English universities risk breaking law over offer withdrawals, say ministers

Regulators push universities to remove oversubscription loopholes after surge in higher A-level grades

Universities in England risk breaking competition laws if they add loopholes letting them withdraw offers from students at the last minute if courses are oversubscribed, ministers and regulators have told vice-chancellors.

For the last two years, the surge in A-level grades allowed more students than forecast to meet their offer targets, and some universities withdrew offers when it became clear that courses would be oversubscribed.

In a concerted push by the government, the Office for Students (OfS), the higher education regulator for England and the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA), universities have been told to remove the oversubscription clauses from their offers or face possible punishments from the regulators.

Michelle Donelan, the universities minister, told vice-chancellors that it was “vital” that their offers were fair as an incentive for hardworking students to attain their grades.

“It is therefore disappointing that, during previous admissions cycles, there have been instances of providers introducing oversubscription conditions that permitted them to withdraw places where the number of students meeting offer conditions exceeded the number of places,” Donelan said in a letter sent to all vice-chancellors in England.

The OfS said it was “concerned” that higher education institutions had added the oversubscription clauses to their contracts with students.

“Our view is that providers should not use such clauses, as doing so would probably contravene consumer law,” the OfS stated. “A potential breach in consumer law may prompt the OfS to investigate and, if appropriate, carry out enforcement action to address any failures to comply.”

The CMA, which regulates universities for possible breaches of competition law, reiterated its view that the offer and acceptance of a university place was effectively a legally binding contract, with the university obliged to reserve a place providing the student met specific entry requirements such as A-level grades.

A clause allowing wide discretion to cancel an accepted offer “is likely to be unfair under ‘unfair terms’ legislation”, the CMA said. Similar clauses that would limit the liability of a university if it fails to provide qualified students with a place “are inappropriate and potentially unfair”.

Universities UK, which represents the leadership of major institutions, said decisions on admissions were a key area of university autonomy, and that institutions were “well aware of their legal obligations under consumer law and strive to ensure these are met”.

University leaders say they have been forced to withdraw places or offer incentives for students to change courses or delay their study because of the uncertainty created by the pandemic, especially the government’s decision to cancel formal exams and use teacher-assessed grades instead. That led to a much higher number of top grades awarded than admissions offices had forecast.

Donelan also welcomed efforts by Universities UK and GuildHE to draw up a new sector-wide code of practice for admissions. But she also urged universities to reject the use of “conditional-unconditional” offers, which give students a guaranteed place in return for immediately rejecting all their other choices.

During the pandemic, the OfS placed a temporary ban on the use of these offers, which expired in September. Donelan said she would “strongly encourage” universities to continue “avoiding the use of conditional-unconditional offers and other practices which may place undue pressure on students to make choices”.


Richard Adams Education editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Minister lambasts English universities for letting down students
Speech by Michelle Donelan signals a rebalancing of tertiary education away from HE sector

Richard Adams Education editor

01, Jul, 2020 @4:56 PM

Article image
Labour wants universities to offer places after exam results
Party aims to stop students from being hindered by inaccurate A-level forecasts

Richard Adams Education editor

13, Aug, 2019 @9:30 PM

Article image
Thousands of A-level students could lose their unconditional university offers
Regulator seeks temporary powers after universities make 30,000 unconditional offers in lockdown panic

Anna Fazackerley

22, May, 2020 @11:05 AM

Article image
OfS publishes plans to punish English universities for poor value for money
Tens of thousands of students are enrolled at institutions that could fail to meet new minimum standards

Richard Adams Education editor

20, Jan, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
Top UK universities 'use secret waiting lists' due to Covid uncertainty
Exclusive: applicants being told privately they have places to ensure courses are full despite admissions turmoil

Rachel Hall and Richard Adams

28, Feb, 2021 @6:52 PM

Article image
Education secretary backs review of university admissions
Gavin Williamson says system needs looking at amid growth in use of unconditional offers

Richard Adams Education editor

16, Sep, 2019 @5:00 AM

Article image
'Best time ever': school-leavers have pick of university courses, says Ucas
Competition is fierce between institutions recruiting from shrinking pool of 18-year-olds

Richard Adams Education editor

28, Nov, 2019 @12:01 AM

Article image
'Conditional unconditional' university offers to be banned in England
Offers are not based on results but on accepting university as sole choice instead

Richard Adams Education editor

02, Jul, 2020 @11:01 PM

Article image
Record numbers of UK students to get first choice of university
Ucas says it does not expect ‘tsunami of appeals’ over teacher-assessed grades despite rise in applications

Richard Adams Education editor

30, Jul, 2021 @3:06 PM

Article image
Universities 'pressure-selling' place offers to school-leavers
Regulator warns rising use of ‘conditional unconditional offers’ may break consumer law

Richard Adams Education editor

25, Jan, 2019 @6:00 AM