This year’s Eurovision was a political statement – whatever the organisers may have wanted | Zoe Williams

President Zelenskiy wasn’t allowed to address the crowd, but the contest was a four-hour anti-war protest – with extra neon

The European Broadcasting Union, which organises Eurovision, is like the European Central Bank: whenever it’s called upon to make an important decision, you can always rely upon it to make the wrong one, and it’s wholly dependent on the mixture of goodwill and inertia that leads the international community not to go on about it. Its bet is a generalised feeling of “Oh well, it made the wrong call again. Never mind. Better luck next year/next global financial crisis”, and it’s one that mainly pays off. This time tomorrow we’ll have forgotten that it wouldn’t let Volodymyr Zelenskiy address the contest, in lieu of Ukraine hosting it, because it didn’t want the event politicised. So I just want to pause for one second to remark how dumb that was.

Inevitably, Ukraine was all anyone was talking about: it was the surtext and subtext, from the opening song, Stefania by the Kalush Orchestra, last year’s Ukrainian winners, to the rousing centre, a rendition of You’ll Never Walk Alone sung by the Netherlands’ Duncan Laurence and also everyone else. The war was lambasted from every angle, while Putin responded to his pariah status by shelling the home town of Ukraine’s entrants, Tvorchi, with the fabulous vindictiveness of an uninvited fairy godmother. To think that by keeping a lid on Ukraine’s president the night could somehow float above world events was laughable: it was a four-hour anti-war protest, with extra neon.

The aim of maintaining neutrality misunderstands either politics or Eurovision, or probably both. Eurovision has been political since its inception, with voting preferences between countries tracking political allegiances closely enough that this has its own field of academic study analysing which countries are in which clusters and how that has changed over time. I feel sure there’s something self-fulfilling about it. The Nordic bloc has appeared thick as thieves since serious statistical analysis began (the late 90s). This built its status as a geopolitical entity, which in turn begat a stronger cultural identity. How could you depoliticise that?

The night itself has always performed a specific political function, something like a family Christmas, where warring parties bring their dispute for arbitration by the group: Turkey v Greece, Armenia v Azerbaijan, Georgia v Russia. It’s actually very like a family Christmas, since the group never really knows how to perform its judicial role and tends to pick a side at random, depending on how drunk it is. Nobody said that Eurovision was effective at politics; it’s just anything but apolitical.

What it does best, politically, is signal disapprobation, nations coming together to chastise or expel the miscreant; it’s much more subtle than a mob. There are degrees of disapproval, from expulsion (Russia in 2022), to a recoverable but painful nul points (the UK in 2003, which was absolutely understood as a response to the invasion of Iraq, the quality of Jemini’s song notwithstanding).

I’ll tell you what was lucky – that the night fell a week after the coronation, not before. If we’d been looking at Penny Mordaunt’s teal battledress after Netta’s insectile warrior carapace, or King Charles’s 40-foot red velvet train post-Croatia’s spectacular floral military wear, we’d have been thinking: this is all very camp, highly melodramatic, just like Eurovision, only not as good – come on, he didn’t even strip to his pants. All rituals are alike, but they’re not all born equal: they exist to muster us around a principle. The principle of Eurovision – that there’s more that unites us than divides us, or in Liverpool’s words, “united we stand” – may be schmaltzy, but at least (unlike, say, “fealty”) it means something.

  • Zoe Williams is a Guardian columnist


Zoe Williams

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Eurovision organisers rebuff Zelenskiy request to give video speech at final
European Broadcasting Union, which oversees song contest, says appearance by Ukrainian president could politicise the event

Nadeem Badshah

11, May, 2023 @9:52 PM

Article image
Ukrainians can feel Europe losing interest – Eurovision is our chance to rally support | Olena Topolia
When I competed in 2010, I could not have imagined I’d be forced to flee a Russian invasion with my young children, says the Ukrainian performer Olena Topolia, aka Aloysha

Olena Topolia

13, May, 2022 @1:42 PM

Article image
Sunak and Starmer criticise decision to deny Zelenskiy a Eurovision speech
Producers of event refuse Ukraine president’s request to speak over fears of politicising contest

Joe Middleton

12, May, 2023 @6:45 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on the Eurovision song contest: how to protest and survive | Editorial
Editorial: Jamala’s song about the fate of the Crimean Tatars in the Stalin era stands in a long and glorious tradition of political music making


16, May, 2016 @6:40 PM

Article image
How do people see Russia? Eurovision gave one answer | Mary Dejevsky
Ukraine triumphed – but the popular vote suggested a more nuanced view of Russia than has often been assumed

Mary Dejevsky

15, May, 2016 @6:54 PM

Article image
Score-settling, boo suppression and voter arrests: will this be the most electric Eurovision ever?
With Russia banned and Ukraine the favourite, this year’s song contest will be momentous. Can the nations unite against Putin? Could we see another police roundup? And how did a Kyiv rapper’s tribute to his mum become an anthem for peace?

Alexi Duggins

03, May, 2022 @5:00 AM

Article image
Russia picks Ukrainian singer for Eurovision song contest
Kiev's Anastasia Prikhodko, one of Ukraine's former contenders, has been selected by Russian TV viewers and judges as the country's 2009 Eurovision entry

Sean Michaels

10, Mar, 2009 @11:01 AM

Article image
Ukraine minister ‘confused’ by Eurovision refusal to let Zelenskiy speak
Exclusive: Culture minister says he was puzzled about reasoning for not allowing president to address song contest

Josh Halliday in Liverpool

14, May, 2023 @9:04 AM

Article image
Russia is banned from Eurovision after invasion of Ukraine
After a U-turn, organisers say Russia’s inclusion could ‘bring the competition into disrepute’

Tobi Thomas

25, Feb, 2022 @5:22 PM

Article image
Anger in Moscow, joy in Kiev, after Ukraine's Eurovision triumph
Russian politicians call for boycott of next year’s contest in protest at the political content of Jamala’s winning song, 1944

Shaun Walker Moscow correspondent

15, May, 2016 @5:56 PM