MPs and peers do worse than 10-year-olds in maths and English Sats

Campaigners seeking abolition of year 6 Sats staged event at which children invigilated tests on parliamentarians

MPs and peers tasked with completing a year 6 Sats exam have scored lower results on average than the country’s 10-year-olds.

MPs including Commons education select committee chair Robin Walker took part in the exams, invigilated by 11-year-olds, at a Westminster event organised by More Than A Score, who campaign for the tests to be scrapped.

Only 44% of the cross-party group of parliamentarians dubbed the Westminster Class of 2022 achieved the expected standard in maths and just 50% had achieved the expected standard in spelling, punctuation and grammar.

Across the country, 59% of pupils aged 10 and 11 reached the expected standard in the Sats tests of maths, reading and writing this year, down from 65% in 2019, the previous time the tests were taken. Detailed figures published by the Department for Education in the summer revealed disadvantaged children had a steeper fall than their better-off peers.

Walker took part in the Big SATS Sit-In Westminster alongside his Conservative colleagues Flick Drummond and Gagan Mohindra; Labour MPs Ian Byrne and Emma Lewell-Buck with the Green party’s Lady Bennett to experience the high-stakes nature of the exams. More Than A Score hope the politicians will take the high-pressured experience away with them and realise that “the exams only judge schools but do not help children’s learning” at that age.

“The exams were absolutely terrifying,” Byrne said, “the mental impact such pressure would have on these young children is immense. Sats at this level must be scrapped. I’m delighted so many cross-party colleagues could experience this pressure too.”

Walker, the new chair of the education select committee acknowledged a need to reform exams for 10 to 11-year-olds, but refused to back dropping the exams altogether. “There will always be a place for testing but that cannot be the be-all and end-all to accessing the most opportunity. Ultimately, it’s not just about testing but it’s how we develop their love of reading.”

His comments were welcomed by Drummond who said a lot of the terminology used in the grammar exam was “unnecessary”. “We should have assessments but they shouldn’t be at such high stakes, wasting six months or more. It was quite a hard test and we need to acknowledge what will actually be useful for the future. We’re not educating young people to pass tests, we should want to give them a love of learning.”

A YouGov poll commissioned for the campaign group found 8% of parents and headteachers agreed that preparing for Sats and other tests should be the bottom of their priorities in the classroom. It also found 60% of parents felt intense nature of the exams harmed children’s mental health.

Alison Ali from More Than A Score said: “This is more than a test of maths and English capabilities, it’s an opportunity for MPs to put themselves in the shoes of 10 and 11-year-olds … they will see how absurd some of the questions faced by children are, how these absurdities influence and narrow the whole curriculum and how they are only used to judge schools not to help children’s learning.”


Aletha Adu Political correspondent

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Support for decision to scrap Sats for seven-year-olds | Letters
Letters: James Smith believes the focus of primary school should be on building relationships and a love of learning, Tony Roberts addresses a crisis in teaching and Colin Richards says four-year-olds will sabotage efforts to measure progress


15, Sep, 2017 @4:35 PM

Article image
Parents and children take part in boycott of primary school tests
Up to 30,000 families said to be backing strike, but turnout appears to have varied widely, with much of England unaffected

Richard Adams Education editor

03, May, 2016 @12:58 PM

Article image
Further gains for maths and literacy results in Sats exam
Department of Education statistics show great disparity between different school types, with mainstream free schools far behind other state institutions

Richard Adams Education editor

27, Aug, 2015 @6:25 PM

Article image
Primary school Sats paper that upset pupils used text from New York Times
One headteacher said 12-page reading test that reduced children to tears was ‘scary and quite middle class’

Sally Weale Education correspondent

18, May, 2023 @4:54 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on testing four-year-olds: wrong again | Editorial
Editorial: Accountability is important, but the new measuring stick being pushed on primary schools is blunt and unimaginative


05, Sep, 2019 @6:16 PM

Article image
Take our Sats maths quiz to see if you're smarter than an 11-year-old
Key stage 2 pupils in England are taking crucial maths exams this week. Try our sample questions to see how you would fare

Martin Belam

16, May, 2018 @10:50 AM

Example Sats questions for 11-year-olds

A small selection of questions asked of primary school pupils in last year's exams

15, Oct, 2008 @12:10 PM

Article image
Covid drives biggest Sats results gap since 2012 for poorest pupils in England
Deprived children fall further behind better-off peers as they lose most learning due to coronavirus

Richard Adams Education editor

06, Sep, 2022 @5:03 PM

Article image
Five reasons parents are boycotting primary schools over Sats
Some children are off school on Tuesday in a ‘kids’ strike’ over tests their parents believe are too pressurising

Carmen Fishwick and Guardian readers

03, May, 2016 @12:05 PM

Article image
Reading standards of 11-year-olds slip, Sats figures show

English and Maths standards rise, despite 16% of primary school leavers failing to reach expected reading level

Jessica Shepherd

03, Aug, 2010 @9:39 AM