Hundreds of thousands of students in Scotland banned from socialising

Student union says move disregards mental health and ‘applies different rules from the rest of the adult population’

Hundreds of thousands of students in Scotland have been banned from socialising and going to bars as coronavirus cases spread to more than 20 universities across the UK.

In a set of rules agreed by Scottish university leaders, students across the country were told they will not be allowed to socialise outside their households. They were also told to avoid bars, pubs and other venues completely this weekend.

The new rules include the adoption of a “yellow card/red card” disciplinary system which could lead to students losing their places, while police will help tackle rule-breaking.

“All universities will make absolutely clear to students that there must be no parties, and no socialising outside their households… Breaches will not be tolerated,” Universities Scotland said after a meeting with the higher education minister, Richard Lochhead. Across Scotland, up to six people from two households are allowed to gather in bars, restaurants or outdoors.

It comes after thousands of students UK-wide were forced to go into isolation within days of campuses reopening, as ministers refused to rule out keeping them away from home over Christmas to stop the spread of Covid-19.

Scotland, which is home to about 300,000 students in higher and further education, is particularly affected as the academic year starts earlier than in England and Wales. An outbreak of more than 100 confirmed cases at the University of Glasgow led to at least 600 students being told to self-isolate on Wednesday night.

The outbreak is said to have originated from socialising during the city’s freshers’ week starting on 12 September. Parents complained about a lack of support for their children, including first-year students living away from home for the first time.

The president of NUS Scotland, Matt Crilly, condemned the announcement, saying that it showed “a complete disregard for students’ mental health and wellbeing”.

Crilly said: “Tonight’s announcement by Universities Scotland and endorsed by the Scottish government unfairly blames students for the spread of coronavirus and takes the unjustified step of applying different rules to students over and above the rest of the adult population.”

Scotland’s University and College Union official Mary Senior said it was “astonishing” that students were being blamed for spreading the virus, and that universities should instead switch to online teaching.

“That is what the Scottish government should be introducing, not threatening students with red cards and banning them from going out,” Senior said.

Institutions in Aberdeen, Edinburgh and Dundee also confirmed infections among students, with 500 in Dundee in self-isolation. The University of Liverpool reported 87 confirmed cases, Manchester Metropolitan University more than 30 and a “small number” at Durham University.

Matt Hancock, the health secretary, refused to rule out requiring students to remain on campus over the Christmas and new year period in the event of further outbreaks, telling the BBC: “We just have to work on all contingencies at this stage. I know that people understand it’s an unprecedented crisis and so we do have to work on contingency plans.”

The Guardian reported this month that the government’s Scientific Advisory Group for Emergencies (Sage) told ministers that universities were highly likely to have “significant outbreaks” in the coming weeks, and that they needed to be prepared.

“Peak health impacts of these new infections and outbreaks they spark would coincide with the Christmas and new year period, posing a significant risk to both extended families and local communities,” Sage warned.

In England, the government’s guidelines for higher education allow for students to be confined to their halls of residence in the event of local outbreaks, including over Christmas.

But Nicola Sturgeon, Scotland’s first minister, reacted angrily when the Scottish Labour leader, Richard Leonard, raised speculation about students being kept in halls over Christmas.


“Talking right now about things like students not being allowed home for Christmas, that is not helping anybody. We all have to work right now to make sure that we cope with this infection virus in the best way possible,” Sturgeon said in the Scottish parliament.

Glasgow University confirmed that a mobile testing centre would be set up at the Murano student village, one of the two residences where students are self-isolating, and that student unions would be shut this weekend.

The university told the Guardian that staff were checking in with each flat and providing emergency food if needed, but students and parents raised concerns on social media that this was not happening fast enough.

A number of parents told the Guardian that, other than receiving an email telling them to self-isolate, their children had not received any further welfare support. One explained that his first-year daughter was in Murano halls, isolating in a shared flat of 10 after two of her flatmates tested positive on Tuesday.

“They have not been contacted by anyone from the university since the email telling them to isolate. The comments by University of Glasgow on the news suggesting they are in some way supporting the student households are very misleading,” he said. “Where is the duty of care? Meanwhile, the university take almost £600 per month per student for rent.”

Sturgeon said the Scottish government would soon set out further measures to ensure guidance was “rigorously implemented” on campus and in student accommodation after continuing discussions with university vice-chancellors. She said it was important that students “understand their obligations but also that universities are properly supporting them”.

Sturgeon was pressed repeatedly by opposition leaders on whether testing capacity was coping with the rise in demand.

“The fact that we do have a number of positive cases identified, and I would expect that to increase, and a number of students being asked to isolate, is [a sign that] test and protect working. That’s a difficult thing when numbers are as they are but it does show that system is working,” Sturgeon said.


Libby Brooks and Richard Adams

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
England campus lockdowns creating ‘perfect storm’ for stressed students
Student leaders warn of mental health impact of Covid restrictions as tensions soar

Rachel Hall and Ben Quinn

06, Nov, 2020 @3:54 PM

Article image
Halt in-person university teaching until test and trace fixed, union urges
Exclusive: UCU general secretary Jo Grady speaks out after rapid rise in Covid cases on campuses

Richard Adams, Amy Walker and Libby Brooks

25, Sep, 2020 @5:00 PM

Article image
Cambridge college threatens to evict students if a Covid-19 outbreak occurs
Trinity’s policy accused of being ‘extremely punitive’ and breaching official guidance

Anna Menin and Richard Adams

16, Sep, 2020 @10:25 AM

Article image
UK universities facing £760m hit as one in five students plan to defer
Exclusive: undergraduates to delay enrolment if classes stay online and activities are curbed

Richard Adams Education editor

20, May, 2020 @7:00 PM

Article image
Hundreds of thousands of UK students call for tuition fee refunds
Almost 250,000 sign petition over coronavirus closures and ongoing room rents

Sally Weale, Rachel Hall and Richard Adams

25, Mar, 2020 @6:26 PM

Article image
Complete shutdown of UK universities due to Covid-19 'impossible'
Vice-chancellors say thousands of students will have nowhere to go if campuses close

Anna Fazackerley

11, Mar, 2020 @12:21 PM

Article image
English universities must consider partial fee refunds, says regulator
OfS warns against blanket refusals as thousands of students locked down after Covid outbreaks

Sally Weale, Helen Pidd and Severin Carrell

28, Sep, 2020 @5:38 PM

Article image
Universities accused of pressuring staff to work on campus
One university says failure to offer ‘full campus experience’ could lead to students seeking tuition fee refunds

Rachel Hall

21, Oct, 2020 @5:25 PM

Article image
Fears of 'isolation fatigue' if students quarantine before and after Christmas
Vice-chancellor of York calls for ‘hard thinking’ on government support for self-isolating young people

Ben Quinn and Libby Brooks

13, Nov, 2020 @5:51 PM

Article image
Third of new students in England show signs of depression, survey suggests
‘Experimental’ ONS survey of first-years finds 37% have symptoms of depression and 39% of anxiety

Sally Weale Education correspondent

27, Oct, 2021 @2:50 PM