School heads forced to act like ‘Covid police’ during pandemic

Educational leaders in England reveal run-ins with parents and souring relations with staff

School leaders felt forced to act as “Covid police” during the pandemic, leading to toxic run-ins with parents and souring relations with their own staff, according to research.

More than half of primary leaders and just under half of secondary leaders struggled to deal with small but vocal groups of parents, ranging from anti-vaxxers and Covid-sceptics to those who did not want their children to attend school because of fears about the virus.

Tensions have continued to persist into the new school year, according to the survey of more than 1,500 school leaders in England.

One secondary head said they regularly received a “whole barrage of vitriol”, while another said parents with extreme views thought “they’ve got the right to treat you like you’re a piece of dirt”, leading them to question if they should continue working as heads.

Although heads reported that their broader relationships improved with parents over the pandemic as a result of increased communication, many disliked having to nag parents and teachers to wear masks and observe social distancing rules.

Pat Thomson, one of the report’s authors and professor of education at the University of Nottingham, said: “During Covid you’re under a real pressure cooker situation where people are feeling stress and under pressure and really anxious.

“If you’re a head you take a real pride in things being a smooth well-running machine. When you can’t sort it really quickly it bothers you. In some cases it was a no-win situation.”

The heads interviewed felt that tensions rose due to the fact “the government was looking to blame and threaten the profession, rather than work collaboratively with school leaders”.

Toby Greany, the report’s co-author and education chair at Nottingham, said the way changes in guidance were communicated by the government was also a problem. “Often heads were only finding out about things at the same time as parents, when they were announced on the news, but parents expected them to have all the answers.”

Nearly a quarter of the heads surveyed said they felt like they were sinking during the pandemic, and two in five considered leaving the profession. Interviewees aged under 46 viewed the demands of the job as incompatible with starting a family.

Claire, a headteacher in Essex, said she worked a minimum of 70 hours a week, arriving at her desk by 7am and continuing until 10pm, as well as working weekends and during the holidays. As a result, she has stepped back from her role as executive head looking after two schools.

“We’ve all held on because we wanted to see our schools through. But I think work-life balance for school leaders was pretty poor before and the pandemic has just eroded anything there might have been. It’s just so relentless,” she said.

In a survey by the Essex Primary Headteachers’ Association undertaken in November, 417 heads rated their work-life balance at 3.6 out of 10 and their happiness in their professional role at 3.8, citing Covid, staffing issues, Ofsted and parent complaints among the biggest stressors.

Heads commented on how they had never struggled so much and that this has not improved as society has reopened. One said: “Autumn 2021 has been the hardest term in 17 years of headship and far worse than anything last year threw at us.”

Another head felt “exhausted, overwhelmed and generally unwell” beginning the school year for the first time in their 30-year career. “I managed two weeks before, one morning, I woke up and just couldn’t do it anymore.”

The Nottingham researchers predicted there would be an exodus of heads in the coming years unless the government offers more wellbeing support and professional coaching, as well as making them feel valued and easing workloads.

“My best guess is that we probably will see a very large number of more experienced leaders in the system choosing to go earlier than we otherwise would have done as a result of the last two years. Two in five isn’t inappropriate to judge,” Greany said.

Contributor

Rachel Hall

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Learning time for children declined as 2020 Covid lockdown progressed – study
Less time was spent learning by July than at start of pandemic despite best efforts of schools and parents, says IFS

Richard Adams Education editor

19, Feb, 2021 @12:05 AM

Article image
Special needs pupils in England 'pushed to one side' in Covid crisis
Sizeable number of Send pupils were unable to return to school in September, according to survey

Sally Weale Education correspondent

19, Feb, 2021 @12:01 AM

Article image
Up to 97% of primary schools set to reopen for new term – survey
Most heads expect schools to reopen despite many lacking PPE and extra handwashing provision

Sally Weale

27, Aug, 2020 @11:01 PM

Article image
Ministers urged to close all schools in England for two weeks
Call comes after government said all primaries in London should remain closed next week

Richard Adams and Simon Murphy

02, Jan, 2021 @8:39 AM

Article image
Back to school: what Covid measures will be in place in England?
New term means end of bubbles, while testing and ventilation monitors will aim to reduce spread

Richard Adams Education editor

27, Aug, 2021 @1:16 PM

Article image
Like the Open University, we now need an Open School for the whole country | Tim Brighouse and Bob Moon
A national online centre could help children catch up after lockdown and revitalise schooling for the future

Tim Brighouse and Bob Moon

12, May, 2020 @5:45 AM

Article image
'The human stuff matters': heads call for a kinder school system post Covid-19
Ten years since Michael Gove’s reforms began, coronavirus shows up their failings, says the Headteachers’ Roundtable - and offers a chance for change

Fiona Millar

05, May, 2020 @6:30 AM

Article image
More than 1m school pupils in England absent last week due to Covid
Official figures reveal 14.3% of children were not in class because of coronavirus-related issues

Sally Weale Education correspondent

20, Jul, 2021 @12:24 PM

Article image
Dear Gavin Williamson, just admit it: schools spread Covid | Michael Rosen
The poet and author finds himself choking back feelings of despair and rage after his own three months in intensive care

Michael Rosen

01, Dec, 2020 @7:15 AM

Article image
Back to school in Covid times: what can pupils in England expect?
Shorter days, bubbles, alfresco meals and staggered arrivals among measures introduced

Ben Quinn

28, Aug, 2020 @11:00 PM