Imaginative lessons and teacher-awarded exam grades | Letters

Rob Watling thinks an education secretary with imagination could transform this summer for children, while Philip C Stenning calls for moderation. Plus letters from Dr Cary Bazalgette and Sarah James

If we had someone with imagination as secretary of state for education, we would be looking forward to a summer of active, creative and inspiring activities for our youngsters. They would harness the skills of under-employed actors, writers, artists, musicians and technicians to run a festival of learning away from Zoom and textbooks. They would pay the outreach teams at museums, art galleries and theatres to restart their best projects. They would work with the community branches of sports clubs up and down the country to develop children’s physical and mental fitness.

They would fund conservation groups, ramblers, wildlife trusts and city farms to extend their work with young people and get them out into the open spaces of towns, cities and countryside. They would recognise that you can learn and “catch up” with the help of people other than a tutor (Poorer primary pupils in England up to seven months behind due to Covid, 23 February). They would value teamwork and collaboration as much as individual learning and competition for exam results.

But we don’t have someone with imagination. We have Gavin Williamson. Which national bodies could petition the government for the funds to get this off the ground as a matter of urgency?
Rob Watling
Radcliffe-on-Trent, Nottinghamshire

• The need to find an alternative to school exams during the pandemic (Teachers to get sweeping powers to decide exam results in England, 25 February) is understandable. But having taught in a school and in universities during a long academic career, I believe that giving teachers the exclusive right and responsibility to determine the grades awarded to their own students would be bad for both the students and the teachers, as it would risk undermining the trust that is so essential to a good student-teacher relationship.

So, at the very least, some form of independent review and oversight of teacher-awarded grades needs to be included in such a scheme. In universities, such review and oversight is usually referred to as “moderation”, whereby grades awarded to students by teachers are reviewed by the teaching staff as a group, and/or by an academic from another university, before being finalised. This reduces the risk of grade inflation, as well as the risk that grades may be awarded on the basis of considerations other than academic merit, and the associated likelihood of a flood of appeals.
Philip C Stenning
Eccleshall, Staffordshire

• Fifty years ago, when we still had Certificate of Secondary Education exams, schools were allowed to set and mark their own exams: these were known as Mode 3 CSE. I reckon our Mode 3 English CSE – at Holloway school, north London – was more rigorous, more interesting, and a better way of assessing young people’s learning than any other exams I’ve taught, marked or moderated ever since. If we trust teachers to teach our kids, then why can’t we trust their skills of assessment? If you can’t assess where the kids are at, you can’t teach them.
Dr Cary Bazalgette

• Oh dear, it seems as though this years GCSEs are already subject to grade inflation. Two polite young people being interviewed on BBC Radio 4’s World at One on Thursday, when asked to give Gavin Williamson a GCSE grade, apologetically stated that they thought he hadn’t done very well and awarded him a C!
Sarah James


The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Gavin Williamson draws teachers' ire with impartiality warning
Education secretary accused of failing to focus on key issues such as coronavirus impact

Sally Weale Education correspondent

05, Oct, 2020 @2:43 PM

Article image
An ambitious overhaul of education is needed | Letters
Letters: The Conservative One Nation group’s report on schooling doesn’t go far enough, according to Greg Brooks and Steven Burkeman, while Ruth Eversley ponders a career recommendation


12, Oct, 2020 @4:28 PM

Article image
The 2020 exams fiasco has more to teach us yet | Letters
Letters: Salley Vickers on why the need for speed in exams is the problem, Prof Colin Richards on why private pupils still have an advantage after the government’s U-turn, and an anonymous teacher on how grades were really assessed


21, Aug, 2020 @4:13 PM

Article image
School exams: no marks for Gavin Williamson’s plan B | Letters
Letters: Howard Falshaw pours scorn on the education secretary’s ‘new’ proposal for mock exams, while Eric Gilhooley and Chris Dunne offer some much-needed solutions to the education shambles


14, Oct, 2020 @4:44 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on record A-level results: a triumph over adversity | Editorial
Editorial: Celebrating students deserve immense credit after surviving an educational ordeal


10, Aug, 2021 @6:18 PM

Article image
University admissions overhaul looks set to fail | Letters
Letters: Readers say the reforms are mere window-dressing and that coronavirus has provided an opportunity to pause and address the vital questions about what education is for


03, Jul, 2020 @2:50 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on schools reopening: a question of trust | Editorial
Editorial: Boris Johnson and his government have badly mishandled the crisis in education due to Covid-19. Instead of giving moral lectures, the prime minister should give teachers and parents the support they need.


24, Aug, 2020 @5:30 PM

Article image
Damage and disillusion caused by A-level downgrades | Letters
Letters: Retired headteacher Mary Smith says Boris Johnson cannot possibly think the marking system has been robust and fair, Chris Pratt calls for common sense, and Syeda Nooresahar Ahmad wonders why she was downgraded in all three A-level subjects. Plus letters from an anonymous former headteacher and Howard Falshaw


14, Aug, 2020 @2:54 PM

Article image
A golden opportunity to reshape education | Letters
Letters: Juliet Woodin says this is the time to take a radical look at the way school terms and holidays are organised, while John Binks suggests a way that the government can support the arts, sports and informal education sectors


15, Feb, 2021 @4:39 PM

Article image
Futures sacrificed for the sake of statistics
Letters: University academics call on the government to reinstate predicted A-level grades, while one father describes his daughter’s devastation at being downgraded and losing her university place. Plus David Druiff reminds us these students will soon be voters


16, Aug, 2020 @4:35 PM