UK government’s heritage culture war is stifling museums, say trustees

Pressure to support Tory position on contentious issues such as colonialism ‘cancels honest debate’

Ministers are facing mounting anger over claims that they are deliberately stifling “honest and open debate” as part of a culture war, with a concerted campaign to purge dissenting voices from positions in Britain’s leading museums, galleries and major cultural bodies.

Trustees, board members and prominent academics have told the Observer there have been demands for them to delete social media posts critical of Boris Johnson or sign “loyalty pledges” backing government policies.

Some also warned that the drive was now having a chilling effect on the research projects some institutions order and the exhibitions they back, shying away from issues such as colonialism and slavery that are deemed too political.

The news comes after two prominent resignations prompted by government attempts to foster cultural institutions more in tune with its own views on issues such as decolonisation and the return of artefacts.

Last week, Sarah Dry, an author who writes about the history of science, withdrew her application to be reappointed as a trustee of the Science Museum Group after being asked to back the government’s policy against the removal of contentious historical objects.

Dry told the Observer that the “long-established arm’s-length principle governing Britain’s national museums is worth defending”.

“Only by remaining free of government interference can our museums continue to earn the trust of the public and to do work of the quality and integrity for which they are admired around the world,” she said. “Requiring trustees to support specific government policy sets a worrying precedent that extends beyond current debates over contested heritage.

View of the Science Museum's transport display seen from above, with a vintage car and boat and a silver propeller plane suspended in mid-air from the ceiling
The Science Museum in London, where historian Sarah Dry withdrew her application to be reappointed as a trustee. Photograph: Dan Kitwood/Getty Images

“Trustees must be free to advise museum staff in making curatorial and interpretative decisions based on their professional judgment and expertise, not government policy. I remain deeply committed to the mission of the Science Museum Group and I made the decision to withdraw from the board with regret.”

Meanwhile, Sir Charles Dunstone, the billionaire founder of Carphone Warehouse, quit as chair of the Royal Museums Greenwich after ministers blocked the reappointment of Aminul Hoque, one of his trustees, whose work promotes the decolonisation of the curriculum. Prof Frances Corner, the warden of Goldsmiths, University of London, where Hoque lectures, wrote to the culture secretary, Oliver Dowden, last week to complain over the intervention. She told him the decision had been met with “shock and alarm”.

“Without an adequate explanation, this decision may well be seen as part of a pattern in which a government that claims to champion free speech in fact seeks to cancel honest and open debate,” she wrote. “On behalf of our academic community I urge you, respectfully, to reconsider your apparent policy with regards to public appointments.”

Concerns are now widespread in academia, with complaints that the freedom traditionally enjoyed by cultural bodies is being reined in by the government. “Arm’s-length is becoming knuckle-length,” said one museum curator. Some senior academics have been raising the issue with the British Academy, urging the body to protest.

Peter Mandler, professor of modern cultural history at Cambridge University, said: “There’s a long and proud tradition in this country of establishing a degree of independence for publicly funded bodies relating to freedoms of expression – universities, museums, charities, the arts. The current government seems determined to limit that independence in order to pursue a ‘culture war’ to please some of its backbenchers.

“Loyalty oaths and explicit political tests for the appointment of trustees don’t sit well with academic freedom and curatorial independence. This will undoubtedly restrict the ability of museums and heritage bodies to do a professional job, drawing on the best talents in their fields of study. It is already engendering excessive caution, self-censorship and backward looking in bodies that we expect to be bold and bright and innovative.”

The Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport said: “Publicly funded bodies have a duty to operate in a way which is impartial and not motivated by activism or politics. The government’s policy of ‘retain and explain’ on issues of contested heritage fully respects the independence of museums and galleries, as the chair of the National Museums Directors’ Council has acknowledged.”


Michael Savage

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Colston protester says Tories are misusing their acquittals to fan flames of culture war
Rhian Graham, cleared of criminal damage for her part in toppling the statue of the slave trader, says a vital debate about Britain’s history is being hijacked

Tom Wall

09, Jan, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
Bronzes to Benin, gold to Ghana … museums under fire on looted art
After Emmanuel Macron’s pledge, British institutions face questions on exhibits looted in the colonial era

Ruth Maclean Dakar

02, Dec, 2018 @6:00 AM

Article image
Dead wrong: Victorians ‘mistaken’ about why Egyptians mummified bodies
Colonial Egyptologists assumed the mummification process was to preserve the body after death. But new evidence asserts it was to steer the body towards divinity

Vanessa Thorpe Arts and media correspondent

12, Nov, 2022 @3:00 PM

Article image
Mrs Livingstone, I presume? Museum to feature role of explorer’s wife
Revamped gallery to reveal the importance – and presence – of Mary Moffat in missionary’s life and travels

Vanessa Thorpe

20, Jun, 2021 @9:00 AM

Article image
Revealed: How Lord Salisbury hid rape by his British consul in Benin
Shocking papers in Foreign Office archives strengthen case for giving looted bronzes back to Nigeria

Dalya Alberge

21, Nov, 2021 @10:15 AM

Article image
National Trust sees off culture war rebellion in an AGM of discontent
After the worries over ‘wokeness’, hunting was the day’s big issue

Vanessa Thorpe & James Tapper

30, Oct, 2021 @8:50 PM

Article image
Mystery over origins of Howard Hodgkin’s Indian art collection could see it lost to UK
Ashmolean in Oxford turned down chance to buy exquisite paintings and drawings, which may now go to New York

Dalya Alberge

11, Apr, 2021 @7:15 AM

Article image
Barbados plans to make Tory MP pay reparations for family’s slave past
Richard Drax reported to have visited Caribbean island for meeting on next steps, including plans for former sugar plantation

Paul Lashmar and Jonathan Smith in Barbados

26, Nov, 2022 @5:16 PM

Article image
Rappers and Rubens: London’s museums embrace the night
A new festival follows a worldwide example by bringing life to the capital’s halls of culture after dark, with music, dancers and poets

Vanessa Thorpe

08, Sep, 2019 @9:00 AM

Article image
High costs and terror fears keep Britons from museums
Domestic visits fall even as foreign tourism rises, amid concerns over soaring ticket prices and safety

Vanessa Thorpe

25, Mar, 2018 @12:05 AM