Covid will reinforce race inequality at Oxbridge, warn experts

With predicted exam grades known to be biased against black students, it is feared numbers at elite universities will fall

Covid-19 threatens to exacerbate racial disparities at Oxford and Cambridge for years to come, according to the organisation charged by both universities with encouraging black students to apply to them.

Naomi Kellman, founder of Target Oxbridge, which has helped 70 such students obtain offers for the coming academic year, warns that far from being a “great leveller” it is “clear that the virus is in fact reinforcing existing inequalities”.

This academic year there were more than 200 black undergraduates studying at Cambridge – an all-time high. At Oxford, the proportion of black students admitted rose from 2.6% in 2018 to 3.1% last year.

Last week’s vote by Oriel College, Oxford, to remove the statue of Cecil Rhodes, the imperialist who supported apartheid-style measures in southern Africa, was seen as another step forwards by equality campaigners.

But concerns have been raised that the predicted grades system – introduced to replace this summer’s Covid-hit GCSE and A-level exams – will impact negatively on black students. Exam watchdog Ofqual has asked schools to provide the grades they think students were most likely to achieve, along with evidence such as classwork and mock results.

Kellman said evidence confirms that each year teachers underpredict the A-level grades of several thousand high-achieving, low-income students. Around 20% of black students are on free school meals, compared with 11% of white students, suggesting they are more likely to be disproportionately affected by this bias.

Ofqual has also asked teachers to rank students for each subject. But Kellman said “too often, bias results in lower expectations for white working class and ethnic minority students, raising the possibility that these groups will fare less well in the prediction and ranking process than others.”

Lower A-level grades will have an impact on students attempting to secure university places this autumn. But it is also feared that lower-than-hoped for GCSE grades may deter less privileged pupils aiming for a place at a leading university.

Bobby Mugo, a student who completed the Target Oxbridge programme, outperformed his GCSE predictions, obtaining an A* in English instead of the C he was predicted. He went on to secure a place at Cambridge but questions whether this would have been possible this year.

“I probably wouldn’t be at Cambridge if I had to go through this process now,” he said. “I think it’s quite common for black students to be under predicted, and talking to other black Cambridge students, it seems like something that happens quite often.”

In April, the Runnymede Trust, the race relations think tank, wrote an open letter to the education secretary, Gavin Williamson, questioning what checks and balances were in place to ensure pupils were treated equally this year.

In response Williamson said: “It is important to recognise that the system we are operating this summer operates very differently from the way predicted grades are awarded for applications to higher education and other purposes.”

Kellman said Oxbridge colleges also had a part to play, not just with the current round of applicants, but for those some years off applying. She urged the colleges to consider students’ backgrounds and show greater flexibility on missed grades. “Now is the time to double down and make sure we are looking at the context in which people achieve their grades. We must not think that this was just a moment in time and it’s all OK now,” she said.

“The reality is that for the next four to five years, anybody working in recruitment, whether that is university admissions or graduate recruitment, needs to pay very close attention to contextual information so that students from not-as-privileged backgrounds aren’t disadvantaged by any disparities that emerge.”

A spokesman for the Department for Education said Ofqual had issued extensive guidance to schools and colleges and “was making every effort to ensure that the process does not disadvantage any particular group of students”.

Contributor

Jamie Doward

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
University admissions study reveals extent of Oxbridge divide

Five elite schools sent more pupils than 2,000 others, with choice of A-Level subjects helping to account for gap

Jeevan Vasagar, education editor

07, Jul, 2011 @11:01 PM

Article image
Calls for private school head’s sacking for ‘tasteless Holocaust analogy’
Furore as headmaster of Stowe says Oxbridge is persecuting students from elite backgrounds

Jamie Doward, Donna Ferguson and Michael Savage

12, May, 2019 @8:00 AM

State or private: still the key factor in shaping life for our schoolchildren
As students await this week's A-Level results, a huge gulf still exists between private and comprehensive education - and the life choices they offer pupils

Polly Curtis and Tracy McVeigh

15, Aug, 2009 @11:06 PM

Article image
Parents and pupils overwhelm schools with pleas for good grades
Teacher assessments that will replace exams may disadvantage poorer students

Julie Henry

19, Apr, 2020 @10:00 AM

Article image
How many pupils from your school go to Oxbridge?

A report out today highlights the division between schools and applications to Oxbridge. Find out how many pupils from schools in England get accepted

Jeevan Vasagar

08, Jul, 2011 @6:00 AM

Article image
White working-class boys in England 'need more help' to go to university
Thinktank calls for changes to help widen participation of ‘most under-represented group in higher education’

Richard Adams Education editor

09, May, 2018 @11:01 PM

Article image
Oxbridge intake: how one state school sends scores of students every year
Hills Road sixth form college is only state school to appear in list of elite institutions compiled by Sutton Trust

Jeevan Vasagar

07, Jul, 2011 @11:01 PM

Article image
Oxbridge needs to guarantee places for the best state school pupils | Owen Jones
I know how the system works against those from state schools, says Guardian columnist Owen Jones

Owen Jones

07, Dec, 2018 @12:14 PM

Article image
Oxbridge: bucking the trend, or hogging the limelight? | Letters
Letters: Adult education is flourishing at Oxford, writes Jonathan Michie, and Michael Pyke is sick of the Oxbridge coverage while our schools are in chaos

Letters

05, Jun, 2018 @4:19 PM

Article image
Oxbridge only has itself to blame for its lack of diversity | The big issue
Academics deflect from their establishments’ deficiencies by saying society is at fault

28, Oct, 2017 @11:05 PM