‘Welcome and important’: academics on decolonising education

The debate that started at Cambridge is prompting other universities to think about ‘new ways of seeing the canon’

The debate sparked by a group of undergraduates at the University of Cambridge, on how and whether to “decolonise” British tertiary education by incorporating more black and minority ethnic voices, is spreading rapidly across universities and academic disciplines.

Paul Gilroy, professor of American and English literature at King’s College London, tweeted an image of Batman proclaiming “Decolonising the humanities isn’t just about Oxbridge”, and commented: “The caped crusader speaks for many of us.”

Malachi McIntosh, a Cambridge research fellow and expert on 20th and 21st century Caribbean literature, sees traditional curricula as damaging – and not just to literary understanding.

“Arguably, the narrowness of our curricula – at all levels of education – has fuelled the current political status quo, where a crude understanding of ‘us’ and ‘them’, built on a sepia-tinged nostalgia for a past that never was, is inspiring grand acts of national self-harm,” he says.

“In my eyes, the question is simple. Do we want to educate young people so that they understand the full range of experiences and perspectives that have contributed to world history? If our answer to that is yes, then we, at least in principle, support repeatedly reassessing who is read and studied and questioning what experiences and perspectives are left out. If our answer is no, then, in principle, we support limiting the exposure of the next and subsequent generations to the realities of the world they occupy.”

Emma Smith, professor of Shakespeare studies at the University of Oxford, is shocked at the venom of some of the media coverage of the debate, and links it to other recent attacks on academic freedom. “We are all in defensive mode, I think, as if whatever we say will be wrong, what with ‘Brexit lecturers’ and ‘leftie heads of colleges’ and ‘social apartheid’,” she says.

Smith, who three years ago led an initiative at her college, Hertford, to replace the portraits of long-dead men with newly commissioned photographs of female alumni, welcomes the debate on broadening the syllabus, including in her own discipline – Shakespeare studies is one area that the Cambridge students singled out as meriting a postcolonial approach.

“I think this is exciting and prioritises new ways of seeing the canon, as well as bringing in new writers,” she says. “Decolonising to me is about developing and employing the critical, historical and conceptual tools to see how ‘English’ literature – like other ‘English’ things like tea and St George – is deeply, richly, problematically interconnected with ongoing histories of travel, colonisation, empire and migration.”

Gurminder K Bhambra, professor of postcolonial and decolonial studies at the University of Sussex, is amused – almost – that it took a row at Cambridge to get the issue widely reported in the media. She has created a website, Global Social Theory – now being contributed to by academics, students and people interested in the subject from all over the world – precisely to provide a wider view.

“Some of us have been working in this area for many, many years,” Bhambra says. “However, the debate the students have started is welcome and important, if it helps more people to understand that this is not about narrowing, it is about broadening.”


Maev Kennedy

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Universities face cut in historic building fund

Oxford, Cambridge and King's College London worst affected by cuts in buildings maintenance budget

Polly Curtis, education editor

30, Oct, 2009 @12:09 AM

Article image
More A-level students will need A* to get into top universities

Leading universities increase the number of courses requiring elite grade

Jessica Shepherd, education correspondent

25, Jan, 2011 @8:58 AM

Article image
Cambridge tops Guardian University Guide league table again

University scores highest in 16 out of 47 subjects, with Oxford placed second and LSE leapfrogging St Andrews into third
• Click here to see the full league tables

Jeevan Vasagar, education editor

21, May, 2012 @4:00 PM

Article image
Cambridge University's poor diversity record highlighted by report
One college did not offer a place to any black applicants between 2012 and 2016

Ben Quinn

03, Jun, 2018 @6:33 PM

Article image
Truss and Sunak’ ideas on education are ‘sugar-rush’ policymaking, says expert
Tory leadership candidates want to bring back grammar schools among other campaign promises but critics are wary

Sally Weale Education correspondent

08, Aug, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
Elite universities still struggling to boost underprivileged intake

Figures shine a light on institutions where less than 5% of students came from 'low participation neighbourhoods'

Rachel Williams

15, Apr, 2010 @2:51 PM

Article image
Cambridge academics seek to 'decolonise' English syllabus
University condemns abuse directed at group of students who sought to broaden literature studies to include black authors

Maev Kennedy

25, Oct, 2017 @2:22 PM

Article image
Storm of student protest over Gaza gathers force

Sit-ins at 16 universities spell return to radicalism, fuelled by social networking and blogs

Anthea Lipsett & Alison Benjamin

23, Jan, 2009 @5:33 PM

Article image
Protests over Gaza spread to eight English universities

LSE director Howard Davies issues joint statement with demonstrators

Anthea Lipsett

22, Jan, 2009 @1:38 PM

Article image
Oxford accused of 'social apartheid' as colleges admit no black students
Labour MP attacks university where one in three colleges failed to admit a black British student with A-levels in 2015

Richard Adams and Helena Bengtsson

19, Oct, 2017 @8:00 PM