Black working-class pupils unfairly excluded in England, thinktank warns

Two-tier education system criminalises black youth, says Institute of Race Relations

Black working-class young people in England are being unfairly excluded and criminalised by a “two-tier education system”, a thinktank has said.

An Institute of Race Relations (IRR) report focusing on London says government responses to inner-city youth rebellions and moral panics over serious youth violence and knife crime have led to black pupils disproportionately being sent to pupil referral units (PRU) and alternative provision (AP).

Young black Caribbean boys are nearly four times more likely to receive a permanent school exclusion and twice as likely to receive a fixed-period exclusion than the school population as a whole, making them the most excluded group apart from Gypsy and Traveller children.

Warning of a “PRU-to-prison” pipeline, the IRR report notes that 89% of children in detention in 2017-18 reported having been excluded from school, according to the HM chief inspector of prisons for England and Wales.

The report’s author, Jessica Perera, an IRR researcher, said: “Amidst the Black Lives Matter protests, we have seen increased demands to decolonise the curriculum. At the same time, the coronavirus pandemic has exposed a system which fails working-class students.

“This paper reminds us that those who have been continually failed are found in PRUs and AP and that their segregation is a damning indictment of a planned education malaise, which has been designed and deployed on a specific section of society with a history of resistance and rebellion.”

Reviewing education policies over the last four decades, Perera says police officers placed in schools and other surveillance methods lead to working-class multiracial youth living on estates in London being framed as “suspects”.

She argues that black working-class boys have been let down by the “monocultural” national curriculum, which replaced attempts – particularly in the capital – at progressive multicultural education. Last month the government turned down calls for a review to add more black, Asian and ethnic minority history to the national curriculum.

With the expansion of academies, which are more likely to permanently exclude pupils, and alternative provision, Perera questions whether rising exclusions are “about removing a section of the urban multiracial working class which poses a threat to incoming gentrifying students” The result, she says, is a “two-tier state education system: academies for the aspirational and pupil referral units for the defiant and apathetic.”

A government spokesperson said: “We know some groups of children are more likely to be excluded than others, and we expect teachers to look at how to address underlying causes of disruptive behaviour in order to avoid excluding where possible, while also keeping schools safe and disciplined for all.

“The school curriculum is already broad and ambitious, teaching pupils about different cultures with significant historic figures from black and ethnic minority communities, underpinned by the need for mutual respect and understanding.”


Haroon Siddique

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Racial segregation in schools holds white pupils back, thinktank warns
Demos study finds parents like to send children to schools where their ethnicity is dominant, but this hampers educational attainment

Matthew Weaver

06, Jul, 2015 @9:09 AM

Article image
School exclusions data in England only 'the tip of the iceberg'
Five times more children being educated in schools for excluded pupils than official figures show, say researchers

Sally Weale Education correspondent

09, Oct, 2017 @11:01 PM

Article image
English schools must not teach ‘white privilege’ as fact, government warns
Comments ahead of new guidance ‘simplistic and unhelpful’, say teaching unions

Rachel Hall

21, Oct, 2021 @5:44 PM

Article image
Exclusion rates five times higher for black Caribbean pupils in parts of England
Exclusive: analysis of racial disparities in education system raises concerns over ‘criminalisation of children’

Niamh McIntyre, Nazia Parveen and Tobi Thomas

24, Mar, 2021 @5:00 PM

Article image
Why white working-class pupils fail at school | Letters
Letters: The low attainment that dogs so much of the white working class is likely to fall even lower in the next few years


07, Apr, 2016 @6:35 PM

Article image
Social class affects white pupils' exam results more than those of ethnic minorities – study
Poverty affects grades less among non-white children with social divide noticeable from primary school

Jessica Shepherd, education correspondent

02, Sep, 2010 @11:05 PM

Article image
'I was shielded from my history': the changes young black Britons are calling for
Exclusive: from schools to policing, 50 people share their experiences of growing up in the UK

Lucy Campbell

30, Jul, 2020 @9:48 AM

Gifted, but black

The education system is failing African Caribbean children, even, says a new report, in authorities whose schools lead the field in race relations. By Wendy Berliner

Wendy Berliner

14, Oct, 2003 @1:00 AM

Article image
Prevent strategy stigmatising Muslim pupils, say teachers
School and college staff question effectiveness of anti-radicalisation drive and say it undermines inclusion efforts

Sally Weale Education correspondent

03, Jul, 2017 @2:42 PM

Article image
In British education, the central issue is class, not ethnicity | Kenan Malik
The arguments about white culture are dangerous because they legitimise racist attitudes and ignore social marginalisation

Kenan Malik

07, Jan, 2018 @12:01 AM