Want horror for Halloween? Critics pick music, books, games and more to help

From a creepy Hollywood comedy to trick or treat for gamers, Guardian critics suggest their cultural classics


Forget slasher films – the essential Halloween movie is Frank Capra’s 1944 comedy Arsenic and Old Lace, which takes place one Halloween night in Brooklyn in a creepy old house next to a churchyard. Cary Grant plays Mortimer Brewster, a drama critic who discovers on his wedding day that his sweet old maiden aunts are, in fact, serial killers with bodies piled up in their cellar. Then his long-lost brother turns up – also a serial killer, with the same body count as the old ladies, and who, to evade capture, has had plastic surgery, making him resemble the horror icon Boris Karloff (played by Raymond Massey – Karloff performed the role in the Broadway version). It has to be the most meta event in Hollywood history. A rather delirious 31 October. Peter Bradshaw



American Horror Story: Double Feature.
Something wicked ... American Horror Story: Double Feature. Photograph: FX

Nothing is as scary as familiarity, slightly twisted. American Horror Story: Double Feature (Disney+), Ryan Murphy and Brad Falchuk’s latest in their anthology series embraces that principle, mining horror from generic 20th-century American mythologies via separate but gradually intertwining storylines. The first part concerns an author battling writer’s block who attempts to free his muse, while staying in a seaside town where a picture-perfect veneer conceals unspeakable wickedness. The second dives into a world of aliens and US politics – surely the most terrifying realm of all. The great thing about drawing on events that have been marinated in conspiracy theories is that they have already taken on an almost fictive quality: this year’s Halloween fright is knowing the horror is all around you. Phil Harrison



Costume Quest.
Child fiendly … Costume Quest. Photograph: Midnight City

There are hundreds of good horror games out there, and you can watch amped-up teenagers scream over any one of them on YouTube, but none of those remind you what it was like to be a kid at Halloween. Costume Quest stars a gang of wee kids donning costumes to fight spooks, collecting candy and rescuing a kidnapped sibling. Keza MacDonald



Shirley Jackson’s The Haunting of Hill House

Is there a more deliciously terrifying moment in all of literature than this, in Shirley Jackson’s The Haunting of Hill House? Eleanor is lying in bed in the “black darkness”, clutching her friend Theodora’s hand as they listen to mad, wild cries of panic in the night – and then the light comes on, and Eleanor sees Theodora across the room: “Good God – whose hand was I holding?” This 1959 novel is the ultimate ghost story, never bettered, telling of anthropologist Dr Montague as he investigates a supposedly haunted house – “somehow a maniac juxtaposition, a badly turned angle, some chance meeting of roof and sky, turned Hill House into a place of despair” – along with three recruits. As Jackson shows with chilling brilliance, the people can be as haunted as the house. Alison Flood



She wolf … Shakira.
Hungry like the wolf … Shakira. Photograph: Joseph Eid/AFP/Getty Images

Although it wasn’t specifically written for Halloween, She Wolf sees Colombian legend Shakira thriving and writhing on immaculate synthpop form, her vocals dancing with the spirit of all great accidentally spooky tunes – campy, vaguely ridiculous, but undisputedly banging in the right open-minded party setting. Has the word “lycanthropy” ever been used better in a pop song? Has it ever been used at all? On the theme of great genre-adjacent Halloween hits, this dedication to one’s inner wild side can be filed next to Nelly Furtado’s Maneater and Kelis’s Trick Me – emblems of a time when pop production was fully beginning to embrace the fun of all things dark. Jenessa Williams


Peter Bradshaw, Alison Flood, Keza MacDonald, Phil Harrison and Jenessa Williams

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Getting over a breakup? Critics pick music, books, games and more to help
Heartbreak is the ailment, could culture be the cure? Our critics’ suggestions to help ease your pain – or channel your angst

Jenessa Williams, Justine Jordan, Keza MacDonald, Peter Bradshaw and Jonathan Jones

11, Oct, 2021 @9:00 AM

Article image
Dirty work: film, books, games and more to help with the daily grind
From Office Space to the Rakes’ 22 Grand Job, Guardian critics suggest culture to cope with the pressure, politics and crushing ennui of earning a living

Phil Harrison, Sam Jordison, Danny Leigh, Keza MacDonald and Jenessa Williams

25, Oct, 2021 @9:00 AM

Article image
Driven to distraction: the best film, music, games and more to prepare for a road trip
From a coming-of-age tale in rural Mexico to zen thoughts on London’s streets, our critics get their cultural motors running

Michael Cragg, Sam Jordison, Sasha Mistlin, Hollie Richardson and Keith Stuart

25, Jul, 2022 @9:00 AM

Article image
A bit of rough: books, music, art and more to help with a hangover
You’ve had a big one, but what goes up must come down. From gentle piano to breezy laughs, our critics offer salves for sore heads

Jenessa Williams, Jason Okundaye, Sam Jordison, Rebecca Liu and Jonathan Jones

05, Dec, 2022 @10:00 AM

Article image
Sip, sip, hooray! Film, music, art and more about drinking
Whether your tipple is Mad Men, Roger Scruton or a game set in Satan’s afterparty, our critics toast the best culture about booze

Jessica Kiang, Phil Harrison, Keza MacDonald, Michael Cragg, Steven Poole

13, Dec, 2021 @10:00 AM

Article image
Astral peaks: music, books, art and more about the majesty of space
From beautiful celestial metaphors to a virtual simulacrum of an entire galaxy, our critics suggest popular culture inspired by the wonders of astronomy

Jonathan Jones, Jenessa Williams, Sam Jordison, Luke Holland and Jessica Kiang

14, Mar, 2022 @10:00 AM

Article image
Christmas crackers: books, films, games and more to kickstart your festivities
From a trans LA showdown to a pastoral Nintendo game, Guardian critics have the yuletide covered

Danny Leigh, Kate Wyver, Jenessa Williams, Sam Jordison and Keza MacDonald

20, Dec, 2021 @10:00 AM

Article image
Succeeding Succession: books, games, music and more about the ultra rich
As Succession returns to our screens, Guardian critics offer artists’ varied takes on the seductive and corruptive nature of excessive riches

Sam Jordison, Keza MacDonald, Danny Leigh, Jonathan Jones and Jenessa Williams

18, Oct, 2021 @9:00 AM

Article image
Pitch perfect: books, music, art and more about football
With the Qatar World Cup imminent, our critics offer up cultural highlights – from a damning tale of homophobia to David Peace’s Damned Utd – about the ‘beautiful game’

Jonathan Jones , Sam Jordison, Jessica Kiang, Jason Okundaye and Jenessa Williams

14, Nov, 2022 @10:00 AM

Article image
Iced gems: art, books, music and more to keep the home fires burning this winter
From storm-tossed seascapes to skating on the Thames, our cultural critics select wintry wonders for the season’s dark days

Sam Jordison, Rebecca Liu, Keza MacDonald, Skye Sherwin and Jenessa Williams

19, Dec, 2022 @10:00 AM