The ‘virgin speculum’: proof that medicine is still rife with outrageous myths about women | Jenny Halpern Prince

No wonder fewer British women are attending cervical screenings when some in the medical profession have such outdated views

An invitation to a cervical screening test upon your 25th birthday has become a necessary but often unwanted coming-of-age present. Despite years of education and advocacy from the Lady Garden Foundation and others about the benefits of screening, many women still do not attend. About 16 million women in the UK aged 25-64 are eligible for testing, but only 11.2 million took a test in 2022, the lowest level in a decade.

There unfortunately remains a false narrative that there are good reasons to be nervous about cervical screening tests. In reality, the test is not physically painful for the vast majority of women, although it can be a bit uncomfortable. However, the test can be needlessly emotionally painful, and for no good reason. This is in part because some women go through the experience of sitting with legs spread apart and “private parts” out, and then hear the nurse call for “the virgin speculum” to be used.

This is the archaic and unnecessarily sexualised term for the extra-small speculum. It should have no place being used in 2023, and it clearly creates feelings of vulnerability.

The Lady Garden Foundation, a charity that I co-founded and chair, is calling for this instrument to be renamed the “extra-small speculum” or at least its medical term, the Pederson speculum; the term virgin speculum should be removed from use by medical device advertisers and the medical profession (it is currently taught in medical schools).

This horrific term came into play in the 1800s, an age when misogyny was rife, yet is still present at the height of feminist achievement in 2023. All women, including me, are reliant on medical professionals to make us feel safe and to spot anything abnormal, yet the blatant labelling of sexual status makes us feel like the medical profession and industry are not in line with contemporary culture.

Our campaign to end the use of the term virgin speculum follows Vice UK’s finding that some British women are being denied proper healthcare because they are virgins. In some cases people were denied scans or probes in the interest of “preserving” their virginity. Dr Ranee Thakar, president of the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists, told the outlet that “healthcare professionals must not perpetuate harmful myths regarding ‘virginity’ when talking to women about their sexual and reproductive health care”.

Yet it feels that women being confronted by the virgin speculum plays right into this. Moreover, with the passing of the Health and Care Act, “virginity testing” is banned, and can lead to a five-year custodial sentence for anyone convicted of carrying out the practice. Therefore we look forward to the prospect of seeing any mention of virginity removed across the whole NHS.

Next week it is Cervical Cancer Awareness week, and we hope to shine a light on barriers to cervical screening testing that must be removed. This is especially true as a significant number of cervical cancer symptoms may go unnoticed, including bleeding from the vagina at times other than when you are having your period, unpleasant-smelling vaginal discharge and pain during sex. It is terrifying that fewer women are being screened than a decade ago, and we must reverse this trend.

By creating feelings of vulnerability around testing, we are allowing cervical cancer to continue to go undetected. All women should be aware of the importance of attending their cervical screening test and do so with confidence, regardless of their sexual status. This will play a valuable role in reducing the mortality rate.

Fundamentally, virginity is a social construct with no biological reality. Many medical associations already recognise this. It is time the rest of the medical profession and advertisers caught up. The small change of name to the extra-small speculum will have huge effects on eliminating psychological anxiety around cervical screening tests, just as we have reduced concerns over physical pain.

  • Jenny Halpern Prince is a co-founder of the Lady Garden Foundation

  • Do you have an opinion on the issues raised in this article? If you would like to submit a response of up to 300 words by email to be considered for publication in our letters section, please click here.


Jenny Halpern Prince

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
If young women are dying of shame about their bodies, we need a rethink | Suzanne Moore
The ramped-up expectations of porn are reversing the gains of 1970s feminism, says the Guardian columnist Suzanne Moore

Suzanne Moore

27, Jan, 2019 @6:36 PM

Article image
Women in England with advanced cervical cancer to be offered new treatment
Immunotherapy drug will be available for incurable forms of disease on NHS after approval

Andrew Gregory Health editor

29, Mar, 2023 @5:00 AM

Article image
HPV vaccine after removal of precancerous cells may cut cervical cancer risk
Study finds reduced risk of cervical cancer recurring after HPV vaccination post-surgery, though further research is needed

Denis Campbell Health policy editor

03, Aug, 2022 @10:30 PM

Article image
Cervical cancer: minority ethnic women more likely to miss screenings in pandemic
Study by Jo’s Cervical Cancer Trust finds almost 40% feel unsafe visiting surgeries

Tobi Thomas

25, Aug, 2020 @12:47 PM

Article image
Proportion of women in England not screened for cervical cancer at 10-year high
NHS England data show 4.6m or so women still unscreened or behind with tests, for disease diagnosed in 3,200 annually in UK

Anna Bawden

23, Jan, 2023 @6:00 AM

Article image
How to redesign the vaginal speculum
The number of women going for cervical tests is at its lowest in 19 years. An all-women team at the US design firm behind early Apple computers hopes that replacing the 19th-century metal tool with their silicone model will help change that

Rose George

23, Apr, 2018 @4:23 PM

Article image
If we don’t stop smearing smear tests, women will die of embarrassment
Women continue to receive negative messages about this simple, benevolent test – and that could mean thousands of lives lost unnecessarily

Chitra Ramaswamy

21, Jan, 2019 @5:05 PM

Article image
HPV vaccine recipients may only need one smear test in their lives, expert says
Change in screening programme could come as result of dramatic reductions in cervical cancer

Guardian staff and agencies

02, Mar, 2022 @9:08 AM

Article image
Campaign aims to boost cervical screening rates in England
About 30% of eligible people are not adequately screened against second most common cancer in women under 35

Nicola Davis Science correspondent

14, Feb, 2022 @12:01 AM

Article image
So, women aren’t doing enough ‘vigorous’ exercise? One more telling-off we can do without
According to a new report, we need to go to the gym more. But that ignores the exertions of everyday life

Alex Clark

31, Jul, 2022 @10:00 AM