Oxbridge student groups to be exempt from free speech law

Labour MPs accuse government of ‘ridiculous’ double standards and warn of two-tier university system

Oxbridge student groups are to be exempt from the legal restrictions imposed by the government’s new free speech legislation, leading to accusations of “ridiculous” double standards by ministers from opposition MPs.

Michelle Donelan, the universities minister, told MPs in a debate on the higher education (freedom of speech) bill that imposing the duties on Oxford and Cambridge student common rooms would be “unnecessary and overly bureaucratic”.

Labour MPs protested that special treatment for Oxbridge was unjustified and created a two-tier system across universities.

Emma Hardy, the Labour MP for Hull West and Hessle, said: “When we are talking about student unions and organisations, we are not just talking about Oxford and Cambridge, we are talking about all the small universities and colleges as well.

“It seems fairly ludicrous to me that every aspect of the bill would apply to the very small higher education provision at Hull College, but would not apply to the junior common room. That does not seem equitable or fair.”

Last week the government accepted an amendment to include Oxbridge colleges under the bill going through parliament. But it excluded Oxbridge student common rooms from being subject to the proposed law, which exposes universities and student representatives in England to legal action and regulatory punishment by the Office for Students (OfS).

The bill would mean all higher education providers registered with the OfS and their student unions must “secure freedom of speech” for students, staff and speakers, including making venues available to groups or speakers regardless of beliefs, and publish a code of practice for all meetings and activities.

Common rooms are the Oxbridge college-level equivalent of student unions, electing officers and often running their own facilities including bars and room bookings, with junior common rooms for undergraduates and middle common rooms for postgraduates.

Donelan told MPs: “Since a bill introduces new routes of redress for individuals who believe that their local freedom of speech or academic freedom has been improperly restricted, it is vital that the right institutions are held responsible.

“Colleges do fund their junior and middle common rooms. And to that extent, they can exert a lot of control over their activities, as these groups do not own or occupy their own premises, or run the room booking systems. And so imposing these freedom of speech duties on [them] does seem quite unnecessary and overly bureaucratic.”

Matt Western , the shadow minister for universities, said: “It is ridiculous for ministers to say that students in Warwick or Hull should be subject to unnecessary, burdensome bureaucracy and their student unions put at risk of being sued, but not the students of Oxford or Cambridge due solely to the makeup of the university.

“Labour in government introduced laws to protect every individual’s right to freedom of speech. This unnecessary legislation is an attempt to distract from the Conservatives’ failures to support students over the last year.

“The government’s exclusive approach risks creating a two-tier system across our universities.”

Earlier this year, the middle common room committee of Magdalen College, Oxford, was heavily criticised by politicians and the media for its vote to remove a portrait of the Queen from its room.

Gavin Williamson, the then education secretary, attacked the decision as “absurd”, leading to front-page news coverage. Members of the common room committee later received deaths threats and antisemitic abuse.


Richard Adams Education editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
If the university regulator is reviewing admissions, it needs to tackle Oxbridge I Lee Elliot Major
The Office for Students has the chance to shake up Oxford and Cambridge’s baffling selection process, perhaps with a lottery

Lee Elliot Major

03, Sep, 2019 @5:45 AM

Article image
Campus free speech law in England ‘likely to have opposite effect’
Campaigners attack the proposals, saying they will further limit what is deemed acceptable speech

Richard Adams Education editor

12, May, 2021 @7:21 PM

Article image
MPs demand urgent action from Oxbridge to widen admissions base
Cambridge says ‘our excellence is built on diversity’ in response to letter organised by David Lammy from 108 cross-party MPs

Richard Adams Education editor

24, Oct, 2017 @6:17 PM

Article image
Oxbridge needs student quotas to end its role in the ‘chumocracy’ | Peter Scott
Oxford and Cambridge are too good and too important to be allowed to remain in the middle ages

Peter Scott

05, Mar, 2019 @6:45 AM

Article image
Let’s have a Blair-Cameron College at Cambridge | Nick Hillman
New colleges or more places would be the best ways to widen access at Oxbridge

Nick Hillman

07, Feb, 2017 @6:45 AM

Article image
What stopped you applying to Oxbridge?
Why are high-flying state school pupils less likely to apply to Oxford or Cambridge than their private school peers? We asked some

Donna Ferguson

18, Dec, 2018 @8:30 AM

Article image
George Orwell was right, private schools bar moves towards a fairer society | Letters
Letters: Jol Miskin and Margaret Tulloch on what Labour may do about private education, and Robert Harding and John Lancaster on the Oxbridge intake from state schools


15, Sep, 2019 @3:47 PM

Article image
Richest students to pay for extra places at Britain's best universities
Proposals could allow UK students to enrol in university of their choice as long as they pay vastly higher fees up front

Jeevan Vasagar, education editor

09, May, 2011 @8:30 PM

Article image
Twenty-one Oxbridge colleges took no black students last year

Bleak portrait of racial and social exclusion at Oxbridge institutions revealed by Labour MP David Lammy's FoI request

Jeevan Vasagar, education editor

06, Dec, 2010 @10:00 PM

Article image
White working-class boys in England 'need more help' to go to university
Thinktank calls for changes to help widen participation of ‘most under-represented group in higher education’

Richard Adams Education editor

09, May, 2018 @11:01 PM