School science needs practical experiments | Letters

Letters: Ofqual plans to remove practical science work from the overall grade for GCSE and A-level science will leave pupils ill-prepared for when they leave school

The education secretary is right to fear Ofqual plans to remove practical science work from the overall grade for GCSE and A-level science (Nicky Morgan calls for Ofqual U-turn on scrapping science practicals, 28 January). The plans are a downgrading of science experiments that will leave pupils ill-prepared for when they leave school.

Finding things out for yourself is at the very heart of science. Ofqual’s argument is that some schools are only doing a really narrow set of experiments and that some teachers are too generous in the marks they give. They say this means we should no longer include the very skills that young people need as part of their overall assessment. That is short-sighted and defeatist. We need to find a solution that actually serves young people and society rather than a quick fix for the bureaucrats.

While I understand Ofqual’s need to assert its independence, it cannot allow that independence to back it into a corner. Scientists, educators and universities have stated from the start that Ofqual’s decision is the wrong one. Surely Ofqual must now recognise this and reverse changes before real damage is done to science in the UK.
Paul Nurse
President of the Royal Society

• For all their emphasis on “rigour”, it is not education ministers obsessing about the 12 times table that will enhance the learning process (Zoe Williams, 2 February). This happens when trained teachers enthused by their job interact well with their pupils, who grow in confidence, learn to make balanced judgments and nurture other personal qualities that are intangible, rather than measurable. Subjecting children to endless tests will no more improve their education than constantly measuring a tree will make it grow.
Barry Samuel
Reigate, Surrey

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Ofqual to press ahead with A-level science reforms despite criticisms
Chief exam regulator says claims that reforms will weaken students’ practical lab skills ‘couldn’t be further from the truth’

Richard Adams, education editor

04, Feb, 2015 @7:00 AM

Article image
Faulty science behind a ‘superior education’ at grammar school? | Letter
Letter: Two basic errors are shown in your picture of a science lesson at a grammar school


11, Sep, 2016 @5:34 PM

Article image
Nicky Morgan calls for Ofqual U-turn on scrapping science practicals
Education secretary criticises move to keep lab work out of A-level and GCSE results, in first test of regulator’s independence

Richard Adams, education editor

27, Jan, 2015 @7:34 PM

Article image
School science needs more money, not more practical exams | Letters
Letters: There are far greater threats to practical work in science: desperate underfunding in state schools and increasing class sizes

09, Feb, 2015 @7:43 PM

Article image
Academisation and a school system on the brink | Letters
Letters: I must protest at the intention of the government to abolish parent governors


24, Mar, 2016 @7:28 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on the education bill: needs improvement | Editorial
Editorial: Nicky Morgan is wrong to remove parents’ right to object to a school being forced to convert to an academy. It’s their child’s education


22, Jun, 2015 @6:57 PM

Article image
Practical work must remain part of science A-levels, say experts
Scientists, universities and employers lambast Ofqual proposals to dispense with laboratory experiments in schools

Richard Adams, education editor

17, Jan, 2014 @7:45 PM

In praise of … science practicals | Editorial
Editorial: Ofqual's decision to remove science practicals from exams could mean the most engaging part of the subject being lost altogether


15, Jan, 2014 @11:00 PM

Response: It's nonsense to claim Britain produces too many science graduates
Response: The skills our students gain are highly sought after across the jobs market, says Peter Main

Peter Main

14, Sep, 2011 @5:59 PM

Higher education: Strategies for science | Editorial
Editorial: The universities minister faces a difficult choice between scientific excellence and student numbers


11, Jul, 2010 @11:05 PM