UK universities accused of overreliance on fees from Chinese students

Tory-backed thinktank is calling for increased funding for domestic students

Britain’s universities rely too heavily on tuition fees from Chinese students, according to a Conservative-backed thinktank that wants the government to replace them with increased funding for domestic students taking “high value” degrees.

The report by Onward, a thinktank supported by Tory MPs and donors, claims there are “well-founded fears” that China’s Communist party and its satellites have sought to undermine academic freedom and research on UK campuses, at the same time as lucrative international student fees have distorted the priorities of universities.

To tackle those concerns the report proposes a series of radical policies, including capping the income a university could earn from a single country and steering more UK students into courses with high graduate earnings, such as medicine, law, economics and sciences.

Will Tanner, the report’s author and a former special adviser to Theresa May as home secretary and prime minister, said: “Britain has never had a serious debate about the growth of overseas students. Yet the viability of the UK’s most prestigious universities, to say nothing of billions of pounds of science funding, is now decided not in parliament but in countries thousands of miles away.

“Even more worrying is that a third of overseas funding comes from China, a country whose government has shown itself unafraid of threatening to cut student flows in response to criticism and whose commercial partnerships with UK universities are increasingly under scrutiny.”

The report comes at a tense moment in UK-China relations, with Boris Johnson’s government last week saying it would ban the purchase of 5G telecoms gear made by Huawei from next year, while the UK is offering the prospect of citizenship to nearly 3 million Hong Kong residents after protests there.

Onward’s proposals also follow current government thinking on changes to higher education funding in England. The report suggests that ministers increase the teaching grants paid for domestic students taking high “value-added courses”, enabling universities to expand in those areas and lessen their reliance on international fees. At the same time so-called “low-value” courses could see their domestic student numbers capped, with one option tying student loan availability to graduate earnings.

One of the report’s complaints is that the rapid growth in international student numbers has “crowded out” domestic students at prestigious institutions. Instead, Onward recommends that universities’ ability to recruit overseas students should be connected to their growth in UK students.

But the Russell Group of leading research institutions, such as Cardiff and Manchester universities, rejected the claim that domestic students were being overlooked.

“Russell Group universities have grown UK student numbers alongside international numbers, and home students continue to make up over three-quarters of our undergraduates, who will be equipped with the skills to go on to success in whatever path they choose,” said Tim Bradshaw, the group’s chief executive.

“Students from around the world choose to study at British universities because of the high-quality education and experience they provide – this is a testament to our quality and should be seen as a success story.”

Last year more than 120,000 students from China were studying at UK universities, while official data shows UK students accounted for 77% of undergraduates at Russell Group universities. But Onward noted that the number of UK students enrolled at several institutions, including Oxford and Cambridge universities, Imperial College, and the London School of Economics, fell between 2014-15 and 2018-19.


Richard Adams Education editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Fifth of UK universities’ income comes from overseas students, figures show
Guardian analysis highlights how dependent sector has become on countries such as China and India

Carmen Aguilar García, Sally Weale, Lucy Swan and Harvey Symons

14, Jul, 2023 @5:00 PM

Article image
Tory hand-wringing for students from the poorest countries is pure hypocrisy | Smita Jamdar
Jacob Rees-Mogg – and even the universities minister – claim raising fees for EU students will help those from further afield. What nonsense

Smita Jamdar

07, May, 2019 @5:45 AM

Article image
EU students could face higher fees to study in UK from 2020
Higher education groups call on government to clarify its policy on tuition costs

Richard Adams Education editor

28, Apr, 2019 @2:28 PM

Article image
England and Wales university fees ‘bad value for money’ – survey
Majority of respondents say £9,250 a year fee is not good value – with 74% backing additional bursaries for poorer students

Richard Adams Education editor

31, Aug, 2022 @5:00 AM

Article image
Tuition fees from UK students fail to cover costs of undergraduate courses at UCL
University College London and other institutions must rely on fees from international students, provost says

Richard Adams Education editor

11, Sep, 2021 @7:00 AM

Article image
Change in student loan accounting could add £10bn to UK budget deficit
Possible decision by ONS would reopen question of funding of students in England

Richard Adams Education editor

16, Dec, 2018 @3:38 PM

Article image
English universities over-reliant on overseas students’ fees, report warns
Public accounts committee says institutions ‘potentially exposed to significant financial risks’, with 80 declaring annual deficit

Richard Adams Education editor

14, Jun, 2022 @11:01 PM

Article image
Students in England call for 30% Covid discount on tuition fees
University students propose rebate for coronavirus-affected tuition, funded by increased interest rates

Rachel Hall

31, May, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
Academic freedom is precious – so why have UK universities sold out to China? | Peter Wilby
In their anxiety to succeed in the global marketplace they have become sitting ducks for an illiberal state

Peter Wilby

11, Aug, 2020 @6:15 AM

Article image
Covid-19 has made universities' financial forecasts redundant. Good luck to us all | Jonathan Wolff
Will freshers opt to defer for a year, and can universities let them? No one knows the answers to even the biggest questions

Jonathan Wolff

05, May, 2020 @6:00 AM