No, girls are not put off by ‘hard maths’, Katharine Birbalsingh | Letters

In response to the social mobility commissioner’s claim that girls are shunning physics because of its difficulty, Matthew Belmonte says we must make Stem classrooms welcoming places for all. Plus letters from Ruth Rising and Rachel Clark

Katharine Birbalsingh’s remark that “physics isn’t something that girls tend to fancy” (Girls shun physics A-level as they dislike ‘hard maths’, says social mobility head, 27 April) sidesteps the crucial question of why girls become so turned off from physics and other Stem subjects (science, technology, engineering and maths). As she observes, the gender disparity in Stem subjects seems to arise in large part from the educational and career choices that girls make – but in what environments are these choices made?

At a population level, more girls and women than boys and men tend to combine quantitative skills with social cognitive skills, and therefore have broad leeway to choose subjects and occupations that emphasise one or the other or both. If Stem classrooms and workplaces are allowed to be “boys’ clubs” whose atmospheres are not fully reflective or supportive of girls and women, then girls and women will continue to take their skills elsewhere. Even as we facilitate individual choice, therefore, we must work to make Stem classrooms welcoming places for all, so that these choices are unconstrained.
Matthew Belmonte
Reader in psychology, Nottingham Trent University

• I was incensed by Katharine Birbalsingh’s comments. In 1975, I chose physics, maths, chemistry and biology for A-levels. The groups were about a third female. Both our physics and chemistry teachers were female. My daughter, now a doctor, chose sciences, including physics, for all her A-level subjects.

I went to a comprehensive school and we were encouraged to do subjects we enjoyed. I am glad we did not have teachers telling us that, because we were female, we would not choose physics or maths because they were too hard. Presumably Birbalsingh also discourages girls from doing too much reading as this might cause their brains to melt and dribble out through their ears.
Ruth Rising
Thornton Watlass, North Yorkshire

• So Katharine Birbalsingh thinks that the low proportion of girls in her A-level physics classes (16%) is because girls don’t like doing “hard maths”. Strange then that girls make up 39% of A-level maths students, where there is considerably more hard maths.
Rachel Clark
Head of maths, St Francis Xavier college, London

Have an opinion on anything you’ve read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication.


The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Girls with top science GCSEs 'deterred from study at higher level'
Low take-up of Stem subjects down to low confidence and boys’ dominance, study finds

Richard Adams Education editor

22, Aug, 2018 @3:06 PM

Article image
Girls do like hard maths, says children’s commissioner for England
Rachel de Souza says lack of female role models a bigger issue, after social mobility head said girls would ‘rather not’ do hard maths

Richard Adams Education editor

17, Jun, 2022 @12:44 PM

Article image
Gender stereotypes are still pervasive in our culture | Letters
Letters: Girls’ subject choices in school are one clear symptom of their unequal experiences, says Julia Higgins


02, Mar, 2018 @4:43 PM

Article image
The problems created by Sunak’s maths lessons | Letters
Letters: Readers remain unconvinced by the prime minister’s plan for students to study maths until the age of 18

06, Jan, 2023 @3:52 PM

Article image
Schools’ Stem diversity problem needs systemic solution, say MPs
Report finds students from black Caribbean backgrounds in England ‘acutely’ underrepresented in Stem

Sally Weale Education correspondent

24, Mar, 2023 @5:01 AM

Article image
Girls overtake boys in A-level and GCSE maths, so are they ‘smarter’?
Girls storm last bastion of male academic attainment as experts question notion of the ‘gendered brain’

Richard Adams Education editor

13, Aug, 2021 @3:49 PM

Article image
Girls shun physics A-level as they dislike ‘hard maths’, says social mobility head
Female physicists question ‘terrifying’ claims made by government commissioner Katharine Birbalsingh to MPs

Hannah Devlin Science correspondent and Aubrey Allegretti

27, Apr, 2022 @2:30 PM

Article image
Stop vilifying teachers who already work hard to tackle bias | Letters
Letter: Schools have strict policies and staff put extraordinary care into ensuring students are treated fairly, writes Yvonne Williams


01, Aug, 2021 @4:21 PM

Article image
Taking delight in times tables | Letters
Letters: Mathematically mature readers respond to a recent Guardian article by Peter Bradshaw


18, Feb, 2018 @5:20 PM

Article image
A-level results show rise in entries for traditional subjects
Geography, history and maths up along with computing and Spanish, while general studies is down after drive to promote more academic subjects

Sally Weale Education correspondent

13, Aug, 2015 @11:31 AM