Futures sacrificed for the sake of statistics

University academics call on the government to reinstate predicted A-level grades, while one father describes his daughter’s devastation at being downgraded and losing her university place. Plus David Druiff reminds us these students will soon be voters

As academics working across a range of English universities, we are writing to express our dismay at the fiasco that is this year’s A-level and Btec results.

The algorithm used by Ofqual, following the government’s decision not to use teacher assessed grades, has reduced students’ A-level grades by, in some instances, two or three boundaries. We have seen students predicted ABC grades awarded CDE, and students predicted BBC awarded DDE. Both of these students were at a state sixth-form college, with a good range of passes at GCSE.

In a vanishingly small number of cases, grades have been moved upwards by a boundary, although it is private schools that have mainly benefited from this, with the number of A* and A grades awarded in this sector increasing by 4.75% this year. Ofqual’s decision to give more weight to predicted grades where students were in a smaller cohort seems to have directly benefited private schools at the cost of larger state schools and further education colleges. This is not the “levelling up” that the government promised would be a keystone of its administration.

In recent days we have witnessed the anxiety, distress and anger this has caused among university applicants. Those at the sharp end of this process are overwhelmingly teenagers who have already lost months of education, and are now, in some cases, seeing their hopes and dreams for the future disappear.

We trust our colleagues who teach A-level and Btec courses, and who prepare their students to enter university. We trust them far more than an Ofqual algorithm. We call on the government to immediately reinstate predicted grades for A-level and Btec students.
Prof Lucy Noakes University of Essex
Prof Julie Anderson University of Kent
Prof Catriona Beaumont London South Bank University
Prof Brad Beaven University of Portsmouth
Prof Bob Brecher University of Brighton
Dr Justin Colson University of Essex
Prof Martin Evans University of Sussex
Dr Cath Feely University of Derby
Dr Alix Green University of Essex
Prof Claire Langhamer University of Sussex
Dr Edward Madigan Royal Holloway, University of London
Dr Katrina Navickas University of Hertfordshire
Dr Daisy Payling University of Essex
Prof Catriona Pennell University of Exeter
Dr Andrew Priest University of Essex
Prof Lucy Robinson University of Sussex
Dr Chris Smith Coventry University
Dr Lisa Smith University of Essex
Peter Stanfield University of Kent
Dr Jon Watson University of Brighton

• My daughter is one of the 280,000 who had their predicted grades lowered. She had studied for many years, got impressive GCSE results (just three years after we moved to the UK) and outstanding predicted grades that secured a conditional offer from King’s College London. Then there was coronavirus, the government cancelled the exams, and she was given some random results. She studied for four A-levels and completed the EPQ. All but one have been downgraded. King’s College simply cancelled the offer.

In the days since, my daughter has spent her time crying, being catatonic and screaming. It is just like the loss of a loved one. After studying hard for many years, after spending four months practically jailed at home, after waiting to receive the random results, she is now lost. She did not even try to look at clearing, she was too devastated to do it.

She was deprived of showing her value via these exams, and she was judged without the right to a defence. At 18 years old, her future has been destroyed by an algorithm. My daughter will not go to a UK university this year. Maybe she will recover, maybe she will decide to study in a country where the education secretary thought about the students, their education and mental health, not just the statistics.
Name and address supplied

• Has it escaped this government’s notice that every last student assessed for A-level and GCSE exams this year will be eligible to vote at the next election? And, for good measure, most students have two parents. Just do the maths, prime minister.
David Druiff


The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Safe return to school isn’t helped by guff from MPs | Letters
Letters: Kevin McCready on outspoken Conservative MPs’ lack of expertise, Ian Richardson on Boris Johnson’s vague words, and an anonymous teacher’s fears about the thousands of community contacts that she and her family will share


27, Aug, 2020 @4:59 PM

Article image
Damage and disillusion caused by A-level downgrades | Letters
Letters: Retired headteacher Mary Smith says Boris Johnson cannot possibly think the marking system has been robust and fair, Chris Pratt calls for common sense, and Syeda Nooresahar Ahmad wonders why she was downgraded in all three A-level subjects. Plus letters from an anonymous former headteacher and Howard Falshaw


14, Aug, 2020 @2:54 PM

Article image
Imaginative lessons and teacher-awarded exam grades | Letters
Letters: Rob Watling thinks an education secretary with imagination could transform this summer for children, while Philip C Stenning calls for moderation. Plus letters from Dr Cary Bazalgette and Sarah James


26, Feb, 2021 @5:13 PM

Article image
Hopes and fears after the Tories' A-level disaster | Letters
Letters: After the government’s climbdown, the fight for a fairer education system must go on, writes GCSE student David Wolffe, while Philip Rogerson has some recommended reading for failing politicians


18, Aug, 2020 @4:25 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on record A-level results: a triumph over adversity | Editorial
Editorial: Celebrating students deserve immense credit after surviving an educational ordeal


10, Aug, 2021 @6:18 PM

Article image
Algorithm method was bound to fail for Ofqual | Letters
Letters: In statistics all predictions should come with a health warning, writes Emeritus Professor Graham Hall, while Dr Peter WH Smith points out that the human factor was missing and Prof John Gray that one cannot use one year’s results to predict the next. Plus letters from John Bailey and Tony Leather


23, Aug, 2020 @5:12 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on English language and literature: more, please | Editorial
Editorial: We must take care not to devalue a subject that helps us build a more rounded and healthier body politic


27, Jun, 2021 @5:25 PM

Article image
An ambitious overhaul of education is needed | Letters
Letters: The Conservative One Nation group’s report on schooling doesn’t go far enough, according to Greg Brooks and Steven Burkeman, while Ruth Eversley ponders a career recommendation


12, Oct, 2020 @4:28 PM

Article image
Glad that schools left the bell curve behind | Letter
Letter: Former A-level examiner Sarah Sheils on the awarding of grades and why levels of performance are higher today than 50 years ago


22, Nov, 2020 @5:08 PM

Article image
Education’s value to society is lost amid focus on graduate salaries | Letters
Letters from Pete Dorey, Christine Hawkes, Bernie Evans, Prof Colin Richards and Dr Nick Pratt


03, Dec, 2018 @5:39 PM