Rashford has Johnson grovelling again – but this time is different

Analysis: decision to swiftly accept failings over latest free school meals scandal marks change of approach

Once again, Marcus Rashford has scored against the government, after Boris Johnson was forced to admit at prime minister’s questions that food parcels being sent to England’s poorest families were “appalling” and “an insult”.

Keir Starmer attacked the prime minister for trying to dodge the blame, pointing out that the stingy-looking packages – pictures of which had been shared by Rashford, and by furious parents, on social media – appeared to reflect government guidance.

But Johnson’s abject apology, which followed a hastily arranged phone call with the footballer, did mark a change of approach from last year.

No 10 had initially sought to brush off Rashford’s calls for free school meals provision to continue throughout the 2020 summer break, before changing its mind and setting up a voucher scheme.

Then in the autumn, the government again resisted a holiday voucher scheme – one backbencher, Brendan Clarke-Smith, even warned against “nationalising children” – before ministers caved in.

This time, the Department for Education had dropped its “food parcel first” guidance by Wednesday afternoon, allowing families to use vouchers if they prefer, once the scheme is set up.

Conservative insiders say the children’s minister, Vicky Ford, was involved in pushing for a swift response on the issue. And Johnson’s language suggested the Downing Street machine has learned a tangle with Rashford only has one outcome.

But some of Johnson’s backbench troops despair that No 10 continues to be outflanked by the footballer – something they see as part of a pattern of flat-footed political management.

On a call with Boris Johnson’s press secretary, Allegra Stratton, on Tuesday, backbench Conservative MPs complained that No 10 remained too slow at rebuttals – and too vulnerable to elephant traps set by Labour.

Throughout the pandemic, Starmer has repeatedly stolen a march on Johnson by pushing for moves the government’s scientific advisers have demanded. In a pattern that has become wearily familiar, Johnson instinctively hits back, before giving way to the inevitable a few days or weeks later.

The clearest recent example was the prime minister’s attack on Starmer on 16 December for wanting to “cancel Christmas”, delivered in a tone of injured indignation, before Johnson announced last-minute changes to the festive mixing rules three days later.

This about-turn, and the more recent one on schools reopening, came more than a month after Stratton’s arrival and the departure of Dominic Cummings and Lee Cain, who were often blamed for Johnson’s pugnacious style.

There have been modest signs in recent weeks that the prime minister is picking fewer fights, and trying to restrain his irrepressible boosterism – urging caution about when the lockdown can be lifted, for example. But it is unclear as yet whether that is the result of a fresh approach to communications or the severity of the current phase of the pandemic. And no amount of fancy political footwork will help if the government is failing the public, in the way a slick campaign such as Rashford’s can relentlessly expose.

Ultimately, the reason the government continues to be caught out over child food poverty is a more fundamental one: the fact that the threadbare social safety net means children are going hungry in the first place.

Once housing costs are taken into account, the incomes of the poorest families were falling even before the pandemic hit. As the Joseph Rowntree Foundation says in its annual report on poverty on Wednesday, the squeeze on incomes was happening predominantly as the result of deliberate political decisions taken by Conservative governments to reduce the welfare bill – in particular, the 2016-20 benefits freeze.

Rishi Sunak increased universal credit by £20 a week early in the pandemic, in an implicit admission that the payments had become too paltry to live on. The chancellor has not yet said whether that will remain in place from April, choosing instead in a recent Spectator interview to highlight the necessity of “hard choices” to tackle the deficit.

With Rashford already on the warpath, extending the £20 a week increase looks all but inevitable; but the government will continue to remain vulnerable to the campaigning footballer’s attacks as long as there are parents in 21st-century Britain who cannot afford to feed their kids.


Heather Stewart Political editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
'Where's Boris?': anger among volunteers at food bank on PM's patch
Refusal to back free school meals extension riles families and volunteers in London and Bolton

Aamna Mohdin and Amy Walker

26, Oct, 2020 @5:00 PM

Article image
Marcus Rashford forces Boris Johnson into second U-turn on child food poverty
The PM called the footballer on Saturday night to confirm latest about-face for the government

Haroon Siddique

08, Nov, 2020 @5:05 PM

Article image
Free school meals: Johnson under renewed pressure from council leaders
Local authorities attack prime minister’s suggestion £63m could cover needs over half-term and Christmas

Peter Walker and Jessica Elgot

26, Oct, 2020 @12:49 PM

Article image
Marcus Rashford: public rallies behind campaign to end child food poverty
Covid-hit firms tweet offers of food donations after MPs reject free school meals plan

Alexandra Topping and Patrick Butler

23, Oct, 2020 @10:59 AM

Article image
Support grows for Marcus Rashford's free school meals campaign
Politicians and celebrities of all stripes come out in support of plan rejected by government

Sally Weale, Patrick Butler and Heather Stewart

23, Oct, 2020 @7:49 AM

Article image
Marcus Rashford calls for urgent review of free school meals system
Footballer’s request comes after Boris Johnson admits quality of some food parcels was sub-standard

Patrick Butler, Sally Weale and Jessica Elgot

13, Jan, 2021 @6:45 PM

Article image
Marcus Rashford vows to keep up free meals fight after No 10 refusal
PM’s spokesman indicates government will not back calls for meals in school holidays

Simon Murphy Political correspondent

15, Oct, 2020 @2:48 PM

Article image
Johnson makes U-turn on free school meals after Rashford campaign
‘Covid summer food fund’ announced after pressure from footballer and campaigners

Rajeev Syal, Heather Stewart and Helen Pidd

16, Jun, 2020 @7:09 PM

Article image
After Marcus Rashford, cafes step in where Tories refuse to tread | Barbara Ellen
It has been heartening to see small businesses rush to offer help to poor children

Barbara Ellen

24, Oct, 2020 @5:00 PM

Article image
No 10 under growing pressure to U-turn over free school meals
Tory MPs angry at damage from government’s refusal to support Marcus Rashford’s campaign

Simon Murphy, Ben Quinn and Patrick Butler

25, Oct, 2020 @9:00 PM