Degree grade matters more than university reputation, report finds

Graduates with good degree from less prestigious university earn more than those with lower-class degree from selective institution

Students are advised to be “more relaxed” about the reputation of the universities they want to attend, after new research revealed they could be better off graduating with a good degree from a less prestigious university than with a lower-class degree from a selective institution.

The report by the Institute for Fiscal Studies found that graduates in England with first-class or upper second class (2.1) honours degrees had higher average earnings by the age of 30 than those who finished with lower second-class (2.2) awards, regardless of institution – meaning that degree class was often more important than institutional reputation.

Figures in the report also suggested it was less difficult to obtain a higher-class degree outside selective universities with competitive entry requirements, despite those universities tending to award a larger proportion of 2.1s and firsts.

Ben Waltmann, senior research economist at IFS and a co-author of the report, said prospective students, parents and policymakers should take note of the findings, and be “more relaxed” about which institutions they aim to study at.

“The findings imply that degree classification may matter as much as university attended for later-life earnings,” Waltmann said.

“Going to a more selective university is good for future earnings, and the fact that few students from disadvantaged backgrounds attend the most selective universities is a barrier to social mobility.

“But that being said, many graduates who get a 2.2 from a highly selective university might have got a higher-paying job had they attended a slightly less selective university and got a 2.1.”

The research, based on detailed government data, found that five years after graduation, annual pretax earnings for both women and men who obtained a lower second-class degree in 2013 were about £3,800 lower than for those who received an upper second-class degree.

The study also found that the rewards for higher degree classes vary “hugely” depending on subject.

Jack Britton, associate director of the IFS and co-author of the report, said: “For many subjects, the difference between a first and a 2.1 is inconsequential for earnings. However, for others – such as economics, law, business, computing and pharmacology – it is substantial.”

For men and women studying law or economics, getting a 2.2 rather than a 2.1 was associated with 15% lower earnings or worse, while there was “no significant difference” in pay between degree classes for those who majored in education or English.

But achieving at least a 2.1 led to much higher average pay for graduates of more selective universities.

Men and women who gained a 2.2 from the most selective universities – Oxford, Cambridge, Imperial College London and the London School of Economics – earned 20% less on average by the age of 30 than those who achieved a 2.1. At the least selective universities, a 2.2 degree led to about 6% lower pay for women and 8% for men.

The IFS also noted “stark gender differences” in the rewards between men and women achieving first-class degrees at very selective universities. The increase for a first-class degree versus a 2.1 was almost nothing for women but about 14% for men.

“This suggests that fewer high-achieving women go on to high-earning careers,” the IFS said.

Waltmann said the graduate gender pay gap was largely explained by subject choice. But even for those who graduated in the same subjects, it was clear that a pay gap had emerged by the age of 30 that was only partly explained by women leaving the labour market to have children.

“Children are a key explanation but they are not the only thing going on here,” Waltmann said.


Richard Adams Education editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
One in five students lose money by going to university, IFS finds
Men benefit more than women and creative arts provide worst returns, according to tax data

Richard Adams, Education editor

29, Feb, 2020 @12:01 AM

Article image
Economics and medicine graduates earn most, finds report
Salary uplift of some degrees in UK exceeds that gained from private education, says study

Richard Adams Education editor

07, Jun, 2018 @4:58 PM

Article image
Student loan changes in England will cost middle earners £30k, analysis says
IFS says from 2023, expected future earnings will be crucial in deciding whether to take gap year

Richard Adams Education editor

08, Apr, 2022 @2:34 PM

Article image
Gender pay gap begins for students straight after university – report
UK data also shows black graduates are more likely to struggle in the labour market

Richard Adams Education editor

18, Jun, 2020 @6:29 PM

Article image
Universities report record A-level grade acceleration in England and Wales
Up to half of applicants awarded two As, limiting places available for those who miss out on first choice

Richard Adams Education editor

06, Aug, 2021 @11:01 PM

Article image
Women gain more than men from master's degrees, finds IFS
Benefit from postgrad study not enough to stop UK women’s pay being lower than men’s at 35

Richard Adams Education editor

16, Sep, 2020 @5:58 PM

Article image
Student loan changes in England ‘could imperil supply of teachers and nurses’
Less well-off young people may be put off university, hitting supply of graduates in key sectors, says review

Richard Adams Education editor

02, May, 2022 @3:35 PM

Article image
Oxford University takes top spot in Guardian's annual university guide
This year’s report sees Oxford moving up from third to first for the first time in a decade

Richard Adams and Rachel Hall

05, Sep, 2020 @7:00 AM

Article image
Rising trend of state school pupils going to university reverses
Proportion of British undergraduates who are state educated now under 90%, the first fall for eight years

Richard Adams Education editor

07, Feb, 2019 @6:09 PM

Article image
Slow rise in university admissions from disadvantaged students
Sluggish progress to close the gap disheartening despite record levels, says Ucas chief

Richard Adams Education editor

06, Dec, 2018 @12:01 AM