School lockdowns risk more cases like Arthur Labinjo-Hughes, says Ofsted head

Amanda Spielman warns ‘there is a minority of children who sadly are safer in school than out of it’

The head of the Ofsted schools inspectorate has said England risks a repeat of cases such as Arthur Labinjo-Hughes, the six-year-old abused and murdered in his own home last year, if schools and social services are disrupted by future lockdowns.

Asked if further school closures could result in similar cases, Amanda Spielman said: “Yes, schools closing clearly has had some significant risks for children around the reduction in quality of education but we know that there is a minority of children who sadly are safer in school than out of it.

“And we have to recognise that by closing schools we make that minority less safe.”

The chief inspector of schools also criticised the “hokey-cokey education” that children have endured during the pandemic, saying that nearly every child in England suffered as a result, including vulnerable children who “disappeared from teachers’ line of sight”.

Launching Ofsted’s annual report for 2020-21, Spielman wrote: “Almost all children felt the impact of Covid-19 and the resulting restrictions to some extent. Many of the youngest children had their development and progress hampered, with some even regressing … In primary and secondary schools, children struggled with a hokey-cokey education: in the classroom, at home, separated in bubbles, isolating alone.”

Ofsted’s report claims that the loss of education, disrupted routine, and lack of activities “led some children to develop physical and mental health problems. Loneliness, boredom and misery became endemic among the young.”

It found that pressures on council care placements have grown during the pandemic, with long waiting lists and children being placed far from their families or in unregistered homes, as some children “became involved in criminal activity, including gang violence, and were at risk of child sexual exploitation”.

Spielman would not be drawn on the number of children who have been made more vulnerable by the pandemic lockdowns, or on the length of time that will be needed for the education system in England to repair the damage.

“In various surveys and testing programmes that have been done so far we’ve seen some encouraging signs. But I think we’ve also seen that it’s the children at the lower end of the spectrum, the ones who are the lower achievers, are the ones who’ve learned least through periods of remote learning and enclosed schools.

“So it’s it’s very important that we stay very clearly focused on the ones who will need help, and who won’t simply recover through schools doing what they always do so well,” Spielman said.

She said the suspension of Ofsted’s inspection visits for long periods since March 2020 had hampered its ability to investigate the workings of educational settings, including within prisons, or other social care.

Prisoners were found to be unable to leave their cells to learn or take part in classes. “Many lost motivation and floundered, especially those with learning difficulties, low levels of education or limited English,” the report states.

In response to criticism that Ofsted’s inspections are disrupting schools still affected by Covid, Spielman said the inspectors were sympathetic and that more than three-quarters of schools’ requests for an inspection deferral have been granted, especially at those with high levels of staff absence.

Post-visit surveys collected by Ofsted found that 90% of schools said that the inspection would help them to improve, while complaints were running at levels similar to pre-pandemic inspections.

“All the feedback that we collect says that our aim this term, to make sure that we genuinely take account of the Covid challenges for school, are landing about where they should,” Spielman said.

But Geoff Barton, general secretary of the Association of School and College Leaders, said Ofsted needed to recognise that inspections remained disruptive for many schools. “We have asked the inspectorate to allow inspections to be deferred upon request to a later date, and while it has slightly softened its criteria for deferrals, it has not gone far enough in this respect,” Barton said.


Richard Adams Education editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Children's exposure to extremism is an urgent problem, says Ofsted head
Sir Michael Wilshaw tells education secretary children need close monitoring in areas with highest risk of radicalisation

Richard Adams, Education editor

07, Jul, 2016 @11:01 PM

Article image
Ofsted head: schools’ focus on food parcels may have hit learning
Amanda Spielman claims prioritising poorest children during Covid made it harder to provide education for all

Sally Weale Education correspondent

14, Sep, 2021 @1:39 PM

Article image
Arthur Labinjo-Hughes report: high number children still at risk in Solihull
Report into children’s services warns of faulty police records and ‘overoptimistic’ case decisions

Jessica Murray Midlands correspondent

21, Feb, 2022 @11:57 AM

Article image
How much did lockdown help Arthur Labinjo-Hughes’ killers escape notice?
Analysis: review into murder of Solihull six-year-old will focus on how crimes against him were not picked up sooner

Patrick Butler Social policy editor

03, Dec, 2021 @4:53 PM

Article image
Ofsted chief accuses minority groups of 'entitlement' in hijab row
Amanda Spielman says school leaders must resist pressure on issues such as the headscarf

Sally Weale Education correspondent

09, Jul, 2018 @6:38 PM

Article image
Councils failing to protect at-risk children, says Ofsted
More than a quarter judged ‘inadequate’ by social care report, and child protection system has too much mediocre provision

Patrick Butler Social policy editor

28, Jun, 2016 @5:42 PM

Article image
Ofsted head seeks more powers to inspect unregistered schools
‘We’ve seen poor education, squalid conditions and worrying teaching materials,’ MPs told

Sally Weale Education correspondent

07, Mar, 2018 @6:11 PM

Article image
Schools shutdown likely to widen attainment gap, says Ofsted chief
MPs hear that it is in children’s interests to return to school as soon as possible

Sally Weale Education correspondent

27, Apr, 2020 @3:44 PM

Article image
Staff crisis hampering children’s pandemic recovery, says Ofsted
Children who have special education needs among those worst affected, says England watchdog’s chief inspector

Sally Weale Education correspondent

13, Dec, 2022 @2:32 PM

Article image
Covid made parents ‘more relaxed’ about unauthorised holidays – Ofsted
Chief inspector tells leaders the pandemic has ‘fractured the social contract between parents and schools’

Richard Adams Education editor

12, Mar, 2022 @2:50 PM