The Proposition: Nick Cave’s savage outback western reveals ugly truths about Australia

Released in 2005, this brutal tale of sibling conflict is set against the backdrop of colonial racism, violence and misogyny

  • The Proposition is streaming on Binge and Foxtel in Australia. For more recommendations of what to stream in Australia, click here

The second feature film written by the musician Nick Cave is a grisly, sweat-stained tale of outback violence and colonial oppression that has lost none of its power in the 16 years since its release. Directed by John Hillcoat, The Proposition is awash with striking scenery and ugly truths about Australia.

After a fierce gunfight, outlaw Charlie Burns (Guy Pearce) and his brother Mike (Richard Wilson) are captured by Captain Stanley (Ray Winstone). Although both brothers are former members of the notorious Burns gang, Stanley’s real target is their sadistic older sibling Arthur (Danny Huston), who is wanted for the brutal murder of a local family.

With no lead on Arthur, Stanley turns to more “inventive” methods, offering Charlie a proposition. He will release Charlie, while Mike will hang in nine days for the crimes of the Burns gang. But both will be pardoned if Charlie can locate and kill Arthur. Mike is naive and not able to mentally comprehend their situation, so Charlie feels he has no choice but to protect his younger brother and accept Stanley’s deal.

Cave’s script presents a compelling dilemma for our antihero and a nuanced view of characters who don’t fit into pigeonholes of “good” or “bad”. In so doing, The Proposition is able to make a much bigger point about the realities of life during colonial rule in the 1880s.

Stanley’s mandate is to “civilise” the country but we need only see him wearing a heavy woollen coat in 40C heat, sweat running down his face, to understand the absurdity of transposing a British way of life on to a land where it will not fit. Just like the fake snow his wife Martha (Emily Watson) orders for Christmas, it is all artifice.

The captain views the country as something to be conquered. “Australia, what fresh hell is this?” he opines, while the Burns gang view nature as a salve, hiding out in remote caves and stopping to appreciate the beauty of a sunset … before embarking on a killing spree.

The colonial settlers’ “civility” certainly doesn’t apply to treatment of the local Aboriginal people, who are exploited as servants or massacred in response to perceived injustices. Meanwhile, Martha is left to rattle around an empty house on her own lest she come to town to be objectified by Stanley’s men or patronised by town officials.

Whether depicting horror or beauty, The Proposition is visually arresting. The violence is staged with wince-inducing authenticity, in stark contrast to the beauty of the cinematography, with languid views of dusky horizons and parched panoramas.

The core cast – Pearce, Winstone, Huston and Watson – are exceptional, complemented by a supporting cast featuring John Hurt as a scene-stealing bounty hunter, David Wenham as a prim but odious town official and David Gulpilil as a tracker on the trail of the Burns gang. Tom E Lewis (Balang Lewis) – who compared the intensity of The Proposition to that of his acclaimed debut, The Chant of Jimmie Blacksmith – is also noteworthy as gang member Two Bob.

Guy Pearce and John Hurt
The violence is staged with wince-inducing authenticity. Photograph: FirstLook/Everett/Rex Features

The Proposition was not Cave and Hillcoat’s first collaboration. They worked together on 1988’s dystopian prison drama Ghosts … of the Civil Dead as well as the soundtrack to Hillcoat’s second feature, To Have and to Hold, and the video for Nick Cave & the Bad Seeds’ Babe, I’m On Fire.

The Proposition’s score is a collaboration between Cave and Warren Ellis and is as integral as any character. Raspy vocals and screeching strings provide the perfect sonic anxiety to the chases and violence, while melancholy violin and piano accompany shots of stunning horizons and characters awaiting inexorable confrontations.

At heart The Proposition is a savage yet utterly compelling story. Its gritty, uniquely Australian take on the western deserves to be recognised as one of the genre’s best.


Adam Fleet

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Proposition rewatched – outback western mixes violence and profundity
Director John Hillcoat’s blood-splattered revenge film revises a classic film genre with help from Guy Pearce, Ray Winstone and Nick Cave

Luke Buckmaster

29, Jan, 2015 @10:33 PM

Article image
Five hidden gems from Nick Cave’s catalogue | Henry Wagons
As Double J kicks off Nick Cave Week, the station’s Henry Wagons dissects some of Cave’s lesser-known triumphs

Henry Wagons

05, Sep, 2016 @2:25 AM

Article image
The Drover’s Wife: The Legend of Molly Johnson review – riveting but heavy-handed outback western
While it doesn’t always hit the mark, Leah Purcell’s Indigenous feminist reimagining of Henry Lawson’s classic is a bullet between the eyes of a whitewashed fable

Debbie Zhou

08, Nov, 2021 @1:59 AM

Article image
Warwick Thornton: racists have ruined the Southern Cross for everyone
Australia’s fantasies about its past are a real problem, says the Indigenous director ahead of the world premiere of his new film, We Don’t Need A Map

07, Jun, 2017 @3:14 AM

Article image
High Ground review – Simon Baker narrowly escapes white saviour tropes in colonial Australia
A white sharpshooter and an Indigenous survivor of a massacre reunite after 12 years in a gracefully directed but rather Anglo-centric western

Luke Buckmaster

26, Jan, 2021 @4:30 PM

Article image
The Song Keepers: ancient German hymns find new life in Australian outback
Naina Sen’s joyful, compassionate film about an Aboriginal women’s choir shows the complex, unexpected consequences of colonisation

Jack Latimore

19, Apr, 2018 @2:24 AM

Article image
Complaints about racism increasing, Screen Australia’s top Indigenous executive says
Bigotry in film and TV industry will not disappear of its own accord, Penny Smallacombe says in wake of Neighbours allegations

Kelly Burke

08, Apr, 2021 @1:26 AM

Article image
Motorkite Dreaming: ultralight aircraft adventure leads to profound truths about Indigenous culture
New film sees ‘rank amateurs’ flying in Western Australia for eight weeks, immersing themselves in remote communities

Steve Dow

09, Aug, 2016 @6:10 AM