Education editor

07, Apr, 2021 @6:48 PM

Article image
Education recovery chief quits in English schools catch-up row
Sir Kevan Collins said to be dismayed that his long-awaited £15bn proposals were watered down to a £1.4bn package

Sally Weale Education correspondent

02, Jun, 2021 @4:54 PM

Article image
PM says 8 March 'prudent' for English schools' return as scientists issue warning
Early return is ‘recipe for disaster’ say experts, as Johnson resists pressure to follow Scottish lead

Sally Weale and Heather Stewart

03, Feb, 2021 @7:16 PM

Article image
How asbestos could slow efforts to fix crumbling concrete in English schools
Work to tackle Raac could expose asbestos that remains in buildings despite being banned in the 1990s

Jessica Murray

03, Sep, 2023 @9:58 AM

Article image
More than 90 English primary schools to close or face closure for lack of pupils
Guardian analysis lays bare effect of dwindling pupil numbers and associated funding amid rising housing and childcare costs

Carmen Aguilar García and Heather Stewart

29, May, 2023 @11:34 AM

Article image
Call for masks to remain compulsory in England’s schools
Letter to education minister urges government not to relax rule yet and highlights long Covid concerns

Sally Weale Education correspondent

04, May, 2021 @1:09 PM

Article image
Tory group demands rethink on recovery plan for English schools
MP queries Treasury grasp of ‘real world’ in tweet, as other Tories call catch-up plan after Covid inadequate

Peter Walker, Sally Weale and Jessica Elgot

03, Jun, 2021 @6:38 PM

Article image
Why are schools across the UK reopening on different dates?
Children in Scotland to start returning on 22 February, but 8 March is earliest possible date for England

Richard Adams Education editor

03, Feb, 2021 @6:48 PM

Article image
Jeremy Hunt announces £2.3bn per year boost for state schools
Extra money meets previous pledge to restore funding for pupils up to age of 16 back to 2020 levels

Richard Adams Education editor

18, Nov, 2022 @6:00 AM