Enlightened: Laura Dern’s best role was smart, brave and ahead of its time

The series was cancelled in 2013 but its biggest crime was being born too soon. Now streaming in Australia, here’s hoping it gets the audience it deserves

What happens when an annoying narcissist has a spiritual awakening? Do they become different? Better? Or does real change require much more than learning how to meditate?

Enlightened, starring Laura Dern, aired for two seasons on HBO from 2011 to 2013. Critics loved it, a third season was on the cards – but it never got the mainstream viewership it deserved and was cancelled due to poor ratings.

Its biggest crime back then, it seems, was to be born too soon. Now streaming in Australia on Binge, it’s stood the test of time.

When Enlightened first screened, streaming services were in their infancy and the TV landscape was more conservative and dominated by the risk-averse network model. These days female anti-heroes and shows that mash up comedy with drama are the norm.

The premise is simple: a self-destructive woman, Amy Jellicoe (Dern), is having an affair with her boss and has a nervous breakdown at the office. A buyer at a major firm, she’s been demoted from health and beauty to the cleaning products department and is furious. When we meet Amy, she has mascara running down her cheeks, is crying in the toilets and then – with the strength that comes from sheer rage – manages to prise open the doors of an elevator to confront her cowardly boss.

After taking a month out to attend a wellness retreat in Hawaii, she comes back enlightened and tranquil. Returning to the banally evil corporation where she once had an office and an assistant, Amy is working in the basement with all the other corporate misfits doing menial data entry work.

Her enlightened state vanishes almost immediately.

In many ways Enlightened depicts how humans are a work in progress. We might think we’ve changed, but a new challenge or an old trigger has the power to knock us back to our old selves.

Dern plays a complicated character who is hard to like in the same way that Girls’ Hannah Horvath was. Amy means well, but the volume is up to 100 and she can’t read a room to save herself. Despite all the self-help books, her ego constantly gets in the way. She wants to save the world, but treats the people around her as expendable. She appears in some of her more obnoxious scenes like an early prototype of a Karen.

Wanting to change the world doesn’t ease your character flaws. You may think you want to work at a homeless shelter (as Amy does in the first season) but you’ll still turn your nose up at the pay.

This year Vox called Enlightened the stand-out performance of Dern’s career and the start of a run of excellent turns including in Big Little Lies and Marriage Story. The role of Amy was created especially for her by writer and co-star Mike White; it is Dern’s performance, and what she can do with her mobile face, that makes this show a must-watch.

While Enlightened saves most of its satire for the corporate world, there is a more subtle critique of the wellness industry running through the two seasons. An idyllic (and expensive) retreat in Hawaii will take you away from your worries for a while, but it doesn’t take long for the glow to wear off. What these retreats often don’t prepare you for is life outside: your annoying co-worker (Mike White), your drug-addicted ex-husband (Luke Wilson), your beaten-down mother (played by Dern’s real life mother Diane Ladd). And they certainly won’t dismantle society’s social problems or structural inequalities.

Over the two short seasons, Amy morphs not from loser to success story – or from unenlightened to spiritual – but from an individual seeking fulfilment to a social justice warrior who tries to change the system from within. That her quest and transformation happens while the character still remains annoying is part of the show’s intelligence – and its bravery.

Viewers have become more accustomed to shows that deliver complex characters and more realistic endings. Here’s hoping Enlightened finds the audience it deserved the first time around.

Enlightened is now streaming on Binge


Brigid Delaney

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Ladies and Gentleman, the Fabulous Stains: teenage Diane Lane and Laura Dern rock punk
This long-buried gem from 1982 about a teen-girl punk band subverts the great rock’n’roll swindle of the Sex Pistols

Jenny Valentish

18, Jan, 2021 @4:30 PM

Article image
Evil: whip-smart, campy horror series is far more than X-Files knock-off
While paying homage to the 90s monster-of-the-week genre, this genuinely creepy procedural is more than it first appears

Emily Tatti

26, Sep, 2021 @5:30 PM

Article image
‘Irresistibly funny’: the 20 best shows to binge right now
To help our readers through the latest lockdowns, we recommend the chillest, easiest and most laugh-out-loud series that we couldn’t stop watching

Steph Harmon, Stephanie Convery and Luke Buckmaster

02, Jul, 2021 @9:00 PM

Article image
Scream: darkly funny, extremely meta horror and a 90s time capsule that never gets old
Whether you caught the slasher series the first time around or only got the pop culture supercut, the original Scream films are still worth a watch

Elizabeth Flux

15, Feb, 2021 @4:30 PM

Article image
One Day at a Time: Rita Moreno and Justina Machado in joyously reimagined 70s sitcom
Don’t be put off by the hints of canned laughter. First-class acting and deep pathos ensure this sitcom holds its own with the best of the genre

Greta Parry

24, Jan, 2021 @4:30 PM

Article image
Veronica Mars: Kristen Bell’s wise-cracking, outsider teen detective series is sunshine noir at its best
Stand aside Nancy Drew, this early-noughties cult hit is a virtuoso blend of high-school drama and murder mystery

Lisa Walker

15, Sep, 2021 @2:42 AM

Article image
Lorena: Amazon documentary about the notorious Bobbitt case is a 1990s time capsule
The trial of a woman who cut off her husband’s penis was sensational at the time, but Get Out director Jordan Peele’s series shows just how much it changed

Jenny Valentish

21, May, 2020 @12:00 AM

Article image
Looking: the queer dramedy that was a decade ahead of its time
With the success of recent queer shows like Heartstopper and It’s a Sin, this HBO series starring Jonathan Groff and Murray Bartlett deserves revisiting

Mark Yin

17, May, 2022 @5:30 PM

Article image
Future Man: bonkers time-travel series full of smut, toilet humour and sci-fi fun
Lowly janitor Josh gets recruited through a video game to fight a future war. Sound familiar? This is the show for you

Van Badham

24, Jun, 2020 @2:28 AM

Article image
Loving Winning Time? You must watch Celtics/Lakers: Best of Enemies
This basketball documentary on the rivalry between Magic Johnson and Larry Bird balances 1980s excess with complex social commentary

Nathan Jolly

22, Mar, 2022 @4:30 PM