Bronzes to Benin, gold to Ghana … museums under fire on looted art

After Emmanuel Macron’s pledge, British institutions face questions on exhibits looted in the colonial era

Thousands of African artworks taken during the colonial era line the cabinets and halls of UK institutions, from the Wallace Collection to the V&A museum. They include the Benin bronzes, the Ghanaian Asante gold, and treasures stolen from the Ethiopian emperor Tewodros II during the 1868 Battle of Magdala.

Now, following groundbreaking moves by France to return some of the works looted by its colonial forces, these museums are facing calls from the African art world for an audit of who has what – and how much longer they should keep them.

“It’s a step in the right direction. France has taken a bold position,” said Iheanyi Onwuegbucha, a curator at Lagos’s Centre for Contemporary Art, saying that the UK should follow suit. “Even if it’s never ever implemented, it would be good to know, at least, how many objects from Nigeria are in British collections.”

A report commissioned by France’s president, Emmanuel Macron, and released last month, called for French law to be changed and thousands of African objects in France’s museums, which were taken during the colonial period, to be returned. Visiting Burkina Faso last year, Macron said that enabling African art to be showcased “in Paris but also in Dakar, Lagos and Cotonou” would be a priority.

Many say it should also be a priority for the British government. Sylvester Ogbechie, a Nigerian professor of African arts and visual culture at the University of California, Santa Barbara, said Macron’s report was the first time a major western leader acknowledged there was something wrong with European institutions holding looted works, and was a “very positive step”. He said however he was not optimistic other countries would do the same. He said racist attitudes that underpinned colonialism had mostly not changed. “The racial element of this is the primary issue. We need to stop talking about it in terms of capabilities or morality or anything of that sort. The simple reason is that we’re dealing with the context of white supremacy.

“The western world for some odd reason has never accepted that Africans have the rights to their bodies or their own resources.”

President Roch Marc Christian Kabore welcomes Emmanuel Macron to the presidential palace in Burkina Faso.
President Roch Marc Christian Kaboré welcomes Emmanuel Macron to the presidential palace in Burkina Faso. Photograph: Ludovic Marin/AFP

The former curator of the British Museum’s Africa galleries, Chris Spring, said France had “every right and reason to make that report”, and the “very contentious collections” in the UK should be looked at. But he said the British Museum was a “museum of the world for the world”.

“If Africa is not represented, that is a disaster. I think we need to remember London is a global African city, arguably the biggest African city in the world, if you think of all the different people. It’s really important that people of African heritage living in the UK and in Europe can see cultural artefacts of their own heritage.”

The best-known African pieces in the British Museum are the Benin bronzes – intricate metal plaques that decorated the royal palace of Benin but were looted from what is now Nigeria by British troops in 1897. The museum has long resisted calls to return the bronzes, but several experts thought the French move would increase the pressure on it. Days before the report was published, the museum announced it would loan some of the most celebrated pieces for an exhibition at the planned Benin Royal Museum in Nigeria’s Edo State within three years.

Ethics aside, the practicalities of potential restitution concern some. Giles Peppiatt, Bonhams’ director of modern and contemporary African art, said that commissioning the French report was morally right, but questioned its viability. “It’s a laudable principle, but is it something that can be done in an orderly and correct way? It’s not as easy as Macron says – it’s a tiny bit reductive.”

Onwuegbucha echoed those concerns, saying many African countries needed to seriously upgrade their facilities before they could receive the works.

“Nigeria is not ready to receive anything,” he said, describing rundown, leaking museums and insect-infested storage facilities of the country’s public museums and galleries. Years without investment in cultural institutions had taken their toll, he said: “It’s beyond shame, what we have.”

Onwuegbucha added that the pedagogical approach needed to change, claiming that guides working in the museums wrongly tell visitors that the objects were used as “juju”, or black magic, presenting their own, often religious, prejudices as fact. “They don’t present these objects to the public as cultural heritage but rather as a representation of the evil past of our ancestors.”

Ogbechie however, said that if the roles were reversed, the conversation would be very different. “This is essentially as if the Benin kingdom went to London and raided Buckingham Palace,” he said. “And then much later we are discussing this issue and we’re saying, well they may have raided Buckingham Palace but Benin has a right to the works they took from Buckingham Palace because they have it anyway.”


Ruth Maclean Dakar

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Yes, I’m a trustee of English Heritage. And I want the Benin bronzes returned | David Olusoga
Black Britons are still supposed to keep out of the debate on the country’s colonial past

David Olusoga

15, Dec, 2018 @6:30 PM

Article image
Cambridge University to return over 100 looted Benin bronzes to Nigeria
Move to see restitution of 116 historical objects taken by British during the sacking of Benin in 1897

Jane Clinton

14, Dec, 2022 @11:39 PM

Article image
Revealed: How Lord Salisbury hid rape by his British consul in Benin
Shocking papers in Foreign Office archives strengthen case for giving looted bronzes back to Nigeria

Dalya Alberge

21, Nov, 2021 @10:15 AM

Article image
London museum returns looted Benin City artefacts to Nigeria
Six objects stolen by British soldiers in 19th century are handed over in ceremony at Horniman Museum

Harriet Sherwood Arts and culture correspondent

28, Nov, 2022 @6:55 PM

Article image
New museum in Nigeria raises hopes of resolution to Benin bronzes dispute
Artefacts held by British museum and other western institutions were looted by British forces in 1897

Mark Brown Arts correspondent

14, Nov, 2020 @11:54 AM

Article image
Regional museums break ranks with UK government on return of Benin bronzes
Aberdeen says it will repatriate a bust while Cambridge museum has ‘expectation’ its collection could be returned

Lanre Bakare

26, Mar, 2021 @6:36 PM

Article image
Germany returns 21 Benin bronzes to Nigeria – amid frustration at Britain
Artefacts looted in 19th century by UK soldiers and sold on, with many more still held by the British Museum

Philip Oltermann in Abuja

20, Dec, 2022 @3:51 PM

Article image
‘Nobody was expecting it’: British Museum warned reputation seriously damaged and treasures will take decades to recover
Experts say loss of 1,500 items reveals lax cataloguing and boosts case for returning objects to countries of origin

Andrew Anthony

26, Aug, 2023 @4:00 PM

Article image
Secrets of rebel slaves in Barbados will finally be revealed
British Library releases vast trove of digitised 19th-century newspapers to bring stories of fugitives to life

Vanessa Thorpe

18, Jul, 2021 @8:30 AM

Article image
Oxford University identifies 145 artefacts looted in Benin raid
Plundered items likely to be returned to Nigeria include brass plaques, bronze figures and musical instruments

Harriet Sherwood Arts and culture correspondent

19, Nov, 2021 @6:28 PM