Brexit was meant to be ‘done’, but in 2023 UK-EU harmony will still be a distant dream | Anand Menon

From squabbles over finance to disagreements about electric vehicles, discord with the EU will define the next few years

Just under three years since the United Kingdom left the European Union – and over six since it voted to do so – the bilateral relationship remains a subject of often bitter debate between the two sides and within the UK itself. This is hardly surprising. The 2016 referendum was deeply divisive: leave and remain identities persist to this day. Moreover, the two sides are still at loggerheads over the Northern Ireland protocol. Yet there is a structural element to this too, which implies that, come what may, a stable equilibrium in UK-EU relations will remain elusive.

This is clearly the case should no solution be found to the standoff over the protocol. In that event, it is possible the trade and cooperation agreement (TCA), which underpins the bilateral relationship, will itself not be fully implemented – and that a running dispute and conceivably even a trade war may ensue.

Yet even should a mutually satisfactory deal be found, bilateral relations will remain unstable, as our new report implies. For one thing, several issues are scheduled to be revisited in the coming years. Fishing quotas will have to be renegotiated in 2026. On financial services, the UK has to decide whether to extend the temporary scheme that allows European Economic Area-based financial services to continue to enjoy their pre-Brexit passport rights and that is currently due to end at the end of 2023, while the EU must decide whether to renew its equivalence decision on UK clearing houses in June 2025. Changes in the rules of origin applied to trade in electric vehicles will come in in 2024 and 2027; and given the lack of domestic battery-making capacity on both sides, this might lead to an end to tariff-free trade in EVs. And, of course, the TCA itself is due to be reviewed from 2025.

Any of these discussions could prove explosive given the political and economic stakes. And even if bilateral negotiations go well, purely domestic action by either side might serve to rock the boat. The “level playing field” conditions included in the TCA were intended to ensure that workers’ rights and social and environmental protection are not reduced. Consequently, adoption of the retained EU law (revocation and reform) bill, currently making its way through parliament, might trigger trade sanctions from the EU were the removal of EU legislation to imply an impact on trade and investment.

A poster reading “no Irish Sea border” is seen at the port in Larne, Northern Ireland June 20, 2022.
‘The EU and UK are still at loggerheads over the Northern Ireland protocol’. Photograph: Clodagh Kilcoyne/Reuters

Equally, what the EU chooses to do will have implications over the Channel. Its carbon border adjustment mechanism – essentially a way of imposing a fee on carbon-intensive goods from countries with less stringent climate policies – implies that, should the UK fail to align with what the EU is proposing, UK exporters might be subject to levies – with the steel sector particularly vulnerable. And, lest we forget, divergence between UK and EU regulatory systems will impact on the Great Britain-Northern Ireland border, hindering the flow of goods.

And then there is the impact of the consequences of Brexit. Last year saw the debate about the economic impact of Brexit kick off in earnest as we began to get real-world empirical data to compare to the economic forecasts. A growing proportion of the electorate are coming to believe that Brexit is having a harmful effect on the UK economy. There is no shortage of voices calling for amendments to the current status quo.

For some, this is taking the form of demands to mitigate some of the deleterious impacts of the current deal. Researchers in both the UK and EU have voiced their concerns about EU foot-dragging on UK participation in the Horizon research programme. It is conceivable, too, that the UK may reconsider its decision to leave the EU’s “list of travellers” scheme, thereby making it easier for school trips from EU states to visit.

At the same time, polling indicates growing support for rejoining the EU. The Brexit debate will remain live within the UK and the signs are that pressure will not abate for a relationship with the EU going beyond the TCA – and potentially implying single market membership or even a future membership application.

In short, we are not – and with apologies to David Cameron – about to stop banging on about Europe. Discussing his country’s relationship with the US, former Canadian prime minister Pierre Trudeau reflected that “Living next to you is in some ways like sleeping with an elephant. No matter how friendly and even-tempered is the beast, if I can call it that, one is affected by every twitch and grunt”.

The EU is clearly not the US. Yet its economic influence is significant and it remains the UK’s largest trading partner. Whether it be the bilateral relationship itself, or the implications of what the two sides decide to do at home for that relationship, Europe will loom large in our political debate for the foreseeable future. The elephant’s twitches and grunts will continue to disturb us.

  • Anand Menon is director of The UK in a Changing Europe and professor of European politics and foreign affairs at King’s College London


Anand Menon

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
A Brexit trade war with the EU could backfire on Boris Johnson | Polly Toynbee
Stoking animosity with Europe has been a winner for the PM. But this time, it could work to Labour’s advantage, says Guardian columnist Polly Toynbee

Polly Toynbee

11, Nov, 2021 @4:07 PM

Article image
This Brexit bill finally buries the Conservative party of law and order | Martin Kettle
Breaking international law is a jaw-dropping move, says Guardian columnist Martin Kettle

Martin Kettle

09, Sep, 2020 @4:04 PM

Article image
Who says Britain can't negotiate a Brexit deal? We've got Frosty the No Man | Marina Hyde
Setting ourselves up as the country you really can’t trust seems an eccentric way of dealmaking, says Guardian columnist Marina Hyde

Marina Hyde

08, Sep, 2020 @1:57 PM

Article image
Our European neighbours now look at post-Brexit Britain and say simply: nein, danke | Jonathan Freedland
From political dysfunction to economic turmoil, the evidence of Brexit as a great problem-creator is all around, says Guardian columnist Jonathan Freedland

Jonathan Freedland

13, Jan, 2023 @3:44 PM

Article image
For the DUP, the border question is raw identity politics | Graham Gudgin
The British government must have been aware of the DUP red lines around an Irish border as its raison d’etre is to keep the UK together, writes former special adviser to the first minister of Northern Ireland Graham Gudgin

Graham Gudgin

07, Dec, 2017 @10:49 AM

Article image
If Johnson adds a customs union, remainers should finally accept his deal | Simon Jenkins
Such a concession would allow all sides to honour the political objective of Brexit and end uncertainty, says Guardian columnist Simon Jenkins

Simon Jenkins

21, Oct, 2019 @12:02 PM

Article image
Scrapping the NI protocol is just the start. Johnson’s trade wars are Trumpism in action | Simon Jenkins
Brexit has left Britain out on a limb. Yet the PM seems hellbent on alienating our trading partners to boost his own position, says Guardian columnist Simon Jenkins

Simon Jenkins

28, Jun, 2022 @9:26 AM

Article image
The Irish border problem is the ultimate barrier to hard Brexit | Simon Jenkins
Any sort of border in Ireland, whether physical or regulatory, is politically impossible and publicly unpopular. That’s bad news for hard Brexiteers, writes Simon Jenkins

Simon Jenkins

24, Nov, 2017 @10:41 AM

Article image
For Northern Irish farmers, no-deal Brexit would be a calamity | Ivor Ferguson
Without an exit deal with the EU, the whole NI agricultural industry will be destroyed, says president of the Ulster Farmers’ Union Ivor Ferguson

Ivor Ferguson

18, Mar, 2019 @2:02 PM

Article image
Brexiters are waking up to the damage they've done | Polly Toynbee
From horse racing to fishing to road haulage, British industry is in chaos. No wonder leavers are turning on each other, says Guardian columnist Polly Toynbee

Polly Toynbee

18, Jan, 2021 @4:46 PM