A-levels: why has Ofqual suspended its criteria to appeal grades?

DfE did not consult exam regulator on guidance and students must now wait until Ofqual issues revised policy

Ofqual, the exam regulator for England, has suspended its criteria for students hoping to challenge their A-level grades on the basis of their mock exam results.

What has happened to the promised exam appeal process?

Last Tuesday, Gavin Williamson announced that pupils in England could use grades from their mock exam to appeal if they were “unhappy” with the results allocated by Ofqual for both A-levels and GCSEs. The details were left up to the exam regulator to decide by Monday – but the Department for Education appeared not to have consulted Ofqual on the new grounds for appeal.

What happened this weekend?

On Saturday afternoon Ofqual published the promised guidance, with crucial details added. Ofqual’s wording appeared to allow a wide range of mock exams and “non-exam assessments” as evidence, with one headteacher calling it “a complete free-for-all”. But the regulator also said successful appeals would mean the Ofqual result would be replaced by either the teacher-assessed grade or the mock-exam grade – whichever was lower – contradicting Williamson’s earlier pledge that pupils would receive their mock grades after appeal.

But by 11pm on Saturday night, Ofqual had removed the guidance from its website and put up a statement: “This policy is being reviewed by the Ofqual board and further information will be published in due course.” So far it has made no further comment.

Did the government know about Ofqual’s Saturday night fever?

Almost certainly not. The Department for Education issued statements on Saturday evening endorsing Ofqual’s appeal process. And the schools minister, Nick Gibb, issued a letter to headteachers and principals at 8.30pm, stating that grounds for appeal included “where a student has a valid mock result which is higher than the grade they have been awarded and wishes to have their mock result stand instead. Ofqual has issued criteria on what constitutes a valid mock result”. He then posted a link to the now removed web page.

What should I do if I want to appeal against my grades?

Wait. Until new guidance or decisions are announced, there is no way of knowing how the appeals will work. But in the meantim,e those applying for university or college places should tell admissions officers if they have mock exam results higher than the grade they received from Ofqual.

How would Ofqual’s appeals have worked?

Pupils would have three bits of information: their Ofqual-moderated grade, their mock exam result, and their teacher-assessed grade. Under the deleted guidance, appeals would only succeed if the mock grade was higher than the Ofqual grade, and if the teacher-assessed grade was also higher than the Ofqual grade. So that meant only grades among the 39% of teacher assessments marked down by Ofqual could be appealed, also contradicting Williamson’s initial “triple lock” promise of either an Ofqual grade, a mock grade or an autumn exam.

What does this mean for GCSEs?

They will be published on Thursday, by which time the government is under considerable pressure to have an appeal process in place. However, the government may have to take more dramatic action given the controversy, as well as its strained relationship with Ofqual. Ken Baker, a Tory peer and the former education secretary under Margaret Thatcher, has called for GCSE results to be delayed to allow an overhaul. Others, such as the head teachers’ unions, now lean towards dumping Ofqual’s grades and instead using teacher assessments, as in Scotland.

What about pupils who don’t have mock exam results?

That remains unclear. Ofqual’s process had “non-examination assessments” as one option, but that may be more heavily restricted when the new process is published, if it ever is.

Are other forms of appeal still allowed?

Only Williamson’s last-minute offer of the use of mock exam grades is uncertain – other forms of appeal are still available. But the other appeals are mainly school-based, for entire courses with a high bar of evidence required, or where an administrative error has been made. Individual students can appeal on the grounds of “malpractice” if they feel they are the victim of discrimination or bias by their school, but not by Ofqual.

How has the Department for Education responded?

The DfE said: “We have been clear that we want to build as much fairness into the appeals process as possible to help young people in the most difficult cases and have been working with Ofqual to achieve that.

“Ofqual continues to consider how to best deliver the appeals process to give schools and pupils the clarity they need.”


Richard Adams

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Ministers braced for backlash as England's teachers despair at A-levels fiasco
Revolt grows as students prepare for results day, with some schools seeing 50% or more of grades revised down

Sally Weale, Heather Stewart and Richard Adams

12, Aug, 2020 @8:23 PM

Article image
Back Ofqual or I quit, chair of regulator told Gavin Williamson
Exclusive: Roger Taylor demanded education secretary admit Ofqual was behind exams U-turn

Richard Adams and Heather Stewart

21, Aug, 2020 @5:02 PM

Article image
Gavin Williamson seeks to blame Ofqual for exams debacle
Education secretary forced into humiliating reversal on A-level and GCSE grades in England

Heather StewartKate Proctor and Sally Weale

17, Aug, 2020 @8:01 PM

Article image
Students in England to sit repeated mock A-levels and GCSEs, Ofqual says
Unions and school leaders critical after regulator publishes long-delayed contingency plan

Richard Adams Education editor

11, Nov, 2021 @5:29 PM

Article image
Ofqual ignored exams warning a month ago amid ministers' pressure
Exclusive: Agency said to have been told of risk of erratic outcomes, but was under government pressure on grade inflation

Richard Adams, Jessica Elgot, Heather Stewart and Kate Proctor

19, Aug, 2020 @7:18 PM

Article image
Nearly 40% of A-level result predictions to be downgraded in England
Exclusive: Assessments likely to be adjusted down before students receive results – analysis

Richard Adams Education editor

07, Aug, 2020 @3:30 PM

Article image
Boris Johnson urged to intervene as exam results anger escalates
Labour calls on PM to cancel planned break as Tory MPs deluged with complaints

Richard Adams and Heather Stewart

16, Aug, 2020 @8:00 PM

Article image
Delay A-level and GCSE exams to give pupils more time, says Labour
Shadow education secretary Kate Green says exams should be pushed back to June 2021

Richard Adams and Peter Walker

30, Aug, 2020 @9:30 PM

Article image
GCSEs and A-levels likely to be partly assessed by cut-down versions of exams
Education secretary to look into use of ‘externally set tasks’ to help teachers in England assess final grades

Richard Adams Education editor

13, Jan, 2021 @4:43 PM

Article image
'I feel utterly let down': students on Ofqual's review of A-level appeal criteria
Exam regulator suspended its policy for challenging grades hours after it was published

Mattha Busby

16, Aug, 2020 @1:25 PM