Education’s black history gap must end | Letters

Letters: Ignorance of how most immigrants came to be in the UK is rife, suggesting that the topic has barely been addressed by the educational establishment. Our children should be told that most of the ‘greatness’ of Britain came by exploitation of other people

As a young man in the 1960s, I lived for a few years in Trinidad (UK children should be taught black history, says Oyelowo, 10 February), finding a country almost split in two on racial lines: the descendants of slaves the British had brought from Africa, and the indentured labourers we forcibly brought out of India after slavery was abolished. This first-hand experience of what we British had done told me more than I had ever learned in any history lessons. This has stayed with me ever since, and I recall coming back to the UK to Enoch Powell’s racist bilge, which made me hate him even more, especially after seeing full-page advertisements in local papers in Trinidad, placed by the NHS and recruiting staff while he was health minister.

I don’t know what kids have been taught in the decades since then, but ignorance of how most immigrants came to be here is rife, suggesting that the topic has barely been addressed by the educational establishment. Our children should be told that most of the “greatness” of Britain came by exploitation of other people, directly as in slavery, indirectly by indentured labour and, of course, through our strong colonial presence in much of the world from Africa to Burma and beyond. We should be teaching our children this, if only to stop the sub-racist bilge that passes for policy in many parts of the political world, and not just Ukip.
David Reed

• I remember as an inspector sitting in a classroom in a comprehensive, when the history teacher introduced the GCSE syllabus to a class of 13-year-olds. He had thoughtfully given each pupil a copy of what to expect if they were to choose history as one of their subjects in year 10. A black girl got up and asked: “Will there be outs?” The teacher was momentarily puzzled. “You know, sir, will we be going out? You can’t do history unless we go out.” The teacher confirmed her point to which she said: “Then I will do history.”

Then he asked them to look at the list of optional topics and explained how they could choose one for their coursework. Again the black girl got up and said: “My ancestors were slaves. I want to do a study of slavery, but it is not on the list.” The history teacher had to admit that she could not introduce a topic of her own choice. “Then I won’t do history,” she said, and sat down allowing the piece of paper to flutter across the classroom. I’ve never forgotten that lesson. I reflected that if we could not accommodate an interested pupil’s request, at least as part of coursework, then there would not be much hope for achieving the commitment and integration of black communities; nor extending the teaching of black history.
Simon Clements

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
'Students need to know the harrowing truth': teachers on black history in the curriculum
Should black history be compulsory in England’s schools? We talk to educators

Donna Ferguson

03, Oct, 2020 @7:00 AM

Article image
Hundreds of schools in England sign up for anti-racist curriculum
Grassroots groups, teachers and councils helping to update syllabus after young people demand change

David Batty, Nazia Parveen and Tobi Thomas

26, Mar, 2021 @3:00 PM

Article image
Many GCSE pupils never study a book by a black author
Exam board AQA features no black writers on GCSE English literature syllabus

Sally Weale and Lanre Bakare

30, Sep, 2020 @5:00 AM

Article image
Black British history: the row over the school curriculum in England
From the omission of the black Tudors to the absence of empire, data reveals how GCSE history is taught

Anna Leach, Antonio Voce and Ashley Kirk

13, Jul, 2020 @9:00 AM

Article image
Secret Teacher: the UK has a complex racial history. Why aren’t we teaching it?​
Recent controversy over an H&M advert left my students struggling to make sense of the issue. The curriculum must do more to reflect the histories of ethnic minorities

The Secret Teacher

20, Jan, 2018 @7:00 AM

Article image
Calls grow for black history to be taught to all English school pupils
Campaigners are collecting support for open letter and want to meet education secretary

Sally Weale , Lanre Bakare and Saima Mir

08, Jun, 2020 @4:55 PM

Article image
National curriculum in England ‘systematically omits' Black British history
The Black Curriculum report says England’s ‘white, Eurocentric curriculum’ fails to reflect UK society

Sally Weale

25, Nov, 2020 @12:01 AM

Article image
'I was shielded from my history': the changes young black Britons are calling for
Exclusive: from schools to policing, 50 people share their experiences of growing up in the UK

Lucy Campbell

30, Jul, 2020 @9:48 AM

In praise of… history | Editorial
Editorial: History boggles minds but also opens them, turning young minds towards optimism as well as understanding


15, Mar, 2011 @12:05 AM

Letters: Turning fragments from the past into a coherent history
Letters: I should like to see any revision of the curriculum to be based on a commitment to a continuous, coherent and chronological account of our nation's history

22, Nov, 2010 @12:05 AM